So you substitute "hitpoints" for "stamina"?

Origineel geplaatst door GorlomSwe:

So you substitute "hitpoints" for "stamina"?

Yep, basically. Instead of "hits zero - you're dead" meter you get "hits zero - you can't stand" one. You can't stand and defend yourself - you're an easy prey that is killed with one hit.

It's a very complicated system - there should be calculations about traumas, pain, bleeding. Also it allows "adrenaline rush" perk that allows character to ignore any ill effects from wounds and traumas for a while.

Origineel geplaatst door Necrius:

Origineel geplaatst door GorlomSwe:

So you substitute "hitpoints" for "stamina"?

Yep, basically. Instead of "hits zero - you're dead" meter you get "hits zero - you can't stand" one. You can't stand and defend yourself - you're an easy prey that is killed with one hit.

Well, zero is still zero, you're just representing it differently and adding an extra penalty to reaching 'one'.

While adding complication to a system, when it comes to games, you've got to actually consider does it add enjoyment or just clutter and a false sense of depth.

Origineel geplaatst door Skoardy:

Origineel geplaatst door Necrius:

Yep, basically. Instead of "hits zero - you're dead" meter you get "hits zero - you can't stand" one. You can't stand and defend yourself - you're an easy prey that is killed with one hit.

Well, zero is still zero, you're just representing it differently and adding an extra penalty to reaching 'one'.

While adding complication to a system, when it comes to games, you've got to actually consider does it add enjoyment or just clutter and a false sense of depth.

Meh, it's details. I'm thinking globally.

A rose by any other name would smell as sweet.

Are you kidding me...? Did no one ever play Romancing Saga? Wtf...

Alright, let me explain. Romancing Saga uses a fun battle system with 2 stats for life. HP and LP... Your HP is your health. Of course, it's never good if you let it go down but you won't die if you run out of it. Here's where it becomes tricky. Monsters can also or will inflicts LP to you if you're down or at any time. Life points... If you run out of those, you die. Simple.

Origineel geplaatst door Sera:

Are you kidding me...? Did no one ever play Romancing Saga? Wtf...

Alright, let me explain. Romancing Saga uses a fun battle system with 2 stats for life. HP and LP... Your HP is your health. Of course, it's never good if you let it go down but you won't die if you run out of it. Here's where it becomes tricky. Monsters can also or will inflicts LP to you if you're down or at any time. Life points... If you run out of those, you die. Simple.

Those freaks not owning a console... Why they're allowed to live at all?

Origineel geplaatst door GorlomSwe:

Origineel geplaatst door Necrius:

Meh, it's details. I'm thinking globally.

You got it wrong, this is details from the very beginning. This requires whoever uses it to solve a lot of (as yet) unanswered problems. It pretty much needs a tailormade game to the mechanic. You can't just up and lift hitpoints out of a game and put this in it's place.

I can throw an idea in and let some actual coders think over it and maybe implement something like that in a game.

Origineel geplaatst door Necrius:

Origineel geplaatst door GorlomSwe:

You got it wrong, this is details from the very beginning. This requires whoever uses it to solve a lot of (as yet) unanswered problems. It pretty much needs a tailormade game to the mechanic. You can't just up and lift hitpoints out of a game and put this in it's place.

I can throw an idea in and let some actual coders think over it and maybe implement something like that in a game.

If an idea is not properly thought out it's not worth a coders time to implement. This is why "ideas people" make terrible game designers.

Origineel geplaatst door Necrius:

Origineel geplaatst door GorlomSwe:

So you substitute "hitpoints" for "stamina"?

Yep, basically. Instead of "hits zero - you're dead" meter you get "hits zero - you can't stand" one. You can't stand and defend yourself - you're an easy prey that is killed with one hit.

It's a very complicated system - there should be calculations about traumas, pain, bleeding. Also it allows "adrenaline rush" perk that allows character to ignore any ill effects from wounds and traumas for a while.

So...basically the D&D 3.5 health system.

yes