I think you'll be surprised by the Sam storyline, I know I was! And yes, you can romance both of your friends as well as Diana. I'm thrilled that it's resonating with you as much as it did with me!!

Without finishing all of the paths my current feeling:
James is awesome! (Yes, I know. It's a trope. They all are. ;p )
Damien is cute but unfortunately put himself in the brother zone immediately and I am having a hard time seeing him otherwise.
Erik is definitely not a keeper but I want to play. I'll probably play him next.
Matthew is too young for me. Cute, though.
Sam is an ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥, for reasons. I'll probably play his storyline once to see it.
Andrew kind of reminds me a bit too much of grandpa but I'll play through it.

It feels like you can romance the girls, too? I may play through flags on one just to see if it has any new cool storyline.

Not done yet. I've finished three playthroughs (2 losses). I am thinking I will put my final thoughts in a blog because I want to delve into why it resonates with me. I'm enjoying it a lot but I am seeing the game behind the game which happens, of course. I'm not using any walkthroughs or anything preferring to find the flags myself. >^_-<

Heh, I know what that's like, the old "pause and do stuff in the house or attend a waking child". :D You need to give me your Twiiter so I can follow!! The boys storyline aren't radically different from one another (although my favorite is James), but you should also give Andrew a go! Hehe...

Always assume any hour count on steam on my account is multiplied by at least 1.3 times. probably more like 1.5. I'm bad about pausing and running to something in the house, lol.

I'm going to reserve opinion until I have made three bois mine. Mwahahaa! Finishing James first. Work and household kept tearing me away.

Initial impressions: Mmmm, hmmm, okay. Here's the trope. Woah...! This could be the best game ever.... wait.... shouldn't I call the police?

Yeah, they'll help solve the boy band with superhuman love powers broke into my mansion I just inherited story.....

Mai? What are you doing? Are we going to go to....

Yep, I'm digging it so far, but I think a visual novel needs at least three storylines completed before I'll give my opinion.

(Side note. I just realized you can take screenshots with F12. I've been taking them with my phone and posting them to twitter, lol.)