As someone who have played P3, P3FES and P3P, I have :

100% The Game
Done all Social Links
Completed all Requests
Fused every persona
Defeated Elizabeth

And I would do it all over again.

The combat and UI was clean, the potential for players to min-max while staying easy enough for the casual audience, the challenge was perfect. The game innovated on the Persona style while keeping it faithful to the original. The bosses stayed true in terms of theme but they innovated and added slight twists and turns that will surprise and delight players who have ran through the original.

As someone who have played P3, P3FES and P3P, I have : 100% The Game Done all Social Links Completed all Requests Fused every persona [spoiler] Defeated Elizabeth [/spoiler] And I would do it all over again. The combat and UI was clean, the potential for players to min-max while staying easy enough for the casual audience, the challenge was perfect. The game innovated on the Persona style while keeping it faithful to the original. The bosses stayed true in terms of theme but they innovated and added slight twists and turns that will surprise and delight players who have ran through the original.