[spoilers] the Aerie and other questions

[avbitran]

So I finished most of the game (endings A-D) but I'm still a little confused when it comes to the way shades work.
If some of the questions get answered in ending e just say so and I'll wait patiently, otherwise feel free to answer.
The biggest example is the Aerie which I still don't understand.

My question is what the hell happened there in part 2? Were the people there always shades? If not, how did they become shades? And what was the point of inviting Nier to the Aerie?

I also really struggle to understand how shades work in general. I get that shades are souls of humans, but how is it possible for a shade to have children for example or why some shades seem harmless? Also, why some shades seem sentient and others are just mindless killing machines?

Last question is about the timeskip - I understand why the timeskip happened, what I don't understand is what happened during the 1300 years. Did the replicants were sleeping for all this time? Were they dying and re borning? I think the game tries to say it's the latter, but if so I don't understand how did it work.

[mega_bahamut86]

I don't really understand what happen in Arie either. I guess some shades took over the bodies of the people there. They knew Nier would come for them sooner or later. So the they lured him into a trap.

I don't think shades can reproduce. The just don't age.

[Minneyar]

Google, "Grimoire Nier," reading through that will provide a lot of answers.

Here's the short explanation, and I'll admit beforehand that I might have some details wrong because it's been a while since I read it:

Gestalts (souls) are immortal, but replicants (their bodies) are not. For the last 1300 years, Devola & Popola have been making clones of replicants to replace the old ones while they wait for it to be safe to combine bodies & souls again. At some point during that time span, the replicants began to speak and develop consciousnesses, and they even built their own villages. Despite being intelligent, they can't reproduce because they don't have souls. Gestalts can't have children because they don't have bodies; the smaller shades you see are simply the souls of children.

Gestalts that are separated from their body for too long begin to break down and go insane. A gestalt breaking down is also what causes the black scrawl to appear on its associated replicant. Most of the shades you fight in the game are gestalts that have lost their sentience, although some are not. The non-aggressive shades you fight near the beginning of the game are just children that don't have any reason to fight you.

There are some gestalts who, when they realize what is happening, try to stop it by forcefully combining with a replicant that isn't their own. This is what happened at the Aerie; a lot of the people there are gestalts possessing replicants who are afraid to go outside because they're scared of the sun. The gestalt and the replicant's consciousness fight for control of the body and eventually go insane. When the replicant eventually dies, or if they fail to combine, the gestalt emerges again, making it look like the replicant "turned into" a shade.

I don't recall if Grimoire Nier specifically says what happened at the Aerie, but the impression I always got was that the gestalts there knew Nier was going around murdering shades and they were expecting him to come for them, so they set a trap to kill him.

[avbitran]

Thanks I'll check out grimoire nier. I still don't understand exactly how the process worked (for example say a replicant dies, what happens to the next "incarnation" of it? Where does it come from and how did replicant Nier and Yonah stayed together for 1400 years retaining the same relationship they had for all this time?)

[lessthanoff]

avbitran님이 먼저 게시:

Thanks I'll check out grimoire nier. I still don't understand exactly how the process worked (for example say a replicant dies, what happens to the next "incarnation" of it? Where does it come from and how did replicant Nier and Yonah stayed together for 1400 years retaining the same relationship they had for all this time?)

The Replicants are recreated roughly every century. Each batch is overseen by the observer androids (like Devola and Popola) as they await the death of white chlorination. So the current Replicant Nier and Yonah are not the first ones to exist.

[Smaxx]

As for "why are some aggressive, some not". Play to the ending, but before fighting the final encounters, open Grimoire Weiss and read the new notes unlocked. They'll reveal parts of history, covering this phenomenon.