Temptation and Petting The Teacher

Step by step to tempt a straight girl and seduce your boss

Introduction

There’s more than one way to skin a cat, but in this guide we’ll follow one route to tempt Mallory. We’ll also get all her CGs while we’re at it. All of the dialogue choices are definitely not necessary to get the achievement, but not knowing all the mechanics, I’ve chosen a path that works, and tried to keep it interesting.

Since a simple change in one choice can also get us the Petting the Teacher achievement, we’ll look at one of the ways that can be accomplished as well.

Now, start a game with Mallory as the traitor. While it may not matter, you get to keep five minions, and there’ll be additional dialogue. Before October 24th, raise Mallory’s loyalty to the maximum of 45.

October

On October 22nd, Mallory will confess. Say:
“Shall we go to my office?”

On October 24th, say:
“The traitor has already been dealt with”
Choose Mallory for your Queen.
“Because I like you”

On October 29th, choose:
“Face painting”
“I don’t see why not”

November

On November 5th, say:
“Would you like to go the carnival with me?”
“Did you want to ride -“
“(Run to catch up)”
“(Pick the black-and-purple prancer behind her)”
“Bumper cars?”
“What about summer or spring break?”
“Isn’t ‘Mallory’ your name?”
“I’m too busy now to worry about the future”

On November 8th, say:
“I don’t know anything about washing clothes”
“I’m sorry I couldn’t help”
“Did you need something?”

On November 9th, say:
“She’s nice enough. Pretty, too”
“Leave her alone”
“She’s my minion”

On November 13th, say:
“Come into my bedroom”
“Why not?”
“...my office then?”
“What’s on your mind?”
“How do you know?”
“Are you sure that’s the reason?”
“What exactly were you doing?”
“I’m happy for you”

On November 25th, say:
“Not since I was very young”

December

On December 6th, say:
“How is she funny?”

On December 18th, say:
“Yes...?”
“My luck is not good”
“I was deferred from my first-choice college”
“I should study”

January

On January 6th, say:
“How was your Christmas?”
“Why?”
“Are you allright?”
“Is there anything I can do?”
“(Hug her back)”

On January 13th, say:
“They’re maintenance access tunnels”
“Underground pipes and cables”
“(Hug her)”

On January 17th, say:
“Are you all right?”
“Did something happen with your roommate?”
“I thought you didn’t go all the way?”

On January 31st, say:
“It hasn’t been that long”
“All right”

February

On February 4th, say:
“Not as cute as you”
“The truth is, I like you”
“Haven’t you thought about it?”
“Because you’re too young?”
“How do you know what you want?”

If you want to go for “Petting The Teacher” as well, be sure to keep a save on February 13th.

On February 13th, say:
“It’s my card”
“No”
“What if I have?”
“She’s not that innocent”

On February 17th, say:
“Just cuddling friends is fine with me”

On February 29th, say:
“(Hop)”
“All right”

Finish the game to get the “Temptation” achievement during the epilogue.

Petting The Teacher

Load your save from February 13th, and on the 17th say:
“We shouldn’t see each other anymore”

Finish the game by beating the final boss, and say:
“I expect a reward for my silence”
“What I want is your intimate personal instruction...”

During the epilogue, you will get the “Petting The Teacher” achievement.

[GreatWyrmGold]

I got the Temptation achievement by just following my instincts and being nice to Mallory. I'm not sure why it's apparently such a tough achievement to get. Apparently, it's easier to make Rowan your slave than it is to make a cuddle bug want to cuddle you.
...That, or more people want to make the quiet, inoffensive girl serve them than want to make the energetic entomology-loving girl happy, but I'd rather pretend that's not plausible.