This is the best RPG ever made

[Rematin]

Simply no competition, this game is almost 100% perfect. The characters, the music, the addictive game play, the visuals, the writing, the world, everything about it is just next level. I just hope CDPR keeps releasing content for this game and hopefully a sequel in few years.

[mikemonger]

It's a pretty good game...I've got no hate for it at all...but best RPG ever? Maybe top 20 but definitely not top 10. Because as others hsve pointed out there's no real innovation here. It looks and plays well but they're all things that have already been done.

Where it shines is its writing.

[Rematin]

Originally posted by mikemonger:

It's a pretty good game...I've got no hate for it at all...but best RPG ever? Maybe top 20 but definitely not top 10. Because as others hsve pointed out there's no real innovation here. It looks and plays well but they're all things that have already been done.

Where it shines is its writing.

but it doesnt need to do anything new to be the best, it simply needs to do things its doing and do them right, what would u say are better rpgs than this one? by that i mean the ones in same genre with open world, choices, action combat and diverse builds.

[Booker T-Witt]

Originally posted by Rematin:

Simply no competition, this game is almost 100% perfect. The characters, the music, the addictive game play, the visuals, the writing, the world, everything about it is just next level. I just hope CDPR keeps releasing content for this game and hopefully a sequel in few years.

That is extremely debatable lol.

[Dailao]

Originally posted by Rematin:

Simply no competition, this game is almost 100% perfect. The characters, the music, the addictive game play, the visuals, the writing, the world, everything about it is just next level. I just hope CDPR keeps releasing content for this game and hopefully a sequel in few years.

I really like it for many things, but it is far from perfect let's be honest.

[Malgus]

Top five if you aren't hit with bug RNG in CP2077. Also it is bit subjective considering how large RPG field is; personally I'd go with DragonAge Origin or Baldur's Gate 3 as overall best. I learn more to magic over cyberpunk, but again personal opinion.

[Caldrin]

Its a good game for sure not the best ever made..
BG3 is it if you like rpgs.. tho if scifi is your thing then this is right up there.

[Wither]

lmao.
Good, may be. But best? There are much better contesters.

[wirednight]

Absolutely not the best RPG ever. Other than the fact it doesn't hold a candle to the old Gold Box games, BG1, BG2, Mass Effect, Dragon Ages, the Oblivions, the Skyrims, and the like for all time, it's still not even the best this year.

It's good, I play it, I like it, but saying it's the best RPG ever pretty much just says it's the only RPG you've ever played.

[Chaosolous]

It’s good.

Baldur’s Gate 3 is better.

[mikemonger]

Originally posted by Rematin:

Originally posted by mikemonger:

It's a pretty good game...I've got no hate for it at all...but best RPG ever? Maybe top 20 but definitely not top 10. Because as others hsve pointed out there's no real innovation here. It looks and plays well but they're all things that have already been done.

Where it shines is its writing.

but it doesnt need to do anything new to be the best, it simply needs to do things its doing and do them right, what would u say are better rpgs than this one? by that i mean the ones in same genre with open world, choices, action combat and diverse builds.

But to really blow my socks off it really DOES need to not only do something new, but do it exceptionally well.

20 years from now you won't have games emulating mechanics introduced in Cyberpunk, because it's just emulating mechanics found in older games like Morrowind and BG2...two games which set the standards still being followed today and which were absolutely mindblowing when they came out.

That doesn't mean Cyberpunk is a bad game. It just means you can't call it best ever,.

[adema066]

Originally posted by Rematin:

Simply no competition, this game is almost 100% perfect. The characters, the music, the addictive game play, the visuals, the writing, the world, everything about it is just next level. I just hope CDPR keeps releasing content for this game and hopefully a sequel in few years.

Making a leveling system that existed for 3 years in a RPG shooter mean nothing now and lazy level-scaling have made the game worse. Unfortunate.

[mikemonger]

Originally posted by Chaosolous:

It’s good.

Baldur’s Gate 3 is better.

Meh. I'm having a hard time getting into Act 3. Just not grabbing me the way Acts 1 and 2 did.

Cyberpunk on the other hand I found compelling start to finish.

[5ean5ean]

Best RPG ever made is Knights of the Old Republic...everyone knows this.

[wirednight]

Originally posted by mikemonger:

But to really blow my socks off it really DOES need to not only do something new, but do it exceptionally well.

20 years from now you won't have games emulating mechanics introduced in Cyberpunk, because it's just emulating mechanics found in older games like Morrowind and BG2...two games which set the standards still being followed today and which were absolutely mindblowing when they came out.

That doesn't mean Cyberpunk is a bad game. It just means you can't call it best ever,.

I kind of disagree with you here. BG2 didn't do anything really knew when you compare it to BG1 and some of the later editions of the Gold Box games... it just did it better. Morrowind's story was out of this world, but it's mechanics were clunky to be honest.

You don't need to be innovative or do something new... you just have to do it better... and have a really, really good story. Morrowind wouldn't be Morrowind if it's story wasn't stellar. Something that Bethesda has been trying to capture again for years.

Fallout 1 wasn't great because it was original or innovative, in fact it was nothing more than a spiritual successor to Wasteland. Still Fallout has spawned generations of games, and Wasteland has become a footnote in the Fallout series (which is a shame I loved Wasteland).

How many people remember Bard's Tale, WIzardry, Planescape, and to this day talk fondly of them, and it was those games that spawned BG2.

You don't need new... but you do need exceptionally well.

Without exceptionally well you're destined to be forgotten.

[Starbarian]

Give OP an Award.