P5 Royale Or P3 Reload

[Cipher]

Just got the True Golden Ending, Enjoyed everything but the dungeons honestly.

Question is should I play P3 Reload or P5 Royale next?

[MadMinstrel]

Doesn't really matter. Both are great. Grab P5, it's cheaper right now.

[Cipher]

I own both already :)

[Kerobe]

P3R has similar dungeon than P4G (i mean many floors randomly generated searching for stairs), so if you want to change a bit, play P5R before i guess (even if there is something similar in P5R but it take less time and the main dungeons are really good)

[CHAO$$$]

Persona 5 even if you ignore that Reload is horribly overpriced by comparison.

reload is trash, its an outdated game with a new coat of paint
No real effort was made to address a lot of the major issues that game has like incredibly lackluster and uninteresting social links, the tedious main dungeon and overall just bad writing.
The main story doesnt really go anywhere until youre over two thirds through the game.

But ultimately neither of these come close to the writing quality in persona 4 which is a bit of a problem considering how much of the game is dialogue.

4 definitely is the pinnacle.

[Skeith]

This is not a jab at Persona 3, but i would recommend 5 Royal. Its just the most modern and the safest best that you will enjoy. Good luck with whatever you pick.

[King Of Lolis]

5 is better in every way from characters to gameplay
3 is pretty bad, just 1 dungeon with over 200 floors and mc looks like an early 2000 emo and other characters look to be over 30

[Door Into Summer]

Originally posted by King Of Lolis:

5 is better in every way from characters to gameplay

This is completely false, ESPECIALLY when it comes to the characters. P5 was either your first Persona and/or you have horrid, insufferable taste.

[King Of Lolis]

Originally posted by Door Into Summer:

Originally posted by King Of Lolis:

5 is better in every way from characters to gameplay

This is completely false, ESPECIALLY when it comes to the characters. P5 was either your first Persona and/or you have horrid, insufferable taste.

Akechi is the best
As for the group, ann

As for 3
What you got an emo mc, a cop guy and girl who looks like a teacher for some reason

5 thus has more fun and interesting characters

And if you dont believe me
Look how persona fans always argue for best girl in 4 or 5 but never ever 3
Exactly

[ilookchinese]

3 reload is most similar to 4. it has randomly generated levels, a great cast of characters, and is more simple than 5. i would personally save 5 royal for last because of how "grand" it is and how its less simple compared to 3r and 4 and i think its the magnum opus of the series. however both are great and if you start with either one youll be playing through two amazing games

[Joe da Immortal]

Play Persona 5 Royal. That game's a masterpiece. Wait for P3 Reload to drop in price. As much as I am excited for that one, it's too expensive. Kind of greedy.

[zuppaclub]

P3R , more simpler , but prepare some tissues.

[Kofmel]

i'd get persona 5 when it's on sale and wait till persona 3 gets like a bigger sale

[RageArmor]

I know it wasn't an option. But if you loved the persona games. You may wanna check out the other atlus games on steam as-well Mainly Etrian Odyssey
https://store.steampowered.com/app/1868180/Etrian_Odyssey_HD/

[UltraPsyker]

I played Persona 3 Portable before playing P4G, and to be honest, it was an amazing experience.
It's pretty different from the 4th, but it has some great storytelling in my opinion (I'm talking about the Portable version, I don't really know if Reload kept the same dialogues).
Also, they made 4 Persona 3 movies which are pretty awesome.

[MAAAAAAA GIC]

Until the rest of the content is released, I have a feeling we haven’t seen the final price for Persona 3 Regreedy.
If you haven’t bought and played Persona 5 already…don’t. It’s a downgrade; the more I play it the more I just want to go back to 4G.

Save your money and buy something that earned its reviews, like the Yakuza series.