Red Dead Redemption 2

Red Dead Redemption 2

Ver estadísticas:
Jindrik 7 ENE 2020 a las 10:05 p. m.
Why is it so easy to lose honor?
Seriously? Like, cmon, self defense should not cost you honor... I mean cmon!
I know what you're thinking.. "Well the dude who attacked me had a good reason." or some other bs logic that doesn't make sense.. and to that my answer is no.

I was ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ hunting, while slowly getting closer to my target with the scope zoom in, not even seeing that there was a dude behind me, I shot my target (the animal, duh) and the dude behind me. "What's this? You trying to kill me?"
Bruh if I was trying to kill that dudes ass, I must be the worst killer ever since my shot literally the opposite of his direction!
Oh so you wanna use self defense? too bad you cant use guns, gotta use lasso and hogtie the ♥♥♥♥♥♥! Oh, so you thought it would the that easy? Just hogtie the dude and leave asap?
Would be a shame if 2 other dudes rode by right at the time you're hogtying the first guy, pumping you full of ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ bullets!

2 kills... and an accidental horse kill... I lost an entire lever of honor... GENIUS! ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ flawless design... if you gonna make people lose 20 or something honor per kill... then let there be an easier way to get 20 or more honor back rather than greeting everyone or hoping to god you'll get a few random encounters... Or, or... allow us to ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ self defend when they start shooting you for no reason!
< >
Mostrando 31-45 de 56 comentarios
=CJ= 9 ENE 2020 a las 12:15 a. m. 
Publicado originalmente por DXWarlock:
Wait, the guy never shot you? Just asked if you was shooting at him in an angry tone and you shot him?
Or that's the only thing I can think of that would cause you to lose honor, you killed first.
He may have shot at you first...granted.
But you HIT first.

How do you propose they decide who was the first attacker..if he missed? What mechanic would work to decide he was trying to hit you but failed? Game mechanics logic can only determine who actually did the first damage..he might be shooting a deer near you, or a bird, or just firing randomly (as far as the game knows).

What non exploitable logic could be put in place to decide if someone was shooting in your direction meant for it to hit you?

I think there's some confusion here judging by this reply and your other posts DXWarlock. The OP is talking about single player, not online, so the game clearly knows who the aggressor is - the AI in this case.
Jindrik 9 ENE 2020 a las 1:28 a. m. 
Publicado originalmente por Azrael:
I played through the full story and I never saw a random NPC go "Are you trying to kill me?!" and starting to shoot, if you haven't done something to provoke that.

You said, you had your gun out, cause you were hunting.
I assume you were looking back, when the NPC was talking and accidentally aimed with the gun at him.
NPC's (and If you think about also in RL Humans in general) don't take too kindly to people aiming with guns at them. In this game, atleast the Men shoot back, the ones that don't try to flee (although I found cowards to be pretty rare).
I honestly don't know about the female NPC's, since I never aimed at them in Single Player, if I didn't have to (since I was playing an honorable Arthur), I assume that most, if not all of the random female NPC's run away, as it would've been custom in the 19th/beginning 20th Century.
Characters like Sadie or Black Belle and such are a huge exception for the time, even more so, if you think about that Women got their right to vote in the US only in 1919.

These were very different times compared to today.

That's the thing, I didn't aim my gun, I didn't point it at him or provoke him, I just shot my gun right when he was behind me, and HE starts shooting me, while my back is still turned!
My goal, like I said 10 times by now, was the animal, I was hunting for an animal, scoped in, and shot. My first reaction after the shot, wasn't to look behind or anything, I went for the carcas, but before I even made 1 step forward, the dude was pumping me with bullets.
Just to make it 100% clear to everyone, I was not the first to fire at any of the targets. Unless you call my shot for the animal the first shot, then yes, in the whole situation, the first shot was made by me, at an animal. The first person out of all 4 targets to take damage, was me, in both cases.
I just wanna point it out again, I was scoped in/zoomed in, cause my target was quite far away!


Publicado originalmente por Kimchee:
Explain yourself to Mary Joe and Honey Boo whom you made early widows. And poor Mary Anne is taking care of her husbands rope marks as we speak cause you hog tied him like cattle. He may never recover his manhood after what you subjected him too.

Should we stop here or do we need to speak about ole Betsy the horse?

Guilty!

Go away, nobody likes you
Última edición por Jindrik; 9 ENE 2020 a las 1:33 a. m.
Azrael 9 ENE 2020 a las 2:10 a. m. 
Hmm, we clearly know that Rockstar implemented 3 NPC Types: The ones who react friendly, the ones who react indifferently and the ones who react unfriendly.

I don't know if they implemented ones that are somewhat mentally unstable and not meant to handle a gun, e.g. an NPC, that is "frightened" by a gunshot and then acts crazy.

My best guess is, to hunt in areas, where NPC's don't travel that often.
Since animals are also spooked by them, this is usually not too hard to follow.
Jindrik 9 ENE 2020 a las 4:03 a. m. 
It's not the first time it happened to me when I was hunting and some random dude just gets aggressive.
Altho the other times it did happen, it went something like this. I got bow and arrow, my target is a bird on a rock, I'm aiming at the bird, but the NPC is within my screen. I know you can argue and say "well you're aiming at the npc" and no, I'm aiming at a small bird, and the npc happens to be in the frame, but my bow isn't even close enough to aim at him, you could say that he is around 40-50 degree off the position of my aim.

And yeah it might seem as if I'm being hostile, but if what people say is true, about the "if npc fires first, then you lose no honor" then that's total bs, every time that happened, I always lost honor, so I just hogtie people and leave em. It's not like I'm deliberately trying to provoke the npc's in game, hell I don't need to try, all that I need to do is just let some random walk into me and they get hostile cause they can't ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ walk properly. But like cmon, if you make the npc's so easily offended, then allow people to not lose honor when it's self defense...

Damn just now I was going inside the saloon, and a dude walked into me (random encounter) I tried to defuse the situation, but I couldn't target him, because it kept targeting the people close to him or the poker people... so he just throws himself at me and starts punching me... I hit him back. In self defense, he hit me fist! HE walked into ME! Because it was a random encounter you know, there was this tiny animation thing. And I lose honor for beating him up? I didn't kill! Or anything, otherwise I would've gotten reported to the law.. But I didn't, no wanted, nothing... just lost honor. I was at cap honor (level 6 cause not far into the story yet) and I lost the level. It took me 4 or 5 I don't remember +honor pop ups, to get back to my cap (level 6)!! So let's say I lost 20 honor for beating him... that means, greeting people gives 4-5 honor! And you get it only after you greet what, 4-5 people? 1 self defense knock out, not kill just knock out = 20-25 times you being nice...
1 - 25?
(just so we clear, I don't quite know the honor number's that was all just an example!)

Yeah, yeah, it's easier to greet people blah, blah, blah, it's fast etc etc..
I don't mind that they become hostile or anything, it really does make the game feel more, realistic and such, but there should be a way to gain honor as fast as you lose it if it's so damn easy to lose honor! Because if you happen to get in a bar fight and the dude has 2 friends, that means you will lose a whole lot of honor in seconds, and it will take you anything from 5 to 10 min to get it all back...
Última edición por Jindrik; 9 ENE 2020 a las 4:05 a. m.
Azrael 9 ENE 2020 a las 5:22 a. m. 
Every 3 greeted people grants you an honor increase. I know that because I found it funny, after killing people, to "attone for my sins" by being ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ friendly to everyone xD

I guess the game interpreted you pushing a button to walk as you walking into the NPC, not the other way round and yeah, if you only beat people up, they don't die, if you wait long enough, you can see them stand up bruised and battered and trying to get away.

However, if you loot them while they're unconscious, it's Theft, so look out to not hold the E key with unconscious people around while in a saloon :D

In my experience, the small things are just this, small things.

Really help strangers e.g. when you see a woman or such asking for a ride because they broke their ankle or their horse died or free kidnapped people, these deeds grant you larger honor increases.

And I think you don't need to have maximum honor to get the good ending.
Afanickton 9 ENE 2020 a las 8:59 a. m. 
Jindrik im just being honest here, you keep continuing the fights. Instead of moving on and NOT FIGHTING you keep fighting. Why are you continuing hostile action and expecting different results from said action. Who cares if they are blaming you, you should know better lol
cerebus23 9 ENE 2020 a las 9:03 a. m. 
the npcs in this game are spastic pricks never interact with them never go near them never watch them or listen to them.

they are crack head psychos.

that ai needs to be toned down about 50 levels.
Jindrik 9 ENE 2020 a las 1:21 p. m. 
Publicado originalmente por Azrael:
Every 3 greeted people grants you an honor increase. I know that because I found it funny, after killing people, to "attone for my sins" by being ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ friendly to everyone xD

I guess the game interpreted you pushing a button to walk as you walking into the NPC, not the other way round and yeah, if you only beat people up, they don't die, if you wait long enough, you can see them stand up bruised and battered and trying to get away.

However, if you loot them while they're unconscious, it's Theft, so look out to not hold the E key with unconscious people around while in a saloon :D

In my experience, the small things are just this, small things.

Really help strangers e.g. when you see a woman or such asking for a ride because they broke their ankle or their horse died or free kidnapped people, these deeds grant you larger honor increases.

And I think you don't need to have maximum honor to get the good ending.

Thats the thing tho, you see, I didn't hold the W, because it was a mini cutscene, you know how when you do a certain action, like skinning or camp chores. you press it, then your character is locked in the animation, where you have no control over it. And it was the exact same thing there. Soon as arthur put his hand on the saloon door, I lost control over him, because I did see the guy drunkenly walk forward, and I was pressing left, but arthur kept going forward, so I stopped pressing the "go key" and he kept going by himself until the dude bumps into me.
And I know about the looting stuff, not only do you lose honor but you also get wanted if they spot and report you.


Publicado originalmente por Afanickton:
Jindrik im just being honest here, you keep continuing the fights. Instead of moving on and NOT FIGHTING you keep fighting. Why are you continuing hostile action and expecting different results from said action. Who cares if they are blaming you, you should know better lol

Okay, tell me how I can stop a bar fight, when a dude is first of all, blocking my path cause he is standing at the door, while throwing punches at me which makes your character stagger, on top of not being able to run because you're ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ indoors!!! So if you figure a way to stop a bar fight without knocking or getting knocked out please tell me, I'll make sure to use that.

The other examples I mentioned, isn't me losing honor, it's me giving other examples where similar ♥♥♥♥ happens, where the damn npc's get aggressive for no ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ reason, or because THEY, can't ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ walk properly and walk into me.. Tell me I'm wrong, tell me that you never, ever had a single npc totally be braindead, walk into you, and the start a fight with you!

There's so many time's that happened. And I assuming its a random encounter, think "oh shoot, I need to take the dude out before he kills me" But nope! It was a dumb npc pathing that doesn't seem to work half the time and you get the blame for it by losing honor, AND getting wanted. I reloaded so many times because of ♥♥♥♥ like this
Última edición por Jindrik; 9 ENE 2020 a las 1:26 p. m.
Insecure Chad 7 ABR 2020 a las 10:14 p. m. 
Publicado originalmente por Eminem:
Publicado originalmente por Jindrik:

Bruh, I'm not sure if you actually read my post?
I was hunting, and while I shot my target (THE ANIMAL) the dude was riding behind me.
And for some ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ dumb reason, he went "You trying to kill me?" and instantly starting to shoot me.
First thing I did was to ride away a bit, hoping he would ride away like most other NPC do.
He was persistent in following me. I didn't wanna ride too far from my animal carcas, so I decided to hogtie him. And in the middle of the animation, 2 other dudes rode by. However they didn't attack me instantly, but instead investigated. Since I was stuck in the damn hogtie animation, I couldn't defuse the situation.
They didn't get an answer, so they too started shooting me, while I was still in the middle of hogtying animation.
Not the first time, nor the second time was I attacking the npc's first, or even anything towards their side.
Not sure if you notice, but npc's are really, really, really ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ hostile sometimes. There has been numerous occasions where I just ride by them. And they pull out their guns yelling something at me. While I was just riding, I didn't interact with the person, I didn't even stop, I literally rode by him, because he was riding in a very slow trot?

I have no issues with some people being hostile, don't get me wrong, it's fun to see variety, but it's kinda stupid if ♥♥♥♥ like that happen and you lose honor because some npc's are trigger happy maniacs that shoot you as soon as they get any tiny reason to do so, be it that you were in their "personal space" for half an extra second or you hunting in their proximity

your story is changing everytime! Poor horse, innocent bystander

#fakenews
Contribute to the thread or just ♥♥♥♥ off....
4kGamer 8 ABR 2020 a las 1:03 a. m. 
Kidding right? Play the game there is more to RDO than hunting. Doing stranger Free-roam missions, turning in live bounties, Local trade deliveries. You can gain massive honor just by feeding and caring for your horse. This thread is retarded seriously man.
Azrael 8 ABR 2020 a las 2:31 a. m. 
Anyone got the Negative Honor Gain symbol as emote for necroing the thread?
Jindrik 8 ABR 2020 a las 10:44 a. m. 
Publicado originalmente por 4kGamer:
Kidding right? Play the game there is more to RDO than hunting. Doing stranger Free-roam missions, turning in live bounties, Local trade deliveries. You can gain massive honor just by feeding and caring for your horse. This thread is retarded seriously man.

Who said I was talking about online?
Maybe it's not an issue in online, but I'm talking about the story mode
Última edición por Jindrik; 8 ABR 2020 a las 10:46 a. m.
MoOoOo 8 ABR 2020 a las 3:43 p. m. 
The poster say "DEAD or alive",
I bring back 6 dead bad guys and I lost 20% of honor......WHAT?!
Última edición por MoOoOo; 8 ABR 2020 a las 3:44 p. m.
DXWarlock 8 ABR 2020 a las 5:34 p. m. 
It doesn't say same money or reputation for dead or alive. It just states requirements, not the outcome.

Are you implying a sheriff in old west that captures everyone and brings in them, vs one that kills them all, would have the same reputation in the community?
Última edición por DXWarlock; 8 ABR 2020 a las 5:34 p. m.
4kGamer 9 ABR 2020 a las 1:50 a. m. 
Publicado originalmente por Jindrik:
Publicado originalmente por 4kGamer:
Kidding right? Play the game there is more to RDO than hunting. Doing stranger Free-roam missions, turning in live bounties, Local trade deliveries. You can gain massive honor just by feeding and caring for your horse. This thread is retarded seriously man.

Who said I was talking about online?
Maybe it's not an issue in online, but I'm talking about the story mode

You didn't say you were talking about Story mode either.... way to be confusing bud.
< >
Mostrando 31-45 de 56 comentarios
Por página: 1530 50

Publicado el: 7 ENE 2020 a las 10:05 p. m.
Mensajes: 56