Terraria vs Minecraft vs Starbound

[Youtube: BoyDilly]

Give me sereous detailed reasons why one game is better than another one. Which game is more replayble? Which game has better exploration and bosses? Which game has better music and community? Which game has better mods? Which game is better in its vanilla form? And which game is the best overall?

[Trace]

1. Terraria
2. Minecraft
3. Starbound

But, Terraria and Minecraft are too different to the point where I don't think they should be compared. And Starbound is just too boring to play it over Terraria.

[jonasaboo]

You can't compare Minecraft and Terraria. They are two completely different games.

[Trace]

Also, stop posting these stupid compare threads.

[Lilian]

Minecraft is more replayable, but terraria has better bosses and they have similar exploration factor. Terraria has better music but minecraft has more impactful music due to the nature of when it appears, minecraft has much more mods and terraria is very good in its vanilla form, although so is minecraft.

Starbound is mostly boring, especially following the storyline, but doing anything else is mildly fun. Over all, wouldn't recommend unless you can glitch the next sale with it too.

[Lilian]

Plus, minecraft never really ends, where terraria kinda has nothing to do after you beat the moon lord. But in minecraft, there's still much to do. Build a grand base, explore to the farthest reaches you can, kill the Wither, explore the End islands. So one world can last longer.

[Lilian]

A terraria playthrough usually ends at or soon after killing the moonlord, but hundreds of hours can go into a single minecraft world. Take HermitCraft for example, of all the youtubers combined there's probably thousands of hours both on and off camera they spent on 1 of the worlds.

[Lilian]

But really, it's just personal preferance. And, i hope my analysis helped.

[Lilian]

But in my opinion, and obviously many others, Minecraft is pretty much unbeatable. It's still very, very popular to this day, and yet terraria has died down a bit. Both are still great classics though, and they are both dear to my heart.

[Tymon]

Honestly, I think it's pretty much an objective fact that minecraft, at least vanilla minecraft, has MUCH less content overall than terraria. Especially when it comes to actual gear, biomes, number of creatures, bosses, etc. If we involve mods however, then modded minecraft probably does have a lot more depth and stuff than terraria. You can't raise and level up creatures to fight alongside you in terraria just as an example off the top of my head.

[-GoV- Ghost Kawanat]

Originally posted by Tymon:

Honestly, I think it's pretty much an objective fact that minecraft, at least vanilla minecraft, has MUCH less content overall than terraria. Especially when it comes to actual gear, biomes, number of creatures, bosses, etc. If we involve mods however, then modded minecraft probably does have a lot more depth and stuff than terraria. You can't raise and level up creatures to fight alongside you in terraria just as an example off the top of my head.

You can with a mod, but overall I feel like all three games can't be compared, but if they must. Here's a simple one word comparison for each.
Minecraft = Building
Terraria = Action
Starbound = Exploration
All three games are great.