Dice re roll bug

[Gui-Geek]

Is it normal to burn a reroll to have same 2 dices ( sometimes 3 ) 50% of time?
Clearly not, your RNG is broken.

[SOFAGUS]

Publicado originalmente por Lfod:

Publicado originalmente por SOFAGUS:

you think we do it because we hate this game? no, we want it to be better for everyone.
Do you think they would change their awful monetisation plans if not the backlash?

When all that was happening I think sometimes people made the mistake of thinking I was talking about them when I may not have been. Obviously the problem people got timed out a few times.

The backlash is fine just some people took it too far in my opinion. It's fine if you think everyone who complained was perfectly normal but we will have to agree to disagree on that one.

i just check from time to time to see how fast game is getting better and if it is getting better at all. I want to play but not in EA

[mrsir]

Publicado originalmente por SOFAGUS:

i just check from time to time to see how fast game is getting better and if it is getting better at all. I want to play but not in EA

Personally, as someone that played pre-release and still play now, I would recommend waiting until at least Season 1 before even considering buying this game. Its fun, but very bare bones still.

[HolyGrail]

perceptive bias, played several hundred hours.. rerolling skulls and not getting what you want happens as often as rerolling 3 die pushes and still not getting the pow i need to hit the blodge character.. just accept that nuffle isnt your friend

[HolyGrail]

Publicado originalmente por mrsir:

Publicado originalmente por SOFAGUS:

i just check from time to time to see how fast game is getting better and if it is getting better at all. I want to play but not in EA

Personally, as someone that played pre-release and still play now, I would recommend waiting until at least Season 1 before even considering buying this game. Its fun, but very bare bones still.

yup you'd get burned out and eventually will stop caring at some point.. it's pretty obvious there isnt gonna be a content drop in the meantime.

[noirnick]

Yes, because it happens all the time when playing on table top. Why, because dice do not remember rolls, so it is always 1 in 6 per die of it happening.

[Murion]

Publicado originalmente por Roderick:

Publicado originalmente por Gui-Geek:

Is it normal to burn a reroll to have same 2 dices ( sometimes 3 ) 50% of time?
Clearly not, your RNG is broken.

Did you use it on players with "loner" trait? I noticed that if the loner trait kicks in and the reroll is denied, the dices are still rolled visually, while in fact, they just show the same result again.

But yes, I have seen two double down multiple times in a row. Yesterday I head two dead players, on one the apo rolled... death. So basicly thee deathrolls almost in a row. Sometimes it is just bad luck.

That happens on every reroll you chose not to do and often it is irritating cause you dont know if you accidently clicked reroll and had Bad luck. Its prett stupid to Show the roll Animation again if you do not chose to reroll or are denied the reroll

[brionl]

Publicado originalmente por mrsir:

Publicado originalmente por SOFAGUS:

i just check from time to time to see how fast game is getting better and if it is getting better at all. I want to play but not in EA

Personally, as someone that played pre-release and still play now, I would recommend waiting until at least Season 1 before even considering buying this game. Its fun, but very bare bones still.

Leaving aside the abysmal state of single player, multiplayer leagues are still missing a lot of basic stuff too. So yeah, keep waiting for now.

[HolyGrail]

Publicado originalmente por noirnick:

Yes, because it happens all the time when playing on table top. Why, because dice do not remember rolls, so it is always 1 in 6 per die of it happening.

ye you just remember it when it doesn't go your way, there's always certain combinations that'll stay etched on your mind.

[Gui-Geek]

Ok now it's really clear that re roll are bugged and give you often same dices.
I just played a game and guess what? my opponent re-rolled like 4 times in a row 2 same dices and it happened again and again in the same match.
Come on this is just impossible with pure RNG.
You can ask him if i'm lying, his name was XENO playing dwarves.
He can confirm that.

[Phart]

The weird thing about rolling dice is that if there is a 1 in 36 chance that it can happen, it will happen. It's not impossible. You have probably experienced 4 unlikely lucky rolls in a row just as often, but because our brain is wired to score "lucky" as "skill" and "bad rolls" as "broken", it feels as if the dice are rigged. They're probably not, unless the devs managed to screw that up, too (where's that BB2 feature that lets you examine dice roll probabilities after the match???)

[sixty4half]

Publicado originalmente por Gui-Geek:

Ok now it's really clear that re roll are bugged and give you often same dices.
I just played a game and guess what? my opponent re-rolled like 4 times in a row 2 same dices and it happened again and again in the same match.
Come on this is just impossible with pure RNG.
You can ask him if i'm lying, his name was XENO playing dwarves.
He can confirm that.

So how do you explain the multitude of people that have experienced rerolls working properly?

[Gui-Geek]

Publicado originalmente por sixty4half:

Publicado originalmente por Gui-Geek:

Ok now it's really clear that re roll are bugged and give you often same dices.
I just played a game and guess what? my opponent re-rolled like 4 times in a row 2 same dices and it happened again and again in the same match.
Come on this is just impossible with pure RNG.
You can ask him if i'm lying, his name was XENO playing dwarves.
He can confirm that.

So how do you explain the multitude of people that have experienced rerolls working properly?

I don t know man lol
And i m not even talking about bad luck because it wasn t even my re rolls but my opponent's re roll.
It s just no possible that it happens so often...
It has to be a problem with re rolls , don t tell me it only happens to you 1/36 times that you get the same 2 dices, this is not true!

[sixty4half]

Publicado originalmente por Gui-Geek:

Publicado originalmente por sixty4half:

So how do you explain the multitude of people that have experienced rerolls working properly?

I don t know man lol
And i m not even talking about bad luck because it wasn t even my re rolls but my opponent's re roll.
It s just no possible that it happens so often...
It has to be a problem with re rolls , don t tell me it only happens to you 1/36 times that you get the same 2 dices, this is not true!

Do you keep a spreadsheet of every die roll and your reroll results?

I cant tell you for a fact that its 1/36 cuz I dont keep a spreadsheet for that stuff.

If your opponents dice rerolled exact results 4 times in one game I'm curious what your results were in that game, you dont mention failures so I'm assuming your rerolls worked which is just odd behaviour for a glitch in a computer game.

Keep in mind, push is on 2 sides so it isn't 1/36 for that. And if you dont have the Block Skill Double down and Skull are pretty much the same so getting a bad result is not 1/36 most often with new teams.

Also; quoting your own post does not give you more creditability

[Gui-Geek]

Publicado originalmente por sixty4half:

Publicado originalmente por Gui-Geek:

I don t know man lol
And i m not even talking about bad luck because it wasn t even my re rolls but my opponent's re roll.
It s just no possible that it happens so often...
It has to be a problem with re rolls , don t tell me it only happens to you 1/36 times that you get the same 2 dices, this is not true!

Do you keep a spreadsheet of every die roll and your reroll results?

I cant tell you for a fact that its 1/36 cuz I dont keep a spreadsheet for that stuff.

If your opponents dice rerolled exact results 4 times in one game I'm curious what your results were in that game, you dont mention failures so I'm assuming your rerolls worked which is just odd behaviour for a glitch in a computer game.

Keep in mind, push is on 2 sides so it isn't 1/36 for that. And if you dont have the Block Skill Double down and Skull are pretty much the same so getting a bad result is not 1/36 most often with new teams.

Also; quoting your own post does not give you more creditability

I didn't do that lol probably missclicked

[Gui-Geek]

And i just re rolled 3 same dice in exact same order and this happening casually every game is just my imagination of course.