Red Dead Redemption 2

Red Dead Redemption 2

View Stats:
Jericho Feb 22, 2022 @ 6:23pm
The Eugenics Supporter... (R* getting political)
Why am I not surprised? This guy is exceptional. You can kill him in broad daylight with lowest possible honor right next to a cop (like I did) and nobody will even get upset with you. All that happened was I got 'wanted' but it was a warning and the cop just wanted me to 'move along' so I left the area for a moment, came back and looted the guy's body. Nothing. Nobody cared about that either. I didn't even get wanted right away. I ran around the corner as soon as I killed him and then came back after 10 seconds once I realized nobody cared. Then the cop noticed me next to the body and all he wanted me to do was "move along."

I just think this is a bit shallow. R* is basically saying with this NPC that it's okay to kill someone if they have an unpopular opinion. I might not agree with what he's saying, but that shouldn't make the fact that I killed him okay.
< >
Showing 1-15 of 119 comments
I kinda agree but it might just be a bug
Jericho Feb 23, 2022 @ 4:15am 
Originally posted by fgndfknjgnkjdfgjkjndgfn:
I kinda agree but it might just be a bug
Nah, it's totally by design.
RageMojo Feb 23, 2022 @ 6:37am 
So this is the conclusion you come too? You are putting your own filthy tainted spin on it my man.
Jericho Feb 23, 2022 @ 7:17am 
Originally posted by RageMojo:
So this is the conclusion you come too? You are putting your own filthy tainted spin on it my man.
How? It's exactly as how it seems. You can get away with killing this man in Saint Denis because R* is trying to humor the idea that it's okay to kill a racist because their opinion is disagreeable.
JuiceWSA Feb 23, 2022 @ 8:05am 
You also get + Honor for wiping out crowds of Klu Klux Klan, but you know...
I'm OK with that.

I must have some contemporaries at R* who have wanted to kill a bunch of those sheet-wearin'-freaks our whole lives - and now we get to do it.

Right on, R*.

I didn't kill the St. Denis Freak - 'cause he wasn't wearing his uniform (his bedsheet - he probably has a clean one just for the occasion) and was standing in St. Denis, but I did speak harshly to him and he ran off.
Last edited by JuiceWSA; Feb 23, 2022 @ 8:07am
Jericho Feb 23, 2022 @ 8:31am 
Originally posted by JuiceWSA:
You also get + Honor for wiping out crowds of Klu Klux Klan, but you know...
I'm OK with that.

I must have some contemporaries at R* who have wanted to kill a bunch of those sheet-wearin'-freaks our whole lives - and now we get to do it.

Right on, R*.

I didn't kill the St. Denis Freak - 'cause he wasn't wearing his uniform (his bedsheet - he probably has a clean one just for the occasion) and was standing in St. Denis, but I did speak harshly to him and he ran off.
The Eugenics Supporter isn't a member of the klan. He's just a generic racist.
Spooky Feb 23, 2022 @ 11:11am 
Originally posted by Jericho:
Originally posted by RageMojo:
So this is the conclusion you come too? You are putting your own filthy tainted spin on it my man.
How? It's exactly as how it seems. You can get away with killing this man in Saint Denis because R* is trying to humor the idea that it's okay to kill a racist because their opinion is disagreeable.
Bro being racist is a bit more than just a disagreeable opinion.
Depaskala Feb 23, 2022 @ 11:21am 
Yes yes. I also hate all these political ww2 games that depict nazis as the bad guys. Political correctness gone mad, I tell you.
onanonehand8 Feb 23, 2022 @ 12:40pm 
So, don't kill him if that is a bother to you. Me, screw that guy.
Droppin Jabronis Feb 23, 2022 @ 1:41pm 
Imagine getting upset about killing some ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ racist in a video game
Chill out - he isn't saying he agrees with eugenics. He is clearly saying that R* are being shallow for giving you high honour to kill someone for having a contemporary attitude. Back then racism was rife, so it is strange that the Police wouldn't respond at all. Get off your high horses.
Scott Memelord Feb 23, 2022 @ 2:12pm 
Originally posted by PepperedSteakSlice29:
Chill out - he isn't saying he agrees with eugenics. He is clearly saying that R* are being shallow for giving you high honour to kill someone for having a contemporary attitude. Back then racism was rife, so it is strange that the Police wouldn't respond at all. Get off your high horses.
Yeah, I'd argue it's pretty immersion breaking.

Hell, there's literally a ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ random event in St. Denis where you have the option to save a black guy from getting his ass beat by one of the cops. So it's really weird that they seemingly don't care.

I don't mind it giving you good honor. I just find it bizarre that the cops don't respond either.

Like if you save the black guy you get good honor but still get a wanted level.
Last edited by Scott Memelord; Feb 23, 2022 @ 2:17pm
RageMojo Feb 23, 2022 @ 2:41pm 
Originally posted by Jericho:
Originally posted by RageMojo:
So this is the conclusion you come too? You are putting your own filthy tainted spin on it my man.
How? It's exactly as how it seems. You can get away with killing this man in Saint Denis because R* is trying to humor the idea that it's okay to kill a racist because their opinion is disagreeable.

Why is it ok to kill the Klan but not this fool?
Jericho Feb 23, 2022 @ 3:37pm 
Originally posted by Spooky:
Originally posted by Jericho:
How? It's exactly as how it seems. You can get away with killing this man in Saint Denis because R* is trying to humor the idea that it's okay to kill a racist because their opinion is disagreeable.
Bro being racist is a bit more than just a disagreeable opinion.
Not really in the fashion that he's doing it. He's not limiting anyone from doing anything. He's just basically being a white supremacist.
Jericho Feb 23, 2022 @ 3:38pm 
Originally posted by RageMojo:
Originally posted by Jericho:
How? It's exactly as how it seems. You can get away with killing this man in Saint Denis because R* is trying to humor the idea that it's okay to kill a racist because their opinion is disagreeable.

Why is it ok to kill the Klan but not this fool?
Because the Klan is actively trying to hurt people, at least in some instances. It's okay to kill them for the same reason it's okay to kill a Lemoyne Raider or a Del Lobo.
< >
Showing 1-15 of 119 comments
Per page: 1530 50

Date Posted: Feb 22, 2022 @ 6:23pm
Posts: 119