Should I wait for Persona 4 Remake?

[Cainanzito]

I never played any persona in my life but I wanna start in the series, it is worth to play Persona 4 Golden first or wait for the remake while playing Persona 5 and 3 Reload?

[Lar Dass]

Nah play 4 first, imo the remakes are only to make the combat and visuals upto date with 5, and its likely p6 will look very similar to 5/3r anyways. Although imo they should have given the remake treatment to p1/2 instead. 4 right now is a gem regardless

[trans ally kazuma kiryu]

nah you can play golden just fine.

[Bubley]

Originally posted by Cainanzito:

I never played any persona in my life but I wanna start in the series, it is worth to play Persona 4 Golden first or wait for the remake while playing Persona 5 and 3 Reload?

As someone who just started playing this game (having never played any Persona game before) two weeks ago, I would say Persona 4 Golden is perfectly fine and doesn’t need a substantial remake. If you don’t mind older graphics, I’d 100% recommend playing this version.

[Mistie]

Remake of Persona 4 not even confirmed you want to wait something that can never be realeased? Play P4G it's worth it, best Persona in the Persona series.

[Xigua]

I bet it's going to get wokefied and censored. So, no.

[Arifufu]

it's worth to play Golden, Golden is definitive edition of Persona 4, so this is the complete edition

[Big Shaq]

You should wait because this version has a dude who abuses his dauughter. The devs will have to rework this in the remake or else people won't buy it. Better to wait and skip this toxic version.

[Xigua]

Originally posted by Big Shaq:

You should wait because this version has a dude who abuses his dauughter. The devs will have to rework this in the remake or else people won't buy it. Better to wait and skip this toxic version.

Who cares about the dad. She has her onii-chan (me)

[fuggles2k]

Yeah, but of course the other guy hasn't thought about how that dynamic would be affected.

You would have to rewrite three characters and a dungeon and get new VAs to even begin to indulge his foolish whims. He's basically read a newspaper article once.

[euphoric.cat]

Originally posted by Mistie:

Remake of Persona 4 not even confirmed you want to wait something that can never be realeased? Play P4G it's worth it, best Persona in the Persona series.

it might actually not be so crazy, honestly.
The domain "p4re.jp" was registered a month ago so there's a really good chance it'll come out next year at the earliest actually. the same thing happened with p3re.jp being registered - the game was revealed a few months after. (as well as a few other domains for the side games)
Shihoko Hirata also wrote a post on Instagram saying she's working on a huge new project around the same time (7w ago), and her most notable work is the soundtrack for P4

[Coffee Addict]

if you play P4G then you'll know what was changed or not when you play P4R

[Master_SI]

Just wait til June 8 to decide. I would say if announced may as well wait and play P3Reload in the meantime. If nothing announced then play 4G whenever.

[SkaaTerminator]

absolutely not, persona 4 does not need a remake and you shouldn't wait for a remake that doesn't even need one since it plays good enough. I can understand with persona 3 but with 4 absolutely not Persona 1 actually needs a remake.

[mdesaleah]

Thing with P4, is that Golden is already the definitive version. No doubt about it.

So unlike P3, where fans wanted a definitive version and were asking for a remake, P4 doesn’t have that issue.

Could a remake be fun? Sure. But no one is demanding it as a necessity

(arguably P3 fans still didn’t get what they wanted since asking for a “remake” doesn’t mean Atlus would make it definitive. So now there are 3 versions of P3, each with their own advantages instead of just two lol)

[euphoric.cat]

Originally posted by Master_SI:

Just wait til June 8 to decide. I would say if announced may as well wait and play P3Reload in the meantime. If nothing announced then play 4G whenever.

Just because persona 3 reload was announced in june does not mean that a persona 4 remake will be.