is Hades better than Bastion and Transistor?

[K.A.]

Rank all Supergiant games now

[PlutoDeamon]

the smoothnes of the gameplay is far better than all titles, but in the story and writing despartment, pyre is still the no1.

[Sleepingfire]

Bastion = Transistor > Hades >>>>>>>>> Pyre. Pyre had the usual brand SGG amazing music/characters that you'd expect, but holy jesus christ was the gameplay boring. Hades has a lot more replayabality than any of the games though, so while personally I'd rate it very slightly lower than Bastion or Transistor, I have already sunk a lot more time into it, and still have a lot more I want to do.

[dHeX ⛤]

Personally;
Hades > Bastion > Transistor > Pyre

[AHordeofBunnies]

Transistor is my favorite overall. After that they are pretty equal in my eyes with maybe a slight disadvantage to Pyre because the sports game gameplay isn't as exciting to me.

[Odahviing]

Hades>>>Transistor>Bastion

[Niccolo']

yes, way better

[Morton Koopa Jr.]

I think Hades, as advertised, is a combination of the best things about bastion, transistor, and pyre. That said, the genre differences aside, I still consider Transistor a masterpiece: a perfect mix of creative and deep gameplay, unique and stylish aesthetic, and a surreal, emotionally gripping narrative.

[RetroNutcase]

As far as the gameplay goes, Hades is far above the others. Smooth, satisfying, fun.

[Specific Beef]

I prefer it, yeah. I'm in the minority that didn't click with Bastion, and although I loved the art and atmosphere of Transistor hugely, the gameplay just didn't compel me to continue.

Pyre, though, I loved with my whole heart, and Hades beats even that.

[Badankadonk]

I consider Bastion a masterpiece, and Transistor right behind it. I did skip pyre since the gameplay didnt look as good but i've always been tempted to get it anyways since I love SGG. I'm starting Hades now that it's released and super excited.

[Whirblewind]

Bastion > Hades > Transistor > Pyre

A generation will pass with no heir to Bastion's throne.

[Morton Koopa Jr.]

Originally posted by Specific Beef:

I prefer it, yeah. I'm in the minority that didn't click with Bastion, and although I loved the art and atmosphere of Transistor hugely, the gameplay just didn't compel me to continue.

Pyre, though, I loved with my whole heart, and Hades beats even that.

A very different trend there

[PePino]

I really liked story in Bastion, but gameplay in Hades is x100 times more fun. I don't think I want to play Bastion a second time, plot gives an emotional experience, it cannot be felt a second time, but Hades can be played whenever you want and have fun

[Cyiel]

I can't because they are different kind of games and i like all of them.

[ZeppMan217]

I hold that Hades improved upon Bastion in every way: better movement, better weapons, better story/characters/music.
Transistor had a lot going for it but it couldn't decide what it wanted to be in terms of gameplay, turn based or real time; story was kinda chewy as well. Corrupted "In Circles" is phenomenal.
https://youtu.be/nMyoI-Za6z8
Pyre was just a ball game with a VN tacked on top, with a weak story to boot.