309 people found this review helpful
2 people found this review funny
Not Recommended
0.0 hrs last two weeks / 248.6 hrs on record (215.5 hrs at review time)
Posted: Dec 14, 2014 @ 8:49pm
Updated: Jan 9, 2015 @ 1:57pm

Updated at 9/1/2015, Status update
Appearently I have written too much, please click HERE[puu.sh] or HERE(doc)[puu.sh] for the full review

There is a summary at the end if you are too busy to see through the whole review.
And just a kindly reminder, there is no R-35 in the game yet.

-------9/1/2015-------
Patch released at 7th
+ Car fix
+ Better connection

- No fix on AI
- Faction War still meaningless
- Still no rear mirror
- Little more bugs

Better than before but not enough
------------------------

Hate to say it, but if you are not a big fan of a free-roam racing game, don't buy it at this moment
Although I am not recommending this game, this doesn't mean I don't like this game, as you see I have thrown more than 100 hours in it

The Crew was a good game for people to driving around the states, it still is, but with tons of flaws atm.
Still, I should start on the good things first as some of you may still interested in the game.

At first, It has a biggest map for a racing game I ever saw, even I have spent more then 100 hours in the game, I still have about 1/4 to 1/5 of the map is undiscovered.
If you only drive to explorer the map and not doing missions, it should take you at least 12 hours, as you can drive 3-4 hours in a starting car just driving a lap of the border.

The game also provide various terrain and environment, with landmarks for players to enjoy and explorer freely.
In some of the story mission, it will even provide some environment effect like fireworks or plane flying over your head which is quite stunning when you see it first time.

There are 5 specs for cars: Street, Dirt, Perf, Raid, Circuit
For Street, Dirt and Perf, there are parts to let you to customize the cars, like front bumper, hood, rear wing, etc.
Just be aware not all the car has all 5 spec.
The interior of the cars are quite detail and you are able to customize the color of it in most of the cars.

There are also different activity like skill challenge or limited period mission that may keep you playing.


Bad things
First of all, lack of cars, there are only 40+5(wreck) cars if you are not buying the season pass, also, there are no Audi, Toyota, Subaru, Mitsubishi, Honda, Hyundai, Vovle and more.
And for each brands there are only 1-2 cars.

The handling are not realistic like GT series, it is acceptable but you may feel strange for the first few hours.

The things that can be driving through are also uncertain, you can drive through some fences in cities, and bounce off with others.

There are no technical tuning in this game, like suspension modification, angle of tires, etc.
The only thing you get is upgrading the equipment directly.

There is no rear mirror view when you are in interior mode

The mechanism of automatic transmission is flawed (Details in Full review)

The difficulty of this game is very hard in different aspect and it is not adjustable.
First, the Rival AI's car can be insanely fast, they will not slow down by environment unless crash.
For some casual driver with the staring cars, it is very hard for them to catch up.
And with the auto catch-up system, even if you are good at driving and lead the whole race, you make one mistake and you will be overtake then lose.

You can invite other players to the mission to try to decrease the difficulty
But the problem is you will need to wait for the game to connect to a random session before you can invite players you don't know
And with a maximum 8 people session, there is very hard to find one who actually willing to play with you

About the police chase, first, the police is as fast as rival AI's car in missions.
They have a circle radar around them instead of a cone vision which should be able to block by buildings
The police heli can see through the tunnels
Most ridiculously is that if you go too far from the police cars, the police car can spawn anywhere near you, and sometime in front of you
This make you need to maintain an approximate distance that their radar cannot catch you but no police car will spawn
To escape it should be always as fast as possible, I don't know why they need to make this system so counterintuitive

There is some perk in the game which can actually increase the handling, acceleration, speed, etc. in the game
Which mean even with a same car, a LV50 player still have a big advantage compare to a LV1 player, if the LV1 player haven’t bought any perk points using credit which can be obtain by paying real money.

Car level nearly mean everything, especially when doing story missions with others.
With my 1200 lv cars, I always outrun the guy who invited me to the coop mission in his/her first time attempt.
In my experience, the higher lv car you have, the higher position you will get in PVP.
And to get a car over 1000lv, you will first have to reach 50 lv at your character
Which mean you will have a big disadvantage before you reach 50 lv

In this game there is a faction war system but meaningless

The stability of the session can be very unstable
When you are in a crew, you select a mission and invite you crewmate, you can end up with your crew member playing the mission themselves and you get a forever loading screen
Similar things happen when you select public PVP lobby, you will be the only one who get into the lobby and your crewmate will continue finding a lobby.
Sometimes you crew member will not appear in your screen even when you are beside of him/her.


PVP sessions also contain connection problems
Sometimes when other player in your session have a unstable connection, the game will pause for 5 seconds
when the player have a really bad connection, you game can have more than 10 times pauses, which is extremely annoying
sometimes you can also getting left behind at the starting line when people already racing in front of you with about a hundred yards away


This is a nice racing game, and for some people it is still a masterpiece
but it is also nearly the worst racing online game ever, don't even know why they make the MMO feature as a selling point
The slogan of this game is "Never Drive Alone", but for me it is like "Never Drive Alone If You Want To Suffer"

Summary
Pros
Huge map for exploration
Many customization for some cars in some spec
Detail and customizable interior
Beautiful and various environment
Environment effects in story missions
Different activities that keep you playing

Cons
Lack of cars
No technical tuning
Handling/Physics are not realistic
Flaws in automatic transmission
No rear mirror
Difficulty is overall high and not adjustable
AI cars will not slow down by environment
Maximum 8 people session make players hard to crew up
Police chasing system is stupid and annoying
Perk system can provide unbalanced advantages
LV of cars nearly mean everything
Faction War system is totally unfair
Forced online with the server is unstable
Game statistics can be messed up by the game/server
Unstable connection among friends/crew member and to the sessions
PVP connection problem
Bad avatar system
Various Bugs

Mixed
Too much uncertainty on the road

Recommend to buy it if you
Love free rome style racing game
Have friends to play together and can tolerate to any possible fail from the server
Love customize your cars and show off

Not Recommend to buy it if you
Cares more about realism of racing
Are a casual driver and consider this game as a single player racing game
Don't want to use tons of times to climb the ladder (Cars LV, PVP, Faction)
Want to drive cars that doesn't exist in the game (find the list on the internet)
Want to race on 1:1 scale circuit
Have a bad connection
Was this review helpful? Yes No Funny Award
19 Comments
Rem4rk4ble Jan 9, 2015 @ 1:12pm 
bellow in the black box are the hours but i made it as is because well spoiler
Rem4rk4ble Jan 9, 2015 @ 1:12pm 
@Broken search up war thunder and look at the reviews. You think 211 hours and a bad review is a lot you don;t know how many hours the war thunder guys put ijn with their bad reviews.
Everything below might come out wierd im new to formating
800 - 2000 hours
Matthewhln Jan 9, 2015 @ 12:44pm 
The truth is I like this game (in some aspect)
but it is hard to be recommended (at this stage)

As you know Steam does not give a Mixed option for a review
I still have recommended to someone which I think they might like this game at the end of the review

You were right about the fact that I have some free time though
BrokenKingpin Jan 9, 2015 @ 7:00am 
So you put 211 hours into a game and then don't recommend it? You must have a lot of free time.
Rem4rk4ble Jan 4, 2015 @ 2:44pm 
yeah. so far this game apears to be more of a disapointment than tdu2 development was when all that stuff happened with Eden and Atari. Better graphics but not gameplay. What I enjoy about tdu2 is getting a viper acr and getting into a cop chase finding a straight road and outrunning the police vipers in a drag race. To bad the police chargers are just as fast as the police vipers but oh well. Thats too bad also I was expexting this game to be amazing. Too bad it was released too soon.
Matthewhln Jan 4, 2015 @ 8:34am 
@woodstock
Well, recently the connection issue is getting better
And I have heard that they are going to "improve" the AI system later
Still, most of the Cons remains

I would say that you can consider it again when this game get a big discount at holiday sale few months later if you are interested
Hopefully they will fix at least half of the problems at that time
Rem4rk4ble Jan 4, 2015 @ 12:03am 
Longest review I have ever seen by far. Glad I didn't buy this game. Was considering. Dodged a bullet
Matthewhln Dec 22, 2014 @ 7:04am 
@koja
Well, I am sorry if this review misleaded you
I have already listed out what is good and bad in this game
also who should try the game and who shouldn't
I thought I gave out the message very clearly

As a review, it is not all about you like the game or not, but also objectively see through if the game worth others to play

but in this case, I will consider modifying the review to prevent misunderstanding
Koja Dec 22, 2014 @ 6:55am 
titel says all you dont recommand it and you still played it for 180hrs or w/e gg
Matthewhln Dec 22, 2014 @ 6:28am 
@koja
It is 170.8hrs, my friend
I think I should restate that I do not recommended it doesn't mean I don't like it
I played it so long that I know what is good and bad in this game

If you read carefully, you can see at the end of this review, I have recommended to some people
And I may, in the future, turn this review to positive when most of the problem fixed

Recently, the network problem are still not fixed, tons of bugs
For me, I can partially ignore them and still play the game
But I don't think a non-free rome racing game lover can tolerate it