Red Dead Redemption 2

Red Dead Redemption 2

查看统计:
Pcnuttie 2020 年 1 月 21 日 上午 9:17
Anyone notice the brothel isn't accurate in the Wild West?
Seems like you can take a bath and get an massage lol I really thought they were gonna be accurate with the Wild West history here but nope. Not even a bank to deposit or rob either like they do in the wild west. I guess they learned their lesson from GTA V or they lazy? Not that I care but I just noticed a few flaws in the wild west they developed. What do you guys think? lol. Not trying to be a pervert or anything here but we wouldn't wanna promote kids to this kind of lewd behavior in PC gaming ROFL! I noticed they fail to add Railroad jobs too. Glad they don't add slaves because that would be 100% racist! At least we can do an better open world game than this. This is too much like a GTA V rip off. At least they are announcing GTA 6 in Feb from what I heard. There needs to be some history accuracy here for some reason but I guess Rockstar doesn't do that at all. No wonder Assassin Creed games have much history accuracy.
最后由 Pcnuttie 编辑于; 2020 年 1 月 21 日 上午 9:20
< >
正在显示第 16 - 27 条,共 27 条留言
TreeTrunk 2020 年 1 月 21 日 下午 6:14 
引用自 Yautja Man
They avoid mentioning slavery and the civil war a lot so much that its cringe. They couldn't even jump into the topic of forced migration of the natives that much only glance over it.
I know man. Indians should be fully in the game. raiding settlements, killing and enslaving each other, learning to ride horses from the Europeans, trading for pelts and whiskey.

Then implement a free roam where an entire town gets attacked and people ban together or else your family (including children) lose their top knots.

No sugar coating. Fierce indians the way they actually were, not the way we think of them to shame America.
Shady Knights 2020 年 1 月 21 日 下午 9:21 
引用自 Kimurion
引用自 Shady Knights
How about playing some games made by Rockstar that have hookers in them? Hang on....who makes this game again?

There are hookers in the game though, you just can't interact with them as you can in other Rockstar Games. You reckon those fine ladies in Dutches camp aren't earning their keep in Vallantine simply by swindling the locals in that saloon...

It is a historical fact, it is in the game, but as a player, you are denied exploring this yourself. At best you get a soapy bath.

Arthur may not endorse it, but for online really no reason why it shouldn't be there for dishonorable characters.

It is not a game made for children, it has adult themes....so why not?

Those ladies in Dutch's camp mostly do work around the camp ( like laundry, helping Pearson with the meals and all that ), hence why they always complain they're bored. The only times they earn money for camp are when they go with someone to help them on robbery jobs. So no, they're not hookers. The game never hint at that so there's no reasons to believe they are. But we do see them being thieves and claiming they're good thieves, and hear Arthur tell stories about how they're good at that. And if you meant that mission in Valentine in particular then I don't see how you went to the conclusion they were hooking when they clearly tell us they were fooling guys to rob them.... ( Karen even got beaten because the guy she was robbing realized he wasn't going to get some ) And, like, they keep telling you they're thieves. Seems you're too biased and want to see the girls at camp being hookers too much.
And I never said there was no hookers in the game. I said you can't go with them, not that there are none. And because it's an adult game doesn't mean it HAS to have hookers in it with whom you can have sex. What, does every game developed have to have sex scenes now, just because it's for the "adults"? Getting laid isn't the point of rdr2, and it wasn't in character for the protagonist, so they didn't include it. Yes historically hookers existed in1900s, they weren't "invented" yesterday, but if it wasn't going with the way the devs wanted the game to be, they didn't include it, they didn't have to include absolutly everything and it's ridiculous to expect a game to just include everything you can do in real life.
I swear you guys just want to nitpick and complain about anything you can complain about. The game is great and has a lot of things to do. Enjoy as it is.

Your interpretation of the camp girls and how they work is different than mine.

Karen was bashed in a hotel room that she had propositioned her mark to take her too. Her goal was to rob him. He was a mean bastard that bashed her. Was it because she wouldn't put out or was it because he wanted to do anything with her cause he paid.

Either way, seems like the best time to rob a bloke to me would be when he is asleep. I was lead to believe that was the idea behind it.

I thought the men following along (sitting outside) knew exactly what the girls were up to on there. All contributing to the camp funds one way or another.

It is open for interpretation, but to me it is a good fit with the way the gang works.

Dunno what your hang up on this is. Not seeking X rated stuff. A soapy bubble bath seems to be the only thing in the game and you can't even take a swing of the drink in front of you, and this option is removed online.

Where does ones posse go to blow off some steam?

Yep, they can't put everything into a game, but if you were writing down themes for Western settings, this type of scenario would be commonly surfaced. Seems like a misstep not to explore it more.

The Mogician 2020 年 1 月 21 日 下午 10:29 
Maybe go play one of those Japanese porno games out there, it seems like you are thirsty.
Pipsqueek 2020 年 1 月 21 日 下午 11:27 
where does it say they are announces gta6 february?
stecph 2020 年 1 月 22 日 上午 1:27 
2 things about this bizarre post:

1) since when is porn a waste of time??

2) how would slavery in the game be racist?
CunkFeatures 2020 年 1 月 22 日 上午 3:36 
引用自 pcnuttie
Seems like you can take a bath and get an massage lol I really thought they were gonna be accurate with the Wild West history here but nope.

You know much of the "Wild West" is fictional right?
The Mogician 2020 年 1 月 22 日 上午 3:59 
引用自 tomtalk24
引用自 pcnuttie
Seems like you can take a bath and get an massage lol I really thought they were gonna be accurate with the Wild West history here but nope.

You know much of the "Wild West" is fictional right?
Wild west for people like these means robbing and killing everybody in sight. Even famous outlaws like Billy the Kid didn't do that. They are obviously twisting the words "wild west" to their own ends.
CunkFeatures 2020 年 1 月 22 日 上午 4:07 
引用自 The Mogician
They are obviously twisting the words "wild west" to their own ends.
Indeed, especially when the term "Wild West" was first used by English poet/novelist Charlotte Brontë.
Uryon 2020 年 1 月 22 日 上午 6:46 
@Shady Knights: sorry mate but I refuse to discuss further with someone going by the logic "all women are ♥♥♥♥♥♥". Blocked you.

引用自 The Mogician
Wild west for people like these means robbing and killing everybody in sight. Even famous outlaws like Billy the Kid didn't do that. They are obviously twisting the words "wild west" to their own ends.

Yeah seems no one has the same definition of wild west. Which is why so much ♥♥♥♥♥ about the wild west not being represented correctly in this game. Anyway you can't reason with these people. You can't reason with anyone on the internet, generally. Better let them rant among other kids in the kid corner ( because the way OP talks shows clearly his age )
最后由 Uryon 编辑于; 2020 年 1 月 22 日 上午 6:49
Shady Knights 2020 年 1 月 22 日 下午 12:45 
引用自 Kimurion
@Shady Knights: sorry mate but I refuse to discuss further with someone going by the logic "all women are ♥♥♥♥♥♥". Blocked you.

引用自 The Mogician
Wild west for people like these means robbing and killing everybody in sight. Even famous outlaws like Billy the Kid didn't do that. They are obviously twisting the words "wild west" to their own ends.

Yeah seems no one has the same definition of wild west. Which is why so much ♥♥♥♥♥ about the wild west not being represented correctly in this game. Anyway you can't reason with these people. You can't reason with anyone on the internet, generally. Better let them rant among other kids in the kid corner ( because the way OP talks shows clearly his age )

Never said that at all, nor was that my logic. Do you know how quotation quotes work? That"s your words not mine.

I provided an alternative viewpoint on the story mode as it was presented to me and reasons why I thought that.

Don't know why you'd take what I said personally.


最后由 Shady Knights 编辑于; 2020 年 1 月 22 日 下午 1:16
Dr. Peeper 2020 年 1 月 22 日 下午 1:16 
This is LATE wild west. Very LATE. Heck, if you were born during this game you very well could have fought in WW1. For reference, the first telephone switchboard was used a dozen years before this game's timeline.
Shady Knights 2020 年 1 月 22 日 下午 1:47 
引用自 Dr. Peeper
This is LATE wild west. Very LATE. Heck, if you were born during this game you very well could have fought in WW1. For reference, the first telephone switchboard was used a dozen years before this game's timeline.

https://www.google.com.au/amp/s/www.nytimes.com/2016/11/26/opinion/sunday/the-saloon-americas-forgotten-democratic-institution.amp.html

Interesting reading....

"By 1897 there were roughly a quarter of a million saloons, or 23 for every Starbucks franchise today."

"Women, not surprisingly, avoided the bar save for prostitutes and some very tough barmaids."

These places weren't for polite society. From a historical aspect, the saloons, and business conducted within seems very sanitised in game V's history.

I think the point of the OP, that the game seems to have passed over some key themes of the time the game is set is correct.

Would have been far more interesting to explore these.

Inversely, the church is closed off too. I haven't played through the story all the way yet, but have disappointed so far that I couldn't interact with the Church either.






< >
正在显示第 16 - 27 条,共 27 条留言
每页显示数: 1530 50

发帖日期: 2020 年 1 月 21 日 上午 9:17
回复数: 27