Worth re-playing NG+?

[Noir]

Is it worth spending another 70+ hours just for Margaret ?

Did the first play through on V.hard, got max S.link, max social stats, read all books, now feels like there ain't much new stuffs to do in NG+ ;/

[[NGNS-SWE] ⚡ Quezkatolen ⚡]

Eh no.
The thing is, for hardcore persona fans getting some more connection to persona 3 with the M sidestory was very cool but for me new game + is only useful for people who didnt max social links and felt they missed out on a few sidestories and really, really wanted to replay the game again- maybe before they play persona 5, or persona 4 dancing or whatever they wanted.

[John Johnson]

I'm really sucked into this game so of course I'm doing it, but if you aren't that interested then probably not. It really doesn't take as much going new game plus if you skip through every already seen event with Z, not to mention how quicker the dungeons are with your OP personas from the compendium.

[[NGNS-SWE] ⚡ Quezkatolen ⚡]

Yeah I would instead recommend you get persona 4 dancing for ps4, psvita or pstv instead which take place just after p4 golden ending, if you want more "persona 4 story".
Yes its not "amazing" but you get a real story adventure in it, AND while you might not love the gameplay with timing buttons, it is really nice to enjoy the whole soundtrack again, with the characters dance to it and being together to solve another case.

[> 𝘋𝘪𝘮𝘪𝘵𝘳𝘪]

If you did everything in the first run then i can recommend watching the boss fight on youtube.
It is easily the hardest boss fight in the game/in the series imo.

[Noir]

hmm, probably gonna pray that P4D is gonna hit PC lol, in the meanwhile guess I'll just do another play through so I can take down reaper and M for the achievements, really wanne fight M myself ;P

[[NGNS-SWE] ⚡ Quezkatolen ⚡]

yeah p4dancing take place just after the p4 golden epilogue, right there at junes. with their new haircuts and cloths
so its a real sequel, trust me.
also p5 has references to it, at the start of the game and even a bit into it if you look around - p5 btw takes place roughly 4 years later storywise.

[Van Helsing]

i plan to go 100% but just missed the last dungeon and overwrite my save with the ng+ so i guess not....
maybe 1 day i gonna do it

[gooooood mewing vietnam!]

why would it take 70 hours to do that? you can just do what you need to do, ffwd everything else, run through dungeons to avoid excess fights, and go to sleep every day

[SkyNET]

Are Persona 4 Arena and Arena Ultimax not canon?

[John Johnson]

Originally posted by SkyNET:

Are Persona 4 Arena and Arena Ultimax not canon?

Yes
Edit: I am bad at reading I mean they are canon

[GeassV]

Originally posted by John Johnson:

Originally posted by SkyNET:

Are Persona 4 Arena and Arena Ultimax not canon?

Yes

P4Arena and Dancing canon, only Persona Q are not canon

[kirbo]

i mean if you wanna fight her for the achievement, yeah why not.
if you have a strong persona and skip all of the text it'll take 20-25 hours to get to the end of the game, heck maybe a bit less, since you do need to manually go through the dungeons.
but not 70

[DogMeat]

Originally posted by GeassV:

P4Arena and Dancing canon, only Persona Q are not canon

Persona Q 1 & 2 are both Canon.

The characters forget the memories of the events at the end of both Q games, so the stories don't matter / continue from the end of Persona 4. Not mattering and 'canon' are too different things

[GeassV]

Originally posted by DogMeat:

Originally posted by GeassV:

P4Arena and Dancing canon, only Persona Q are not canon

Persona Q 1 & 2 are both Canon.

The characters forget the memories of the events at the end of both Q games, so the stories don't matter / continue from the end of Persona 4. Not mattering and 'canon' are too different things

yeah but all memories all wiped, that's why i say persona q not canon

[SkyNET]

Nice!
It goes like this

P4G
P4A
P4AUM
P4D

Plenty to play.
Thankfully, both Arena games work great on RPCS3
Only missing Dancing.

Atlus pls port to PC. Tnx.