Paladins of tyr

[secret0agent0james7bond]

I listened to karlach snuck in the upstairs and sneak killed anders and trynn. She won’t admit they’re dead and if I try and progress the game she leaves the party. Did I royally screw up my game?

[Dre G Writer]

You need to talk to them and make them attack you first, then you kill them. Killing them without reason will most likely produce the issue your experiencing.

I killed them by defending myself when I talked to them and they attacked me. I was able to tell Karlach about it and she was like, bro, your now my bestfriend, I didnt even have the option to NOT bring her into my party as she would not take NO for an answer even after I told her(i have 4 custom character party, she cant join even if I wanted it)

[secret0agent0james7bond]

Dang I thought I was being smart by ambushing them, guess I screwed that up. Thanks

[Rangoun]

There's a third mob in the front room of the tollhouse. Did you get them as well? If you missed them, that might be causing your problem?

[Veganleader1]

I'm not sure that's even what matters, though I may be speaking partly from EA experience. There are actually 4 of them: Anders, Trynn, the vendor girl, and the rogue who hangs around out front. Maybe they removed the rogue from the game because he never came into the fight, like I'm used to and I never saw him afterwards. I fought the other 3 inside the house. I did speak with Anders I think this time, so you may be right, but did you kill all of them?

[secret0agent0james7bond]

Anders and trynn are the only two in the building no vendor girl or rogue…..

[Rangoun]

Originally posted by secret0agent0james7bond:

Anders and trynn are the only two in the building no vendor girl or rogue…..

Cyrel is the girl in front. I'm guessing mage of some kind. Don't know what to suggest except explore the area around, including the roof, see if she's all the way up there?

I've no experience in early access, but there was no rogue out front for me.

[The Seraph of Tomorrow]

Originally posted by secret0agent0james7bond:

Dang I thought I was being smart by ambushing them, guess I screwed that up. Thanks

Nope, the game doesn't allow you to play smart without breaking it more often than not.

[Xenospire]

This is so dumb. So much multiple ways to do things.

She wanted them dead, I killed them, now I can never finish her story...

[BOLBIES]

Same happened to me. I'm debating if I should just keep going or wait to see if Larian fixes these quest bugs

[DraloX ツ]

i just did that part earlier today and can confirm you dont need to talk to them. I sneaked up on the girl in the back of the house and sneak attacked her to start combat with all 3. After the fight the dialog with Karlach continued and i was done with that part of her storyline. OP probably is just missing 1 of the npcs and need to hunt her down

[ChaosKhan]

Originally posted by Xenospire:

This is so dumb. So much multiple ways to do things.

She wanted them dead, I killed them, now I can never finish her story...

You need to kill all 3. Just Anders and Trynn are not enough. The spellcaster/vendor needs to go too.

[Step_Fodder]

I did the sneak attack but went back and started a fight with the vendor. Triggered a fight with the remaining and let me end the quest

[Exarch_Alpha]

Originally posted by Step_Fodder:

I did the sneak attack but went back and started a fight with the vendor. Triggered a fight with the remaining and let me end the quest

Yep. Works properly.

Even gives you a surprise effect to give you some extra time on the paladin a hole, the biggest threat by far.

[GrandMajora]

No, you did not 'royally screw up' your game, because Karlach is not an essential NPC.

[Exarch_Alpha]

Originally posted by GrandMajora:

, because Karlach is not an essential NPC.

Fight me