STEAM GROUP
Thief 1 & 2 Crew T1-2C
STEAM GROUP
Thief 1 & 2 Crew T1-2C
0
IN-GAME
30
ONLINE
Founded
May 27, 2019
Ranking Every Thief Gold, II & DS Mission
For the fun of it, and because I'm bored, I've decided to 'rank' every mission in the original trilogy. Feel free to share your own rankings (you don't have to include every game).
I hope thirdkeeper doesn't mind me including DS here as well given that this is a Thief 1 & 2 group.

1. The Sword - Thief the Dark Project (10/10): Trippy genius. Best level of all time.
2. The Haunted Cathedral - Thief the Dark Project (10/10): Second best level of all time.
3. Robbing the Cradle - Thief Deadly Shadows (9.5/10): Terrifying. Exceptional.
4. Into the Pagan Sanctuary - Thief Deadly Shadows (9.5/10): Fantastic atmosphere.
5. Return to the Cathedral - Thief the Dark Project (9.5/10): Unsettling, sensational.
6. St. Edgar's Eve - Thief Deadly Shadows (9.5/10): For the same reasons as above.
7. End of the Bloodline - Thief Deadly Shadows (9/10): Perfect introduction.
8. Precious Cargo - Thief II: The Metal Age (9/10): Great rainy vibe and detailed design.
9. The Mage Towers - Thief Gold (9/10): Fantastic atmosphere and wholly unique.
10. Down In the Bonehoard - Thief the Dark Project (9/10): Huge and very special.
11. Lord Bafford's Manor - Thief the Dark Project (9/10): Excellent introduction.
12. Escape! - Thief the Dark Project (8.5/10): Visually awesome with the best cutscene.
13. Blackmail - Thief II: The Metal Age (8.5/10): Don't like the feel of it but still brilliant.
14. First City Bank and Trust - Thief II: The Metal Age (8.5/10): Excellent thievery.
15. House of the Widow Moira - Thief Deadly Shadows (8.5/10): Superb soundtrack.
16. Life of the Party - Thief II: The Metal Age (8/10): Size is overrated. Building layout too.
17. Trail of Blood - Thief II: The Metal Age (8/10): Actual design is average. Cool visuals.
18. Strange Bedfellows - Thief the Dark Project (8/10): Precursor to Escape!'s greatness.
19. Still Life with Blackjack - Thief Deadly Shadows (8/10): Too much throwback crap.
20. Eavesdropping - Thief II: The Metal Age (8/10): Great layout and atmosphere.
21. Killing Time - Thief Deadly Shadows (8/10): Disappointingly linear but great vibe.
22. The Lost City - Thief the Dark Project (7.5/10): Interesting and memorable.
23. Of Brethren... And Betrayers - Thief Deadly Shadows (7.5/10): Too small, but decent.
24. Framed - Thief II: The Metal Age (7.5/10): Tied with the two above. Very good level.
25. Running Interference - Thief II: The Metal Age (7/10): Bit dull, but fun.
26. The Sunken Citadel - Thief Deadly Shadows (7/10): Silly and glitchy but enjoyable.
27. Sabotage at Soulforge - Thief II: The Metal Age (7/10): Truly massive... and difficult.
28. Shipping... and Receiving - Thief II: The Metal Age (6.5/10): Tedious as hell.
29. Assassins - Thief the Dark Project (6.5/10): Gone off this one a lot for some reason.
30. Thieves' Guild - Thief Gold (6/10): I quite like it but it is too big and tedious.
31. Break From Cragscleft Prison - Thief the Dark Project (6/10): Somewhat tedious.
32. Into the Maw of Chaos - Thief the Dark Project (5.5/10): As a finale? It's fine.
33. Casing the Joint - Thief II: The Metal Age (5/10): Below average and forgettable.
34. Undercover - Thief Gold (5/10): A bit of a drag after the first time. Still good, though.
35. Song of the Caverns - Thief Gold (4/10): Dislike the concept and hate the layout.
36. Kidnap - Thief II: The Metal Age (3.5/10): Like The Lost City, but incredibly tedious.
37. Ambush! - Thief II: The Metal Age (3/10): Empty city, tedious level design.
38. Trace the Courier - Thief II: The Metal Age (2/10): Snore-fest.
39. Masks - Thief II: The Metal Age (2/10): Worse repeat of a below average level.
40. Checking Inn, Checking Out - Thief Deadly Shadows (2/10): On rails tutorial.
41. A Keeper's Training - Thief the Dark Project (2/10): Good... for a tutorial.

Average Mission Placing (Thief the Dark Project & Thief Deadly Shadows tutorial levels excluded):
Thief Gold - 15 (Out of 11 missions, also my favourite game)
Thief II: The Metal Age - 25 (Out of 15 missions)
Thief Deadly Shadows - 13 (Out of 9 missions)
Last edited by Francisè von Spitroast; May 3, 2020 @ 4:18pm
< >
Showing 1-1 of 1 comments
thirdkeeper May 3, 2020 @ 4:25pm 
34. Undercover - Thief Gold (5/10): A bit of a drag after the first time. Still good, though.

Terrific ! - Can you help the guy who just asked about the gate in Undercover?

It's been too long for my brain to remember..
< >
Showing 1-1 of 1 comments
Per page: 1530 50