First game of the series I play and I was pleasantly surprised. Voice acting, character design, art direction and animation, writing and ui are all great. I also like the little clues scattered across all dialogues, the little meta jokes, the ending, and how the game tells you "we'll get to that later" when you pick a clue that could be valid instead of flat out saying "no".
It suffers from a couple of minor issues that most point&click/mystery games have: two of the puzzles I found annoying/hard to understand (pinboard and pirate keys), sometimes you get stuck because you forgot to click on an unassuming part of a room that happened to be an important clue (easily solved by clicking on the hint button) and the gameplay loop of going back and forth and exhausting all dialogues of all items x all characters can get boring (it could be solved by adding some time mechanic that forced you to be smarter about what to ask of whom; but then again, time mechanics can be stressful, so I guess it's not that bad).

First game of the series I play and I was pleasantly surprised. Voice acting, character design, art direction and animation, writing and ui are all great. I also like the little clues scattered across all dialogues, the little meta jokes, the ending, and how the game tells you "we'll get to that later" when you pick a clue that could be valid instead of flat out saying "no". It suffers from a couple of minor issues that most point&click/mystery games have: two of the puzzles I found annoying/hard to understand (pinboard and pirate keys), sometimes you get stuck because you forgot to click on an unassuming part of a room that happened to be an important clue (easily solved by clicking on the hint button) and the gameplay loop of going back and forth and exhausting all dialogues of all items x all characters can get boring (it could be solved by adding some time mechanic that forced you to be smarter about what to ask of whom; but then again, time mechanics can be stressful, so I guess it's not that bad).