Does anyone find collectables not making ANY warning sounds at all in RDR online?

[Elladonna]

like I've looked everywhere in the marked area, nothing.

[Erynar]

Well, sometimes collectibles don't make any sound and/or don't put off any glow like they're supposed to. However, if you don't yet have the skill that makes visible dig sites glow and make the collectible sound, then they're _supposed_ to not have any glow or sound. So, you may need to be looking for circular spots of disturbed earth where you get the option to dig. If you don't have a shovel yet, then you can't dig up those collectibles yet, but you're not supposed to be able to get any maps which require a shovel before you have the shovel.

And of course, if you have the metal detector, the spots that it detects aren't ever shown in any way shape or form other than with the metal detector. So, if the spot requires a metal detector, then you need to use your metal detector to find it. However, you're not supposed to be able to get any maps which require a metal detector until you have a metal detector, so if you don't have a metal detector yet, that can't be it.

[Erynar]

Also, this reddit thread says that it's a known issue that collector maps sometimes give wrong locations: https://www.reddit.com/r/RedDeadOnline/comments/ei4ke3/red_dead_online_bugs_issues_thread/

So, it could be that you're just missing it, or it could be a bug.