cant romance naoto

[Chief Keef]

i have maxed courage and knowledge and the other social qualities at 4, i am in a relationship with chie and rise, date is 11/15 where the thing at the shrine happens, i chose "protect naoto" and after that she says "i consider you a friend as well" pls help i want to be able to date best girl

[Freudesleid]

DId you choose "I am glad you are girl" at level 5 to 6?
Apparently you need to choose 3 options to get her as your gf
The 3rd unlocks after choosing the 2 options

[Chief Keef]

Originally posted by Hurensohn:

DId you choose "I am glad you are girl" at level 5 to 6?
Apparently you need to choose 3 options to get her as your gf
The 3rd unlocks after choosing the 2 options

oh ♥♥♥♥ i said gender doesnt matter im ♥♥♥♥♥♥

[Chief Keef]

Originally posted by biggie cheese:

Originally posted by Hurensohn:

DId you choose "I am glad you are girl" at level 5 to 6?
Apparently you need to choose 3 options to get her as your gf
The 3rd unlocks after choosing the 2 options

oh ♥♥♥♥ i said gender doesnt matter im ♥♥♥♥♥♥

the save i can load is 11/14 nooooooooo

[Freudesleid]

Rip.Well, there is always a next time.

[Redblaze27]

That locking you out is weird.

She's only interested if your thinking about her gender?

[Cheezystix]

Originally posted by Redblaze27:

That locking you out is weird.

She's only interested if your thinking about her gender?

Yeah it's really weird.
I mentioned this in another thread, but saying that her gender doesn't matter shouldn't have to lock you out of her romance option. Picking either choice should allow for her to fall in love with you either way since both options basically mean the same thing.
For someone who is apparently best girl, she sure is picky....

[RDG]

Originally posted by Redblaze27:

That locking you out is weird.

She's only interested if your thinking about her gender?

Well it makes sense, she is looking for someone that can see her true feminine self. If you say gender doesn't matter you are literally just not giving it importance by saying "hey gender doesn't matter, because you are not a love interest".

[Redblaze27]

Originally posted by RDG:

If you say gender doesn't matter you are literally just not giving it importance by saying "hey gender doesn't matter, because you are not a love interest".

Or you are implying you are down for Naoto, regardless man, woman, or something else entirely.

[P-O-T videa burger]

ohh i was wondering about that too

[Scorpix]

You can check even her reaction. If you say that you are glad that she is a girl, then she will start feeling embarrassed. She starts to feel from that moment, that in Yu's eyes she is a 100% girl not a male. Otherwise she wont be sure about how you see her.

[Cheezystix]

Originally posted by RDG:

Originally posted by Redblaze27:

That locking you out is weird.

She's only interested if your thinking about her gender?

Well it makes sense, she is looking for someone that can see her true feminine self. If you say gender doesn't matter you are literally just not giving it importance by saying "hey gender doesn't matter, because you are not a love interest".

In a way that does make sense, but I always took it as you telling her that her gender doesn't matter because she is a love interest.
In that moment she is wondering why she was born a women because it would make life so much easier (Mainly both her job and hobbies) for her if she was born a man.
Now while saying "I'm glad your a girl" is not a bad thing to say in that situation, I feel like it's just a more creepy way of saying "Your gender doesn't matter" because either way your basically telling her that her gender does not define nor devalue herself as a person.
They both contain the same overall message so I feel either choice should get you to romance her.

[Chief Keef]

Originally posted by Hurensohn:

Rip.Well, there is always a next time.

all right maybe i could do that in ng+

[RDG]

Originally posted by Redblaze27:

Originally posted by RDG:

If you say gender doesn't matter you are literally just not giving it importance by saying "hey gender doesn't matter, because you are not a love interest".

Or you are implying you are down for Naoto, regardless man, woman, or something else entirely.

Game was written in an era where LBGT pandering wasn't a thing yet, so no.
The MC and Naoto are written as heterossexual characters, so it makes complete sense. If you say gender doesn't matter you are just telling her she is just like another "bro" to you.

[RDG]

Originally posted by Cheezystix:

Originally posted by RDG:

Well it makes sense, she is looking for someone that can see her true feminine self. If you say gender doesn't matter you are literally just not giving it importance by saying "hey gender doesn't matter, because you are not a love interest".

In a way that does make sense, but I always took it as you telling her that her gender doesn't matter because she is a love interest.
In that moment she is wondering why she was born a women because it would make life so much easier (Mainly both her job and hobbies) for her if she was born a man.
Now while saying "I'm glad your a girl" is not a bad thing to say in that situation, I feel like it's just a more creepy way of saying "Your gender doesn't matter" because either way your basically telling her that her gender does not define nor devalue herself as a person.
They both contain the same overall message so I feel either choice should get you to romance her.

I can see where you are comming from but you are overthinking this a bit, she was never a "gay" character, or bi for that matter (unlike maybe Kanji and Yosuke), she just dresses up as a boy for the sole reason she feels in her workplace women have a harder time (even though in reality, its just a competitive environment where the majority that ->choose<- to work in happen to be male, where men also have a hard time with against guess who? other men, I know right).

MC seeing her as female opens up the possibility for romance, since I guess no guy has ever approached her as a female and she just flat out refuses every girl contact.

[FhqwhTODD]

Originally posted by biggie cheese:

oh ♥♥♥♥ i said gender doesnt matter im ♥♥♥♥♥♥

Why would anyone ever say stupid crap like that anyways.