Its Terrible Sadly

[Fast]

This is the type of game that with the right direction could have been amazing.

Instead we get some clunky stiff unimaginative basic survival gameplay with minimal effort, and terrible combat in a Dune skin.

This is the "oversold , under deliver" in a nutshell.

It could be great, if they develop it for another year or two, but no way in hell this turns out good if it launches in a few weeks time.

[Knight of Ni]

i am just glad, i had fun.

[Xarko]

Another post bro? You must really love the game.

[[Sec8] Kilo]

easily the most fun I have had in a game in years... and it was just the damn Beta...

[Big Fudge]

You played a beta - a mere razor-thin shaving of the full game. I encourage you to not judge a book by it's first paragraph.

[Big Fudge]

Originally posted by Sec8 Kilo:

easily the most fun I have had in a game in years... and it was just the damn Beta...

Same. Had an absolute blast. Can't wait to find a group of ppl to play with.

[Knight of Ni]

remember kids if you aren`t able to have your own opinion you will get nowhere in live.

[Wolf]

Combat and mouvement animations are terribles. PvP not exist like a deatmatch mode with instant respawn in restricted area.

[Æsir]

People making these posts amuse me. Sometimes I wonder if it’s one person who had been banned coming back to troll.

Like, what kind of discussion do you want to have here? You know you will get the opposite opinions, but are you open to hearing and accepting them or are you just here to take a piss?

[Dark_Mage09]

Originally posted by Fast:

Survival mechanics are limited and basic, blood(water)/sun....thats it...wow.

And Minecraft, the "Best game ever made" has health and food. That's it...wow. What's your point?

[Fast]

Originally posted by Dark_Mage09:

Originally posted by Fast:

Survival mechanics are limited and basic, blood(water)/sun....thats it...wow.

And Minecraft, the "Best game ever made" has health and food. That's it...wow. What's your point?

Did you genuinely just compare this game to minecraft?

Minecraft is a different beast that you clearly do not understand whatsoever, if you think this is in the same universe in terms of comparison.

Minecraft is so good because it does everything it aims to do almost perfectly. It is a representation of doing the things that matter in respect to the games premise and focus in a perfect manner. Minecraft is first and foremost a creative sandbox with survival elements, and a depthy crafting system.
Minecraft developers know their target audience and have somewhat perfected their design and the general quality of their updates in a way the directly resonates with its audience.

The culmination of all the important facets that make minecraft are what make it so good and popular. Not one single mechanic or system.

This game barely does the things it focuses on, in a passable state never mind good.

This straight up made me laugh.

[alan0n]

I'm about to make a lot of people mad.

Minecraft is not even mid, its bad.

The combat is jank, the animations are terrible, the UI is hideous, the game play is generic, the crafting is unintuitive, and the graphics... are total dog water.

The ONLY thing that made minecraft great was it was the first unlimited sandbox that broke open the market.

Objectively, as a game... it was middling if you want to be generous and not good if you want to be objective.

The people and the community that the sandbox attracted made that franchise, the quality of the game itself had little to do with it.

[Dark_Mage09]

Originally posted by alan0n:

I'm about to make a lot of people mad.

Minecraft is not even mid, its bad.

The combat is jank, the animations are terrible, the UI is hideous, the game play is generic, the crafting is unintuitive, and the graphics... are total dog water.

The ONLY thing that made minecraft great was it was the first unlimited sandbox that broke open the market.

Objectively, as a game... it was middling if you want to be generous and not good if you want to be objective.

The people and the community that the sandbox attracted made that franchise, the quality of the game itself had little to do with it.

Exactly what I meant. I merely meant to point out that one game can get away with stuff like that but if it's not Minecraft, nooo, everyone complains about everything.

[Fast]

Originally posted by Dark_Mage09:

Originally posted by alan0n:

I'm about to make a lot of people mad.

Minecraft is not even mid, its bad.

The combat is jank, the animations are terrible, the UI is hideous, the game play is generic, the crafting is unintuitive, and the graphics... are total dog water.

The ONLY thing that made minecraft great was it was the first unlimited sandbox that broke open the market.

Objectively, as a game... it was middling if you want to be generous and not good if you want to be objective.

The people and the community that the sandbox attracted made that franchise, the quality of the game itself had little to do with it.

Exactly what I meant. I merely meant to point out that one game can get away with stuff like that but if it's not Minecraft, nooo, everyone complains about everything.

What you are doing though, is what-a-bout-ism. This game can be terrible because that game is.

What if....the new game tried to be better and we work from a place of high expectations and quality and not start with the standard bar on the floor.

[😎Astran😾]

I concur - It's terrible in a way like Star Wars Galaxy was at launch in 2003: buggy, unpolished yet somehow very fun

I had no intentions to buy the game before beta but now I feel quite interesting. Once they'll show open world co-op quests or guild PvP extraction raids or 50% discount - I'll buy it immediately

[Rocinante]

The combat is great but lets be real.... some people cant cope with the fact that they're terrible at the game. Get better noobs, game is good you are not.