all horses sold with one click

[Firpo]

Wanted to sell one single horse and all stabled horses were gone instantly... why!? That happend the second time now I am a little bit upset.

[Eminem]

You got a previous save?

[Firpo]

I got a save yes but I did lot a of challenges the last few hours so... on the other hand now my horses are gone and they were fully trained and customized with love (white Arabian too)

:(

[DancesWithDeadThings]

This keeps happening to me too and its driving me insane. First time, I had been playing for 3 hours and stupidly hadnt saved so had to give up on several missions completed and lots of perfect pelts sold. Now I just went in to try to sell one stabled horse so I could stable a newly caught one, and it happened again. Just rapid fire sells all 3. What gives?

[Erynar]

I don't know that it will actually result in anything being fixed, but you might as well complain to Rockstar: https://support.rockstargames.com/categories

Worst case, they ignore you. Best case, they actually fix the problem. Either way, they should know about the issue (and they may or may not be aware of it already).

Personally, this specific issue aside, I'd suggest that you just get in the habit of manually saving on a regular basis. It makes it much easier to back up when you make mistakes, and it makes it so that bugs like this cost you less (though obviously, they shouldn't happen at all).

[markquinn2k4]

OK so I'm a year late to this thread but I figured it out for anyone who comes across this bug.

If you use the mouse to click the sell horses button, all the horses will be sold. Instead, use the actual button on the keyboard. For me it's the space button. I click the space button and it sells one horse at a time as it should. *Don't* use the mouse.

[Xantra]

Same happend with me :(

[Full Metal Bucket]

Same here, another piss poor ♥♥♥♥♥ port from console to PC, you would think a decent game developer would actually give a ♥♥♥♥ about pc players....
This game so far is amazing, just that little things like this keep making it a chore rather than a pleasure to play

[$2 Hero]

Originally posted by Full Metal Bucket:

Same here, another piss poor ♥♥♥♥♥ port from console to PC, you would think a decent game developer would actually give a ♥♥♥♥ about pc players....
This game so far is amazing, just that little things like this keep making it a chore rather than a pleasure to play

yep dude i got $1000 none of these problems persist on console. they get fixed or sony/ms up their ass

"you see sir whats great about PC is the vast and wonderful community who can bugfix/troubleshoot the game for us"

"well done jeffrey"

"yes sir we've trimmed the PC budget by $42,000 annually"

"WELL DONE JEFFREY!"

[Velvet]

Markquinn2k4<<<< had the answer I was needing. Thank you SO MUCH!
Note to self: do NOT use the MOUSE use the key on the keyboard (mines space bar) to sell ONE horse only. I was feeling pretty salty loosing my horses and having to find a save that still had them. FYI, even if you SAVE before you sell the horse, it is NOT a guarantee that they will all still be there. I've had to go back two three even four saves before I found a save that had them still at the stable. Hopefully now - I wont have that problem!

[angelsdavid1989]

I cannot sell a horse at all, least not in online mode, they just disappear and get vaporized into nothingness as if they never existed in the first place.

[⛧Perdurabo⛧]

Originally posted by angelsdavid1989:

I cannot sell a horse at all, least not in online mode, they just disappear and get vaporized into nothingness as if they never existed in the first place.

Yes: in the online world, you cannot sell horses.
No matther how much you payed for it, if you want to get rid of it, the only option is to discharge (might be misspelled) it.

But in the story mode you can sell horses, even the ones you tame in the wild.

[Uraniq]

Originally posted by markquinn2k4:

OK so I'm a year late to this thread but I figured it out for anyone who comes across this bug.

If you use the mouse to click the sell horses button, all the horses will be sold. Instead, use the actual button on the keyboard. For me it's the space button. I click the space button and it sells one horse at a time as it should. *Don't* use the mouse.

Thank you so much!!! Still works 2025, I just did it as you said and sold only one horse, I lost 3 horses and was going crazy,good job I had save! Thank you so much <3