What if Hosea...

[HerculeHolmes]

Unmarked Spoilers Below.

What if Hosea had survived the bank robbery in Saint Denis?

Either Milton's gun jammed at the last second and he somehow escaped, or his gunshot wound turned out to be non-fatal and he was broken out of the Saint Denis Jail by Sadie and Charles.

How do you think the rest of the story might have developed with Hosea still around?

[GhostyOsty]

He could have turned himself in, and in attempt for Dutch to go with the plan and let everyone go. In all, Micah could've lost his chess match.

[Khorne Flakes]

One of two scenarios play out in my mind(assuming Hosea and most of the gang made it back to camp).
1) Dutch continues to ignore the protests of Hosea and no doubt other members of the gang. No matter what though, I can't imagine they'll be remaining in Saint Denis any longer with Hosea's protests. Instead they'll flee north into the wilderness and camp out where they normally would at near the end of the game. At some point I Imagine Dutch will try to enact vengeance upon Leviticus Cornwall for hiring the Pinkertons like in the original game. I imagine after killing him, Hosea will have had enough of Dutch's contradictory BS and tries to leave with Arthur, Charles, Uncle, John and the girls + Jack... It's anyone's guess if maddened Dutch and Micah bring things to a gunfight. Bill will probably side with Dutch, not sure about Javier.
If they make it out alive, they'll probably give up the nomadic lifestyle and settle somewhere out west in New Austin, maybe even on MacFarlane's Ranch. With Dutch either dead or still out east, they won't have to worry about the Pinkertons(atleast for a while). Since all of this takes place without going to Guarma, Arthur has plenty of time to recover from his sickness.

2) Dutch either finally listens to Hosea or the rest of the gang agree that staying east now is far too risky. They immediately pack up and sneak in the dead of night past Blackwater and to New Austin, where they'll probably stay low for a few months, somewhere between in between Tumbleweed and Armadillo. It's likely Dutch and other members of the gang will find opportunities to try and rob both towns. No doubt this will draw the Pinkertons to their location(though the rat probably was feeding them info too), at which point they'll flee either further west or go to Mexico.
Again, I can see Arthur surviving in this scenario as well. Regardless of how active things get, I can't imagine Hosea will tolerate Arthur doing much outside the camp in his sickened state.

[in]

They were done anyway. Best case he would've ended up living with John like Uncle. Or still dead like Grimshaw.

[HilAroEye]

Diposting pertama kali oleh HerculeHolmes:

Unmarked Spoilers Below.

What if Hosea had survived the bank robbery in Saint Denis?

Either Milton's gun jammed at the last second and he somehow escaped, or his gunshot wound turned out to be non-fatal and he was broken out of the Saint Denis Jail by Sadie and Charles.

How do you think the rest of the story might have developed with Hosea still around?

Dude are you a YouTuber or something? LUL, I see you've made a bunch of threads where you ask people to make alterations to the story of singleplayer

Here's my guess, if Hosea lived, Dutch wouldn't have lost his head and the gang would make it to Tahiti, or maybe the boat captain taking the gang to Tahiti would betray them and tell the pinkertons, or maybe they all would have died during some other robbery...many more things can happen

[n0mad23]

Hosea was all ready moving to some advanced terminal illness, so his time was pretty limited anyway.

[HerculeHolmes]

Diposting pertama kali oleh in:

They were done anyway. Best case he would've ended up living with John like Uncle. Or still dead like Grimshaw.

I misread this as Arthur living with John like Uncle.

"Arthur! Get up and do some work!"

"I can't! I got TB!"

[⚜︎Dmitry Light]

Hosea is dead. The end.

[HerculeHolmes]

Diposting pertama kali oleh ⚜︎Dmitry Light:

Hosea is dead. The end.

At least until Undead Nightmare.

[⚜︎Dmitry Light]

Diposting pertama kali oleh HerculeHolmes:

Diposting pertama kali oleh ⚜︎Dmitry Light:

Hosea is dead. The end.

At least until Undead Nightmare.

Undead Nightmare for RDR2 never will be.