Garrys Mod Server Reviews.

I go from server to server giving you my personal Player Ratings and Stats Based on time there.
Come here weekly for new server stats updates.
Will post deep reviews based on my personal experience.
Reviews are my own personal opinion and not created to slander or drive away players/donators.
I hope you find this guide to be helpful.

See to the guide index on the right side of the screen as you scroll down to pick a server review
Ratings are listed for several game modes such as _-_ Dark Rp_-_TTT_-_ect.

Dark Rp Rated categories
Jobs:
Weapons:
Props:
Staff:
Rules:
Donator perks:
and in rare cases Population


TTT Rated categories

Staff
Rules
Traitor/Detective Items
Maps
Weapons
Donator Perks

DivinityRoleplay.net [score 7]

DivinityRoleplay.net
Dark RP
Hit System
ip: 72.5.195.35:27015

Ratings--------------------
Jobs: 10 Excellent selection of jobs with a great choice of dumb ones to entertain you.


Weapons: 6 About average Selection of Weapons. Not as many as a player would thrive in.


Props: 7 Prop restriction is above 30 props. Thats good for any base. Yet too many are whitelisted.


Staff: 7 The staff are rated a Little over average on Stats for there seem to be a lot of admins whom talking down to players rather than handle things. I will seperate the good events and bad in detail below.

Good----
Alot of the admins are either really fast to respond or direct in taking control of a situation by defusing it. Some admins handle things very formal. A quick sit and listening to both sides of a story.
They handle things in sit's professionally every time. With a teleport. Discuss ect.
When a sit is brought up they dont slap someone with a punishment for running off a building for the first time, for you may be running during the time of tp and continue as such empty minded.

Bad----
Ive seen countless admins give a same player over 3-5 verbal warnings for something and not take action. Even in tense cases such as raiding while someone has a building sign and no raidables.
Yet there are some whom will not start a sit and talk or messaging. Some whom will teleport to you and simply remove the offender from ones building or area. Not taking the time to even listen to anything so they can avoid a sit and continue RP'ing.

Rules: 9 pretty basic rules. Nothing to strict. Yet I can suggest a few that other servers use and it works very well. [Ill break this down later]


Donator perks: 6 Any server that allows someone to buy admin status is just asking for abuse.
Other than that not much else is offered besides some small personal perks like points for stat increases.

If your looking for a fun time Id say go here, although if you get fused easily by people or annoying situations known common in garrys mod than you might have a hard time here. When you arrive just try to make a friend as soon as you can for here you will find yourself needing someone to watch your back in all times. Even in admin sits. People here will raid you over and over and over. Some people love the hell out of tricking gun dealers to sell them a gun and once there fading door goes down they shoot them. Its pretty fun in the long run.

ProtectionRP. org [score 9]

ProtectionRP.org

*NEED STAFF*
M9k
45+ Jobs
Fast DL
No Lag

This Review is based off of over 15+ hours of gameplay.


Review---------------------

Weapons: 9.9 I want to say 10 really bad but some guns are not fully implented into the server. Such as the winchester. You cannot buy ammo for this gun.

Jobs: 8 They have a pretty basic job line up with some nice fun ones but alot of the rules dont allow for more freeplay with alt classes.

Props: 8 Pretty basic amount of props and fun goofy ones. Yet some commands in the toolgun would be nice since usefulness is limited here. Plenty to spawn for a base.

Staff: 8 Some are really laid back yet 2 whom names shall be [Gon] and [Jesse]. Abuse and it gets by. Im not meaning abuse as in admin powers. I mean abuse as in stretching the rules so far that and other player would know its abuse such as running up to a player whom is either afk or in the middle of something such as building adjustments or sign placing and adverting "Get away from me 10 seconds or die". Not only I have tested this on them but 3 others whom joined me in the experience.

Now I will list the good and the bad.

Good-----
Id like to say fast but Ill stick with quick for sometimes the staff are quick to a sit but not as quick as needed in many occasions such as a mass rdm.
Pretty relaxed when it comes to talking to players until one gets mad.
Punishment is direct and never debatable when verdict is drawn. No begging from players work. This is good to not show mercy in terms of someone trying online to offend or harrass others and escaping the thought of it being wrong by grasping in their mind that it is a game and nothing should be taken serious. Yet some game events could be taken so serious it could reach court.


Bad----
Now I have an astounding agreement with my collegues on the matter of the teleport jailing. When a player is teleported to a sit with an admin a teleport jail is not always needed for it makes some players feel as though they have done something wrong. For many of the cases we encountered we had called the admin and both parties were jailed on the spot. I understand by jailing you can better calm the situation and discuss yet this can anger if not stress a player.
Now I understand how many admins are young but being ill tempered at any age past 13 is not good. Many events of anger in sits

Donator: 10 They dont screw other players out of a fun time by giving a huge advantage to donators. Its pretty equal on all terms in the case of strength of job. Since I found it extremely easy to obtain items and weapons used by vip players and being able to just as easily kill them. No huge advantage offered. Yet being a donator feels like a fun promising choice for you can feel as though you will enjoy a long stream of gaming on this server.


Population: 6 I have to say during school hours for most of the eastern coast this server is dead. So a huge time lapse of empty halls.

Rules: 9 nothing to unfair or bizarre about them yet a better breakdown of terms of rdm and nlr zones is needed for alot of confusion for many players were not overlooked. Such as a player had been killed just barely out of spawn doors several times for "NLR BREAK" as the players advised and the admins agreed. A base kill is a good nlr zone, yet when killed in the streets the nlr boundries are stretched for a player must have a way to another point on the map. If not entering a building along the way or stopping.


Overall I would say play on this server. Yet make sure its not in between the times of 8am-3pm eastern time[new york] for this server is dead as a doornail weekdays at that time. I enjoy playing here playing and find when its populated that a good raiding party on the pd is well in need here.

RetributionRP. Org [score 5]

RetributionRP. Org
*Need Staff*
M9K
Inventory
Drugs

74.91.119.126:27015




Jobs: 7.5 I see alot of jobs yet too many restricted to Donator. That sort of makes a player feel pressured to donate to fully enjoy their stay if intended longer. Yet enough to satisfy for short term needs.

Weapons: 8 Alot of fun guns to choose from yet I cant give this a 10 for the health settings in the game. Some players have access to over 300 hp and can survive most lethal shots.4

Props: 4 Enough props to build a small base but not enough to fully enjoy this system. If you enjoy building dont come here, too many whitelisted and black listed harmless props. They really hate doors and fences here as well so no good hobo homes to build.

Staff : 4 They staff are fast to respond but not always there to discuss or even listen. Some ignore blatan rdm and other major rule breaks and other things. A spawn prop block was occuring and no player could leave and it took staff 15 minutes to fix this. There was a layer spawning props in another players base for 30 minutes and several rdms occured near this but all a Admin whom was in the crowd could do was enjoy the ruined mess and fun killing ingoring all the rule breaking occuring. Not all of them are professional and of the ones that are their pressence is scarce.
Several incidents where a staff member pulled me to a sit and I had not only out proved myself to know more of the rules but proved some admins knew almost none of the rules listed. Such as what qualifies as a prop block/ what qualifies as mass rdm/ what qualifies of a false warrant/ and what qualifies as massive prop spam**

**.(A player was jailed for 10 minutes for spawning 4 white walls at once in the street and it was declared prop spam. He after being jailed and released showed his intentions by building a house and staying there for over 35 minutes in the server.0

IN THIS IMAGE THE ADMIN WAS LOOKING AND READING AT THE SIGN STANDING NEXT TO ME (thats why I didnt do @dmin) chat
Rules 9 Good set of rules and forced presentation of them. [if only everyone --admins--- read them]


Donator Perks: 5 Alot of perks for donated granted yet its too much. Too much advantage for donators so this server is practically pay2win. Such as fading door bombs/grappling hook/all the swat jobs.



I can say that even though I tried to have fun here I found it very difficult and I wouldnt immediately recommend coming here unless you love mindless raids over and over and over for thats all you will be able to do. Dont even try to build a base. Itll be raided even while you have a building sign[even by admins]

UrbanGamers. net [4]

UrbanGamers.net
DarkRp
Meth
Gangs
Fast Download
74.91.114.3:27015

I like seeing this when I load into a server. So I know that everyone has no excuse to read the rules even the admins.



Jobs: 7 Great selection of basic jobs and some common ones. Yet some of them seem repetitive, as in copies of other jobs.


Weapons: 10 Plenty of guns to spawn for all your killing needs.

Props: 5 Pretty basic prop spawn list. Not a lot are black listed. Yet spawn limit is very low and you have to donate to earn more.

Staff: 0 I hate to say it but within 10 minutes of being on this server I have seen that the admins never read the rules or even know how to admin.
First in an act of a raid I shot at the mayor in self defense and was instantly jailed for 300 seconds without a sit after the mayor killed me.
No sit was done. No explanation to me personally for as to why. Only a note and a warning saying "reason: RDM" Although it was self defense[he shot first and was raiding] and I never killed him.

Than theres jailing for me killing myself. Not for being wanted during or ect. Just killing myself. An admin didnt like that too much and lied saying I was wanted during this time. HA!
Now some admins tried there best And I respect those and they deserve to be recognized amongst the ranks here. For they truly acted with respect towards others and unbiased upon ever situation towards any player. Yet they were not there very long. For them I say thanks.

Its really easy to lie here though. If you like lying to get out of trouble every admin is guillble, try it they really are.
I was even asked what I wanted for my troubles of a police officer jailing me. I lied and said I didnt do anything. The admin didnt even check the logs to see I shot him once. He jailed that officer for 300 seconds. I did this to test if an admin would check logs. The player even asked them too. They said no this player "Me" is new and wouldnt lie to me. [really???]

Than theres the rules. Few admins cared or made them strict to players unless it effected the admins rp time or a friend of theres. I was running down the street and rda'd for no reason. I called an admin for it and they came to and said "You were raiding him". I WAS RUNNING DOWN THE STREET. AS A HOBO LOL.

Oh and dont even call an admin to a sit for spawn rdm. If someone kills you there just try to run by the next time you arrive.
Several events of admins stretching rules to kill for fun or to minge.
Yet some admins were nice enough to give me money for my troubles.
Some even Tried to bribe me not to report them for rdm.



Rules: 9 Great set of rules. Presentation was wonderful as well.

Donator perks: 5 Im going to say 10 in terms of giving more beyond all belief in perks yet 5 in how it was made by changing the current settings for non-donors. Like massive restrictions with props. You give too much to donors yet by doing so you simply have to take away from your free players. I think something needs to be changed here.


Personally I tried my best for over 2 hours to enjoy this server. I even made myself a gun shop Look---


Now I had enough props to build a defensive base. Yet Not enough to decor or fully explore the chance of decoration for my shop.
For this server I would say I wouldnt play here if you are in need of help. Come here to kill. Thats all that seems to occur. All the time. Randomly. If you like that than you will have fun here.
I did not.

Fearsome Gaming TTT [score 7]

Fearsome Gaming TTT
Semi-vanilla TTT
Friendly Staff
Fast DL
23.244.41.141:27015

I had a pretty decent time here yet I didnt find it to be anything special or extraordinary.


Staff 7 Excellent staff, yet sometimes lazy
The staff I saw slayed friends for rdm, never argued with players and were very kind to me.
Yet if someone say rdms as a detective and a player asks how do I report you dont even respond instead buy more T rounds. Like here.


Rules 10 Excellent show of the rules and presentation was amazing. The breakdown is fantastic.

Traitor/Detective items 7 I hate to rate it low but you only have basic T/D items. I know its a semi-vanilla but there are ways to insert items without forcing a player to download them. A bigger branch of items would be great. The greatest thing you get here is a defib/ or an ak. Even if it is
semi vanilla there are some vanilla things that are missing from here as well. [very tiny downloads]

Maps 8 I love the selection of maps and the changing over is fast and the download of the maps are great. Yet some of the maps must have issues or the download from server process must be wack for there are alot of missing textures on certain maps.


Weapons 7 I hate to rate this one 7 as well but some more guns would make this server better and there are plenty of small downloads of guns that can be added. Sense it is semi-vanilla this should help to improve this server.


Donator perks 4 I understand buying vip and ect but providing more for them would bet better except for the fact that all you offer are hats and other small objects. More playermodels would be nice for Donator's. Alot of vanilla models exist. Some of them are used when the map rotates too. Providing those as a choice would be nice. Also Pay2admin is never a good idea. So that doesnt help.


I did rdm at the start of the round as a D yes but that was to see if someone would slay or even help the player begging for help to the admin. Instead he was ignored I dont like this. If you are an admin, than put that before the game. Thats what you wanted to be. So be it. Also please add something to make this a spicy meatball. If you like people dropping in as in this is a 24/7 minecraft ttt meaning pure rdm than I would and wouldnt recommend this server, I had a great time yet a better response from admins would be nice. Also too much vanilla, not enough semi
I guess thats what we get when you allow Pay2Admin. Lazy admins

Dinkleberg's TTT [5]

Dinkleberg's TTT
Fast Downloads
Staff Needed
64.94.238.145:27015

Staff 5 Staff here are either really disrespectful, too fast to judge or dont know the rules themselves. Plus plenty of pay2admins here.
One instance----Heres a broken down version of a T baiting rule.
****** This includes saying that you are a T, shooting close other players, and more
I was reported for killing someone for T baiting was my reason. I told them he was shooting randomly and obviously near me. Whats he do? He slays me. He wont even answer me in @ chat or normal Y chat.
Than when a player rdms a admin he rages for over 9 minutes in spectator. I had to suffer this for I was slayed. Guess which admin? Thats right it was Drew the one whom slayed me. He also ignored me for all those 9 minutes in spectator.

Being slayed Mid round. I was slayed mid round for a slay I already served. So why was I slayed? "I didnt know you were slayed" was his response? Did he slay himself? No! Did he reward me for the wasted T round? No! He ignores me.

Rules 10 Great show of the rules and nice breakdown

Traitor/Detective items 10 Amazing list to choose from on both ends. Makes things really exciting.
Maps 8 Great selection of maps yet some of them even after downloading take forever to swap too. Some even require a redownload. Which gets old.

Weapons 10 Excellent choice of guns all over the map.

Donator perks 6 I understand buying vip and ect but providing more for them would bet better. More playermodels would be nice for Donator's. Also Pay2admin is never a good idea. So that doesnt help. Espically when they dont know the rules.
I am no longer going to play here, I was abused too much by players/staff. This score will stay for good.

Super Legion RP [score 3]

*Needs Staff*
Super Legion RP
100k Start
Cars
Purge
TV
216.105.171.226:2715

Jobs: 5 This seems to be a half assed attempt at pleasing normal players for there are SEVERAL classes not listed in the job listings that seem to be avaiable for admins/donors.
Here are all the listed classes You can choose from.

So if thats all the classes and I see no perks for donors on the donator Page. Than what the ♥♥♥♥ are these things.



First you have over 400 hp. 2nd that gun he is using is a minigun. Neither able to be done from what I can see by any other than admins

Also Having only 2 gun dealers is the most idiotic thing for a sever I have ever seen. For the first 15 minutes of me being on the server I was getting ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ destroyed by everyone with guns, and where were the gun dealers? AFK both of them.
I asked an admin for help on this situation. His response? "No ♥♥♥♥♥♥ Leave Me ALone"

Weapons: 0 Pay2win but its hidden or exclusive to favorties for I tried talking to an admin about how to get such things as a lightsaber ect and his comment was "No ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ allowed"

Props: 10 Excellent Selection of props and barely any white listed or restricted.



Staff: 0 Self supplying/healing/ ect abusive. The worst staff by far from any server. Not only did sits end always in the victim being punished but the admins would do there own sits even if they were not rdmd. Like here I have a kos sign and I killed an admin for going into my base. He was standing right out my doors and I blew him away. Result? A Rdm by other staff and a Warn tp teleport 15 minute pyshic gun holding talk. I was held for over 15 minutes as I was harrassed and battered by 2 admins whose only point in player this game was newbie crushing. Several acts of mass rdm, rdm, mass prop spam and prop block occured.

Heres admins healing themselves MID ROLEPLAY.




An Admin violating my kos sign and me killing him and another admin whom was not in his party rdming me in my own house. They warn me for it.

Even an instance of an admin whom was going to raid my house Flying through my walls to inspect it first. He is this hobo whom was the one that held me in spawn for over 15 munutes.

Now heres an instance of an admin being a ♥♥♥♥. I had been in this sit for over 10 minutes. This admin just LEFT HIS COMPUTER leaving this hitman whom rdmd me to mic spam me for 10 minutes. So READ THE TOP OF THE IMAGE.
It is impossible to die in spawn. Everyone is under its effects, even the admin since hes ghosted. Since he was afk and ingoring us for so long I slash my knife at him for about 3 minutes. Finally he comes back and claims I tried to rdm him in a sit. DUDE YOUR INVINCIBLE THATS NOT ATTEMPTED RDM


Rules: 5 Rules are very basic and never pushed on players or even followed by staff


Donator perks: 0 You cant even get the info on whether its for donors/admins only for the donator page leads straight to payment. No promises or rewards for donating. Simply Give me your Money.



All in all I will never Play here again. By far the worst Server I have ever played on. Deserving the worst score Ive ever given. I would not recommend coming here for anything other than getting abused.

Serious TTT Vanilla [score 9]

Serious TTT Vanilla
24/7 Minecraft
No Downloads
192.184.57.6:27015

Staff 8 Excellent staff, always check logs and talks calmly to players. Even the trial Mods. Yet some of them are too fast with some things such as accusations to grant a free kill or misleading information leading to reporting the wrong player. Beyond that excellent.

Rules 10 Excellent presentation and breakdown of rules.


Traitor/Detective Items 10 For its a vanilla server in its fullest. It even includes a harpoon!



Maps 10 Its a 24/7 minecraft server so of course it will only have minecraft maps. Its living to its fullest exent.


Weapons 10 All the Defaults plus more such as ak47 and other great default weapons to choose from.
Donator Perks 7 Alot given but you are stripping away from the FREE zone to allow more to stack upon the donator Page.


I myself have over 30+ hours on this server, the rounds are only long with alot of people on. Its a pretty great server but since its so easy to get on that leaves alot of room for rdm and leave/mass rdmers/ect. I have fun here when I get bored of those high strung GMOD servers. I would recommend playing here.

Additional Information

If someone would like me to review a server for them just post down below :) Ill get to it when I can!


I try to spend 2-4 hours on a server before writing a review and at different times to try and capture the server at its peak for the day.

If someone is bothered by a review of mine or is curious as to why a score is such and such number you may contact me at any time. [post on my steam]

I will try and change the scores every 3 months as to checking up on a server as they change.

If you wanna see another guide heres a fresh out of the oven guide for Dark Rp
http://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=685914552
Warning Its for people whom are bored of Dark Rp

[DarkMoon2112]

Please reveiw DeepGaming Serious RP Please

[VODKACAT]

review Oculus Gaming

[>KB> >KEKSQUAD]

Hey b want to review KekBox F2S: Stronghold?

[Niceme3]

Try The MonoLith Sever

[-Aya]

buyable admin rank is sometimes nerfed version of non bought one

[AJBcool]

Re rate divinity rp, they have changed a shit ton and added events that people can join like TDM, and it wont interfere with those that dont want to join

[ObiWanCanBloMe]

review SuperiorServers (in general) i have had some very bad times on these servers, half the visitors can do better moderating the servers then most the admins. gotten to the point i call it Inferior servers.

[Knuckles]

@ JustSlayin
If you didnt enjoy my guide than a open opinion would have been fine to post. Yet stating "Who Cares" implies that my opinion means shit. That is rude. Next time try to be a nicer person when posting on someones guide. Thanks for viewing though :)

[Totally Frogtacular]

TPS gaming, could you check it out?

[Robo]

Review Live To Trait TTT