GTA V vs. Cyberpunk 2077

[Kamamura]

Comparison of various ingame systems:

https://youtu.be/PsBrkLq31eM
https://youtu.be/1IPRjzrHvak

IMO quite fair. Remember that GTA5 is already 7 years old.

[evil tomatoes]

Първоначално публикувано от Darkie:

Първоначално публикувано от Kamamura:

That being said, of course those are comparable games, both are presenting open world games,

First off.. we had an exact same thread with exact same videos. Closed now ofc.. Because what you don´t understand is that one of these games are a Openworld Action Shooter (that is GTAV) the other one is an Adventure-RPG with FP perspective and an Openworld

In GTAV the openworld is its biggest focus. In CP2077 it is an secoundary.
GTAV has no ineractable story, no leveling/progression of character, no character creation or stats in general..... It is like comparing GTAV to lamborghini american challenge, because both games are about driving a car......

So lets do that.. I am even friendly enough to take GTAV PS4 gameplay and not PS3.

Run both at the same time... GTAV almost looks like this old SNES game and the driving is actually very similar... no progression in GTAV.....

Go to 3.14
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d74REG039Dk

Go to 1.30
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bXUPp-tqaj8



Are we done comparing silly things? What about we compare the RPG aspects of Morrowind and GTAV.. or even the graphics of boths original releases... you know what.. lets bloody compare them... Imagine I was on the GTAV forum flaming the game for not being a proper RPG, but a soulless Action Shooter in a open world (the latter is what the bloody stupid thing is)

It should be pretty obvious what both games tries to be... but well...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hCnom86ac1U

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=puVICAvG6NU



Absolutely stupid to compare these games... CP2077 and GTAV is like comparing Strawberries and Tomatoes.. just because both are fruit... I wonder whom would win the "is most sweet" contest... Just absolutely silly in most cases without looking more nuanced on it.

well said.

[River]

But does gta v has story dlc tho?

[SpaceWombat]

Първоначално публикувано от Skarmo:

GTA 5 is such a bad game...

- No hacking
- No implants
- No cyberware mods
- No robots
- No eddies
- No ...

(Just kidding, but guess what I'm trying to say...)

yepp, it's also GTA "5" not GTA "1". Last time I check Cyberpunk 2077 is the first iteration they've made. I know it's no excuse since anyone can just play another game to see what aspects are good to copy, but come on CDPR might have struck gold with TW3 but that hardly ever mean't their next project would be perfect from the get go. This is their first game within an urban shooter setting and I think if you think in that regard they did a good job compared to other studios' typical first entries. Not trying to justify the management decisions they made, but it's an objective observation that's all.

[evil tomatoes]

Първоначално публикувано от Axx:

All the cope from the fanboys sustains me. GTA 5 is almost a decade old and is more detailed. Cyberpunk should have all the same details and more. This is what happens when games are rushed.

no. different game, different studio.
that's like saying Assassin's Creed recent releases should be GTA too coz it's the gold standard in openworld mayhem.

Първоначално публикувано от Kleerex:

I didn't know GTAV had character leveling with skills and perk trees, character augmentations, weapon upgrades and crafting, dialogues with choices, and a futuristic city.

they did but they scrapped it. dammit. ^_^

[RIVEIR]

Първоначално публикувано от orchid9_:

Like it or not, but GTA 5 is objectively a technological masterpiece. It's vastly more complex and does vastly more complex calculations on a fly than Cyberpunk does, not to mention that it is extremely better optimized.

[evil tomatoes]

Първоначално публикувано от River:

But does gta v has story dlc tho?

dude, they got a casino! nothing can top that. nothing.

[zacharyb]

Първоначално публикувано от evil tomatoes:

Първоначално публикувано от River:

But does gta v has story dlc tho?

dude, they got a casino! nothing can top that. nothing.

Pffft Casino's are so early 2000's, gambling in games is all about lootboxes now, get with the times.

[Korppi]

4 prior games will go a long way in making a good game... GTA 3 was the first 3D GTA-game and it didnt have the same features as GTA 5.

[Thodin]

The stealth system was the best in GTA5....oh wait^^

You see you can't compare an action game for children with a full fledged open world RPG wich in fact has all those juicygame mechanics action games will never have.

[gungadin22000]

I'll take CP, personally. Setting is better and generally doesn't hassle me to do annoying sidequests involving driving towtrucks slowly around town. CPs sidequests usually involve dudes and the shooting thereof.

GTA5 was fun, but padding all those side activities onto it for no reason detracted from the experience rather than adding to it.

[TheAgent]

You lot need to brush up on the trailer.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ixl31324UxE

Still not sure?

Dont believe me, listen to Keanu..

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Es9cEjBjzg

GTA is the perfect game to compare it to.Cyberpunk was marketed as a game where you steer your own destiny in an open world, RPG elements aside here.

GTA's story is a very good one. anyone who says otherwise is lying to themselves, given it also spans 3 playable characters that also interact with each other outside of the players control.

Cyberpunk was marketed as an open world game, not a story driven game and one where you can "Shape your own destiny" as long as you follow a set path laid out....

If CDred didn't want you experiencing night city outside of the story lines, they would have locked the city away.


The fact is, people want to be sold a lie that the game they are in, especially when it was marketed as such, is going to be immersive.

Instead we have a very good game, with not very good a world to interact with.

Hell i cant even sit on any of the many available seats to just take in the sight of the city.

There are vendors dotted around everywhere you cant interact with. even if its just buying a snack or Drink.

the AI is dumber than a box of rocks. try and defend it all you like saying "its not a game like that", when thats exactly the game they tried to say we would be getting.

[⚡Snake⚡Plissken⚡]

There is no competition here, 2077 isn't completed yet.

[Wisp Cat]

There is "hacking" in some gta games.

But the hacking minigame in 2077 is something that some real life hackers actually do. (When working with machine language, compressing it by taking advantage over how stuff can overlap can make the difference between an attack failing or succeeding.)

Of course, it's utterly "toy hacking" -- and it's still just a minigame. But this is a small example of currently unappreciated depth in the game.

[Kiwibom]

Stop comparing an rpg game to a non rpg game. 2 different games.
Sure you can prefer gta over cyberpunk but just stop comparing those 2.

[evil tomatoes]

Първоначално публикувано от zacharyb:

Първоначално публикувано от evil tomatoes:

dude, they got a casino! nothing can top that. nothing.

Pffft Casino's are so early 2000's, gambling in games is all about lootboxes now, get with the times.

dude, you're killing me.
that bit sarcastic. yeah, GTA online is nothing but a microtransaction milking cow.