𝘎𝘰𝘰𝘥 𝘦𝘯𝘥𝘪𝘯𝘨 𝘧𝘰𝘳 𝙩𝙝𝙚 𝙒𝙧𝙖𝙞𝙩𝙝.

In total, you can do eight possible endings to get the Completionist Achievement in Hooked on You. However, there are other storylines you can unlock to gain hidden rewards that reveal the secrets of Murderer’s Island.

The Wraith is probably the most sincere and nicest of all the Killers, so he isn’t too hard to romance. He values two things in conversations: being honest and the subject of grandmothers (he loves his Grandma Abi.)

Before we start with this list of conclusions, players should know that the questionnaire at the beginning doesn’t affect anything and we won’t include any answers for that part of the storyline.

𝘋𝘢𝘺 𝙊𝙣𝙚

The Wraith is pretty easy to impress on the first day as long as you are polite and consistently tell the truth. Here is a list of things you should say to him at the start of Hooked on You:

• Kick it back
  
  
• Choose the beach icon to go to the pool
  
  
• Goggles and snorkel
  
  
• Hands off
  
  
• Have some fun
  
  
• “I’m sorry”
  
  
• Tell him “No” (when he asks if you could be as shy and nervous as someone like him)
  
  
• Hold the bell delicately
  
  
• Choose The Wraith in storytime
  
  
• Ask about the story
  
  
• “I would forgive him”

Say, “Yes” after The Wraith asks you more about the story

𝘋𝘢𝘺 𝙏𝙬𝙤

Once you decide to partake in the hangout event with Wraith, he’ll take you to The Cosmic Dump. These interactions are what you should say to him:

• Break the silence
  
  
• “I have no idea”
  
  
• Mix those potions!
  
  
• “I remember my grandmother”
  
  
• “What’s the table for?”
  
  
• Smile
  
  
• Truth or Dare produces the same result
  
  
• “Hmm, great question”
  
  
• “Cactus”
  
  
• “Show me something”
  
  
• “You’re a hypocrite” or say nothing

The Wraith will bring you to his hidden lair after your conversation with The Spirit. Then, you’ll decide where you should explore next in the area, and none of these selections will affect the storyline.

Eventually, the player will exit the lair and go to dinner. Here is the next set of dialogue you’ll have to choose:

• “Say you had a great time”
  
  
• “Fine, I’ll tell a story”
  
  
• “Romance”
  
  
• Choose The Wraith for storytime and the hangout event
  
  
• Ask what’s wrong
  
  
• Suggest throwing a frisbee
  
  
• Hug him

During the elimination round, don’t choose The Wraith

𝘋𝘢𝘺 𝙏𝙝𝙧𝙚𝙚

As always, the third day is the most critical time to steal The Wraith’s heart, and these are the interactions you should pick:

• “You could never disappoint me”
  
  
• Pick up that coin (it doesn’t affect this outcome)

Since you’ve misplaced The Wraith’s bell, you’ll need to investigate the Killers’ locations.

The Black Lighthouse (The Spirit) is the first choice, and your decisions don’t matter in this part of the Hooked on You.

The second is the Trapper’s Cave; you’ll have to be careful here, or else you’ll die. Here’s what you need to do to stay alive:

• Look around the cave
  
  
• Pick up the coin if you want
  
  
• Quit while you’re ahead
  
  
• Bribe him/tell him you’re pranking Wraith

At the Huntress’s Cabin, it is essential to tell her, “Say you’re pranking Wraith,” because she will instantly kill you if you don’t.

You’ll have to interact with The Spirit to get Wraith’s bell when you finish these tasks. In this part, any decision will do, but you should still try to accurately win the precision game (you don’t have to be perfect.)

Then, it’s time to bring back the bell to Wraith and pick these selections:

• “What are we finishing?”
  
  
• “A statue of a horse”
  
  
• “Cactus”

During your conversation with Grandma Abi, you’ll have the opportunity to prove your worth with a Constellation Trivia or a Cornhole minigame.

If you choose the trivia quiz, these are the correct answers:

• “Cetus”
  
  
• “The Zodiac”
  
  
• “Horologium”

All you have to do after this is pick ‘Accept Wraith’s Love,’ and you will now trigger the Blood Pact achievement.

𝘽𝙖𝙙 𝘌𝘯𝘥𝘪𝘯𝘨

When you’ve done most of the steps of Wraith’s good ending, you’ll be asked to accept or reject his love, so choose the option “Reject Wraith’s love.”

Two dialogues will come up after you deny him: “Tell him the others were right about him” and “Tell him you’re not a killer.” The first selection will give you the Star Killer ending, a storyline where you break The Wraith’s heart, while the second produces The Wraith’s Wreckage achievement (he kills you.)

[STRONG THE BUDO]

Hi! Your guide is awesome, but I might have an important note:
IF YOU ELIMINATE TRAPPER and you choose to pick up the coin in his cave and then "quit while you are ahead" he will show up and kill you (no choice to be made), and the narrator makes it pretty clear that it's because you eliminated him.
So, to avoid this, you just DO NOT PICK UP THE COIN, if you do this, then you will be fine.

[🦉]

good guide thanks