Why Arthur Morgan is killing American Soldiers?

[gatto_nero]

He is psychopath? Cowboy best Indian friend? R* WTF?

[Saint Graz]

its all part of the plan you got to have faith

[GhostyOsty]

Didn't intend to, apart of Dutchs plan and was trying to protect the Indians as Dutch was Minipulating them for an escape.

[Cpl. Burden R 3294]

More importantly, why are the US Soldiers armed with Winchester Rifles and not Krag-Jorgenssens like they should be for the time period? ;)

[Grizz]

Because he's an outlaw.

[AC Denton]

1) He's not a cowboy.
2) Well, yes. If you followed the story, they are friendly with the natives and trying to protect them.
3) If you followed the story you'd also know they have no love or appreciation of the government and it's men.
4) They're soldiers. It's their job to be in combat. If they're not okay with being shot at then they picked the wrong job.

[Charley Pepper]

A renegade.

[Cpl. Burden R 3294]

Originally posted by gatto_nero:

You suggest there were cowboys that killed American troops with indians?

Originally posted by ac_denton:

1) He's not a cowboy.

Also. It's a *game*. These things don't reflect reality one on one.

However if you want an example of an outlaw that fired at US Soldiers, around this time period, a certain gentleman by the name of Pancho Villa.

Small thing perhaps but, why do you not have a mouse next to your name, and your profile doesn't show RDR2 as a played game?

[IvantheFormidable]

Originally posted by gatto_nero:

You suggest there were cowboys that killed American troops with indians?

If you're using "cowboys" to mean "outlaws" (which you are), then yeah, there probably were some that fought American troops.

[Mr. Ayak]

He's not a cowboy. He's an outlaw. Also cowboys didn't kill indians, they worked with cattle and horses. Use your brain buddy.

[Twitchey]

Selective outrage much.

[Wabbajack]

Originally posted by gatto_nero:

Originally posted by Sauide:

The indians are the native people of the USA they got killed by the people from europe (the citizens of the usa today). Sometimes its good to put down the rainbow glasses and look at history as it was.

You suggest there were cowboys that killed American troops with indians?

The game was inspired by late western American. The word inspired implied that R* use the same settings and they doesn't need to keep it 100% history accurate, and I'm glad that Arthur kills those soldiers. Why? Because those soldiers are horrible person not like the one Arthur saved.

[gatto_nero]

Originally posted by Cpl. Burden R 3294:

More importantly, why are the US Soldiers armed with Winchester Rifles and not Krag-Jorgenssens like they should be for the time period? ;)

Because they are time travelers... I mean outlaw? Big Indian lovers. Enemy of the good American solder!

Just give me gps location of grave of this scumbag Arthur Morgan I want to pee there.

[gatto_nero]

Originally posted by Cpl. Burden R 3294:

Originally posted by gatto_nero:

You suggest there were cowboys that killed American troops with indians?

Originally posted by ac_denton:

1) He's not a cowboy.

Also. It's a *game*. These things don't reflect reality one on one.

However if you want an example of an outlaw that fired at US Soldiers, around this time period, a certain gentleman by the name of Pancho Villa.

Small thing perhaps but, why do you not have a mouse next to your name, and your profile doesn't show RDR2 as a played game?

Francisco "Pancho" Villa was a Mexican revolutionary general and one of the most prominent figures of the Mexican Revolution. As commander of the División del Norte, 'Division of the North', in the Constitutionalist Army, he was a military-landowner of the northern Mexican state of Chihuahua.

[gatto_nero]

Is Arthur Morgan Mexican?

[GhostyOsty]

Originally posted by Wabbajack:

Originally posted by gatto_nero:

You suggest there were cowboys that killed American troops with indians?

The game was inspired by late western American. The word inspired implied that R* use the same settings and they doesn't need to keep it 100% history accurate, and I'm glad that Arthur kills those soldiers. Why? Because those soldiers are horrible person not like the one Arthur saved.

You're talking about a Rockstar game mind you.