Clarify On Multiple Romances

[LukanGamer]

Put Spoiler tag if need be;

but what exactly happens besides 1 extra scene sort of thing if you multi romance do they actually all break up with you or just give you a quick punishment scene and then go back to loving ?

If they do break up can you romance 1 of main 4 gals and then all the sides ? (read someone say you can do this, but he may have just got lucky and not triggered event).

[LukanGamer]

Originally posted by evengaar:

Oki, just for you to be sure, 2 possible consequenses of multiple romancing:
1) While on a date with girl at Sunday (u know, that happens after they call you on phone and ask to spend the day together) you may encounter another girl - one of them will get reverse Arcana. Honestly to avoid it just don't hang out with them at Sundays - you won't be able to level up their social link anyway during such a date. Didn't happen for me, so it's possible to avoid.

2) Sad scenes with 3 of 4 ( or 4 of 4) girls during Valentine's day ( Chie, Yukiko, Rise, Naoto) - not possible to avoid ( btw Ai, Yumi and Marie didn't have any bad reaction). Also some people said, that they got Reverse link at that moment - but I guess it won't happen if you already maxed their Social link - so you just feel like a jerk.

Doesn't exactly answer me unless that was to clarify what I read was correct including with the yet again mix on side gals being unknown :D not to mention doesn't clarify things people (including some extent me) don't know what mean.

Decided to look it up more think found answer so guess will just copy paste it and assume it correct.

[LukanGamer]

Still bit confused seems there some chance involved and massively depends on who with max being a potential save for some but here what I found a person say:

If both women are a combo of Chie, Yukiko, or Rise, you lose both.
But if Naoto, Yumi, or Ai are involved you only lose the one you run into.
Yes, the odd avoidance is to max the first S. Link before trying something new. I managed relationship with Chie, Yukiko, Rise, and Naoto
(Not sure if this means So long as you Max first you fine or if he just lucky ?)


1 or more will break up with you (unless maxed? and or lucky?), but you can repair and even re-girlfriend them :


"Should you happen to cause a reversal, you must spend 3 visits to patch things up before you can begin rebuilding (ex: Yukiko reversed to Rank 8. After 3 visits regaining her trust, you are allowed to continue to Rank 9). In order to rebuild enough where they re-accept being your girlfriend, strengthen the bond with lunch invites/study dates. If neither are available, simply have a corresponding Persona with you to double the bond (ie. Triglav, a Chariot Persona, would help with your bonding with Chie)."

[Cheezystix]

The moral of the story is that if you don't want to feel like an absolute ass then just stick to one girl. If you don't care then pimp yourself out. There are really no major gameplay changes depending on who you date.

[evengaar]

Originally posted by LukanGamer:

Still bit confused seems there some chance involved and massively depends on who with max being a potential save for some but here what I found a person say:

If both women are a combo of Chie, Yukiko, or Rise, you lose both.
But if Naoto, Yumi, or Ai are involved you only lose the one you run into.
Yes, the odd avoidance is to max the first S. Link before trying something new. I managed relationship with Chie, Yukiko, Rise, and Naoto
(Not sure if this means So long as you Max first you fine or if he just lucky ?)


1 or more will break up with you (unless maxed? and or lucky?), but you can repair and even re-girlfriend them :


"Should you happen to cause a reversal, you must spend 3 visits to patch things up before you can begin rebuilding (ex: Yukiko reversed to Rank 8. After 3 visits regaining her trust, you are allowed to continue to Rank 9). In order to rebuild enough where they re-accept being your girlfriend, strengthen the bond with lunch invites/study dates. If neither are available, simply have a corresponding Persona with you to double the bond (ie. Triglav, a Chariot Persona, would help with your bonding with Chie)."

If you want to romance all girls - just play the game following the walkthrough. Other than Valentine's day 3 or 4 sad scenes, you wont have any more consequences
P.S. I really don't understand what you want to hear) If you wanted info on "Reverse Arcana status" - it would be easier to google it xD

[LukanGamer]

Originally posted by evengaar:

If you want to romance all girls - just play the game following the walkthrough. Other than Valentine's day 3 or 4 sad scenes, you wont have any more consequences
P.S. I really don't understand what you want to hear) If you wanted info on "Reverse Arcana status" - it would be easier to google it xD

This is what I asked and you answered now though appears to be incorrect? or least not the only way if what I posted (found) is correct.:

"If you want to romance all girls - just play the game following the walkthrough. Other than Valentine's day 3 or 4 sad scenes, you wont have any more consequences "



Also I did google though should not require to as that the point of asking; Reverse Arcana status:

It actually quite harder to look up then you think it would be, most so for accurate info and for full info (being that the girl will break up with you is not explicitly said with it least most the time from what I saw)-->
This part of them breaking up being made worse by the constant people not fully knowing and game itself being confusing with how it handles it (which is still quite unconfirmed :D but o wells).




O and just fyi you may want to link walkthroughs not just say "the walkthrough" as there is 48 in this case and other games can have way more.
---> I likely when I play this I wont use walkthrough 100% as it likely requires a lot and likely not as enjoyable and just will regirlfirend if need be (assuming that correct).

[evengaar]

Originally posted by LukanGamer:

Originally posted by evengaar:

If you want to romance all girls - just play the game following the walkthrough. Other than Valentine's day 3 or 4 sad scenes, you wont have any more consequences
P.S. I really don't understand what you want to hear) If you wanted info on "Reverse Arcana status" - it would be easier to google it xD

This is what I asked and you answered now though appears to be incorrect? or least not the only way if what I posted (found) is correct.:

"If you want to romance all girls - just play the game following the walkthrough. Other than Valentine's day 3 or 4 sad scenes, you wont have any more consequences "



Also I did google though should not require to as that the point of asking; Reverse Arcana status:

It actually quite harder to look up then you think it would be, most so for accurate info and for full info (being that the girl will break up with you is not explicitly said with it least most the time from what I saw)-->
This part of them breaking up being made worse by the constant people not fully knowing and game itself being confusing with how it handles it (which is still quite unconfirmed :D but o wells).




O and just fyi you may want to link walkthroughs not just say "the walkthrough" as there is 48 in this case and other games can have way more.
---> I likely if/when play this wont use walkthrough as it likely requires a lot and likely not as enjoyable and just will regirlfirend if need be (assuming that correct).

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/pc/293013-persona-4-golden/faqs/76145 - you can use this one. Honestly, it's quite hard to do Reverse Arcana in P4 - i finished vanilla 2 times and golden 1 time (all with miltiple romances) and didn't encounter it. Also if it really happens - just reload the save and try to do other thing that day and date with that character at the evening)
Maybe I misunderstood your question in the beginning, cause I thought u asked about break up during Valentine day's scene, not the reverse arcana one

[LukanGamer]

alright will check out guide some at some point,
Good to know it rare and easy to avoid just not the type or length of game I personally want to beat more then 1x but want to experience a good portion of the story+character content.

(I know True end / True(gold) true end require some things towards end that need to be followed played enough japenese games to know that a huge thing they love to do).

[LukanGamer]

O and just found this in a guide so guess its something that should be watched for:

friendzone Ebihara on *First* time she confesses and never ever take her on a sunday date

[evengaar]

Originally posted by LukanGamer:

O and just found this in a guide so guess its something that should be watched for:

friendzone Ebihara on *First* time she confesses and never ever take her on a sunday date

If you are going into romantic ending with her - yeah, she must be friendzoned first time she confesses to you