Logan still turns me down

[Teresa]

It said in the latest hotfix it fixed NPC's turning you down. Didn't work. I got so frustrated I deleted the save. it said he was my soulmate. i gave gifts everyday. Still kept saying you'll just take it back , waving his hand. How can I fix the problem of him refusing proposal The hotfix did not help this old woman. I am 60 and don't know how to fix this. I've played over 900 hours and have not had this problem with any of the other NPC's.

[Endora]

Quite rude, doesn't it? I guess I'll start a new character and befriend Andy as fast as possible.

[Acneman]

Have you had enough relationships with him? Also I suggest to try a couple of times since it's usually for NPC to turn player's down even if they've reached enough relationship points.
If it's still not working, it should be a bug. You can send the bug report to us by following the steps here: https://steamcommunity.com/app/1084600/discussions/0/3713810544748132640/

[CHEMSHAW]

i am also having this issue and it won't work with the proposal spot either just says he has other plans and to try again at another more convenient time. lmao like bro, convenient for whom?? i 70 hours deep in this! im committed. heaven help me if i gotta start over cuase the burnout is reaaaaal. lmao

[syzara]

I have the same issue. If you try to propose at the arch, the game says that "your sweetheart has other plans" forever. My character is full soulmate level with Logan, and she never flirted with anyone else.

Edit to add: I mailed my save file.

[Zombified]

Originally posted by syzara:

I have the same issue. If you try to propose at the arch, the game says that "your sweetheart has other plans" forever. My character is full soulmate level with Logan, and she never flirted with anyone else.

Exactly the same issue I had.. it never resolved itself. I restarted my save because it was the same every day for a couple of seasons. I had Logan maxed out as soulmate and I had Andy as a BFF... so I just started again to see if it happens again. (Also never once chose a flirt with anyone else). It seems some have no problem and the rest of us can't marry him. So sad.

[syzara]

Originally posted by Zombified:

Exactly the same issue I had.. it never resolved itself. I restarted my save because it was the same every day for a couple of seasons. I had Logan maxed out as soulmate and I had Andy as a BFF... so I just started again to see if it happens again. (Also never once chose a flirt with anyone else). It seems some have no problem and the rest of us can't marry him. So sad.

Since you're restarting anyway, may I suggest starting to flirt early? In a different thread on here we were discussing that that might be the difference in successful proposals. I honestly don't know if it is the issue, but it can't hurt to be a bit more cringey perhaps for a good cause ;)

[[OTG] Aelirenn]

My experience was I chose every flirt option except that first cringey one in the hideout because no way no how am I tell someone I just met something so silly. The embarrassment is real. lol

I had previously chosen 1 flirt option with Owen (when his friend came to town) and 1 with Ernest (the bit with Banjo and the wadded up piece of paper). I had also told Unsuur "Let's be best friends."

I also made it a point to befriend Andy, but that's because I genuinely like the kid and wanted to adopt him no matter what happened with Logan.

I flirted at every opportunity after the first one, kept giving him gifts even after the relationship was maxed, and he confessed to me. We had a hot date. I kept asking him on dates and giving him gifts.

I already had the engagement ring from a while back because I like being prepared. I asked him on another date, took him to the proposal place, and got the option to propose (E). I did and he said he thought I'd never ask or something to that effect. Then we were considered married and he moved in (sleeping with his hat on lol), but I did have a wedding ceremony at the church on the following Saturday. Got to the church, put on my pretty dress, took a couple of pictures, clicked the book on Miguel's desk, and the ceremony started.

The wedding picture the game took is goofy because Logan is barely in it lol but the whole thing worked as intended. I did not throw a party because I didn't even think about it.

I should have said that this was a game I had been playing for quite a while. I am now replaying the game from start to see if I can duplicate the success. I have no idea why it worked for me and some people, but doesn't work for others. I have no idea if anything I did was different than anybody else.

I will try to keep up with both threads to offer anything else I notice, but it will be a while. We just got the bridge finished in my new game and I have a lot going on this week so I don't know how much time I'll have. Darn you real life!

[Zombified]

Originally posted by syzara:

Originally posted by Zombified:

Exactly the same issue I had.. it never resolved itself. I restarted my save because it was the same every day for a couple of seasons. I had Logan maxed out as soulmate and I had Andy as a BFF... so I just started again to see if it happens again. (Also never once chose a flirt with anyone else). It seems some have no problem and the rest of us can't marry him. So sad.

Since you're restarting anyway, may I suggest starting to flirt early? In a different thread on here we were discussing that that might be the difference in successful proposals. I honestly don't know if it is the issue, but it can't hurt to be a bit more cringey perhaps for a good cause ;)

I chose every single flirt line that popped up with him.. even the ones made me laugh so darn much.. talk about awkward.. so unfortunately, in my case, that did not help. I still couldn't. Here's hoping it works this time because I really don't feel like marrying off the poor girl to someone else.

[Zeesha]

Originally posted by OTG Aelirenn:

I will try to keep up with both threads to offer anything else I notice, but it will be a while. We just got the bridge finished in my new game and I have a lot going on this week so I don't know how much time I'll have. Darn you real life!

I started a new one as well to see if there's something I missed in the points, but I will take a lil to get to Logan. Was also only going to take Andy to Good friends (or whatever the title is) to see if it bugs out or there was something I missed not posting in the list of things done.

I mean, my main is over or at 2 years old so it's not a new play through or it hasn't been through however many patches. Would think if anyone had a problem, she would of. Was wrong though. :/

[syzara]

Originally posted by syzara:

I have the same issue. If you try to propose at the arch, the game says that "your sweetheart has other plans" forever. My character is full soulmate level with Logan, and she never flirted with anyone else.

Edit to add: I mailed my save file.

It's not my hobby to quote myself, BUT I got a reply from QA:

Hi~
It‘s a known issue that should be fixed in the full version. You can ask for a repair after full release if the issue persists.

Just for you'all information!

[jlnew6724]

Same here when we speak he calls me partner in crime ! Why would you call your soulmate partner in crime?

[Nichiki]

Yeah, ive maxed my hearts for Logan, currently working on maxing my hearts for Andy as well. Hoping that makes a difference, but he just tells me to keep it and waves his hands at me so far.

[catherinetixier63.200]

moi aussi j ai le meme probleme avec logan et je suis a 1400 heures

[syzara]

Originally posted by OTG Aelirenn:

My experience was I chose every flirt option except that first cringey one in the hideout because no way no how am I tell someone I just met something so silly. The embarrassment is real. lol

As that seemed to me the only difference between our play-throughs, I started a new one (post-hotfix) and picked all flirts except that first super cringey one and guess what

IT WORKS!

So here is another data point for y'all. I am also friends level with Andy.

[Acneman]

I suggest to go further into the storyline since many players tried to propose to Logan when they haven't reached a certain point in the story.