kwrty Sep 20, 2017 @ 5:07pm
Found a user who stole my artwork, what can I do?
So when I was just browsing Steam I found a user that had uploaded the artwork that I made myself in After Effects. http://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=1133526675 This is the link to the one he uploaded, here is mine: http://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=1127750046 . You can see by the dates alone that he uploaded after me.

I was pretty♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥off so I commented asking him to remove it but he deleted the comment and made it so you can not comment on the post. Now I am not sure what to do to get him to delete it as I can't comment anywhere on his page and I doubt he would accept a friend request to talk this through. I've read that I can file a DMCA take down for this however I also read that the other user can see my private info if I do this, so I'm not sure that this is the right way to go. So I was wondering, is there anyway to get the Steam mods to remove this or something? I've reported him, however that usually doesn't work...

EDIT: I don't actually own the rights to the GIF I made because I used someone else's logo, so y'all can stop commenting. I will gladly delete the art I uploaded if the other guys does.
Last edited by kwrty; Sep 21, 2017 @ 4:01pm
< >
Showing 1-15 of 19 comments
999999999 Sep 20, 2017 @ 5:20pm 
Report the artwork.
mimizukari Sep 20, 2017 @ 5:31pm 
you can only dmca takedown if you have a copyright on the artwork, and if you do, yes, your information has to be made public to issue dmca takedown.
Matt Sep 20, 2017 @ 5:54pm 
The answer is the DMCA request, which isn't something to take lightly. Does it really bother you that much?? Reporting is no good, because a moderator can't determine if the artwork really belongs to you.
Crystal Sharrd Sep 20, 2017 @ 7:07pm 
This is just me, but I would sue him/her for all (s)he's worth. But I'm pretty sure you first have to issue a DMCA takedown order.
Zekiran Sep 20, 2017 @ 7:58pm 
Originally posted by Matt:
The answer is the DMCA request, which isn't something to take lightly. Does it really bother you that much?? Reporting is no good, because a moderator can't determine if the artwork really belongs to you.

As long as the artist supplies the information necessary, DMCA is the best way to go. When I report artwork, it's with a link to the original (usually over on deviantart) but it's still up to the owner of the artwork to send a takedown order. When I see those jerks stealing great art and getting lots of thumbs up for it - and no link, no request, and usually stolen from people who specifically ask not to repost their work - I *always* inform the original creator.

So... DMCA, if the art in question is yours, that's your right and your responsibility, no one else can do that.
Ztarman Sep 20, 2017 @ 8:16pm 
I remember when the same **** happened to me a year ago. The only option is to report and move on.

"Naming and shaming" also isn't allowed on the site.
You could hire a DCMA service to handle that for you, so you don't have to reveal your personal info (it's similar to private registration of domains). That's how they do it on YouTube with take downs.
kwrty Sep 20, 2017 @ 9:08pm 
Damn, well this sucks a bit. I'm not sure that I would actually be eligible for applying for the DMCA because I don't really have much proof that I created the art (other than AE file). Thanks for the replies though.

I guess in future I better water mark anything I make and upload it to DeviantArt or something prior to uploading it on Steam to avoid **** like this happening.
Last edited by kwrty; Sep 20, 2017 @ 9:09pm
kwrty Sep 20, 2017 @ 9:38pm 
Originally posted by AustrAlien2010:
Ofcourse it can be proven whether you made it or not. Servers use timestamps as well. But sueing someone for such a small offense doesn´t seem right, somehow. You should pardon the pour sod, imho.

Yeah I understand what you mean, sueing someone for this does seem a bit wrong. I just wish that stuff like this wouldn't happen in the first place so I wouldn't even have to bother with this.
Ztarman Sep 20, 2017 @ 11:51pm 
Originally posted by AustrAlien2010:
You could try referring to your thread. And again ask politely to remove it, or at the very least give proper credit. Maybe then he/she will listen to you.

Not happening.

He already said this individual deleted his comment which means they don't give a **** and will pass of his artwork as their own without giving credit (which was their intention in the first place).

There's nothing he can do besides "upgrade" it or pray that the community will help get it pulled down (which I doubt). Why Valve allows this nonsense to happen in the first place is a mystery to m... oh wait, zero quality control and no safety for content creators.
Start_Running Sep 21, 2017 @ 1:17am 
Originally posted by kẅrty:
Damn, well this sucks a bit. I'm not sure that I would actually be eligible for applying for the DMCA because I don't really have much proof that I created the art (other than AE file). Thanks for the replies though.

I guess in future I better water mark anything I make and upload it to DeviantArt or something prior to uploading it on Steam to avoid **** like this happening.

Proof of publication prior to the offender's publication is typically a good way to start. A post to another site for example. That site will have records of when the piece was uploaded to their server so the offender would have to prove that they had it before your publication.

Even where they say they had the file on their computer they would have toe xplain how the hell you got it if they'd never published it in any way that can be proven.

This is why as an artist it's always a good idea to tag your work in some way. Most artists will slip the signature in somewhere and in a manner that is otherwise unapparent to the viewer. Like say hiding a black box with a scan of their siugnature in one frame of the animation.. FOr any animation running faster than 24 fps this is pretty much impossible for the human eye to pick up.
Paul Sep 21, 2017 @ 1:26pm 
Originally posted by AustrAlien2010:
It's not really theft, if nothing was taken.

Kẅrty also has not yet responded to my inquiries. I wonder why. I relished another one of these cases.
I did a search of that persons profile picture (the lady), which led to a bunch of that same picture used places, but I saw a lot of "MXDVS" so I searched that, found a store with that rose and knife thing on it; "Cross hatching of a flower and shivs Drawing by Max for MXDVS" the "Max" had a link that went to an instagram "mxdvs" that says: "Max Reynders 🕊 creative director of @ateliermxdvs antwerp based illustrator n stylist"

leading me to believe: the OP took that logo thingy, ploped it on a AE background effect, and claimed it as their own artwork.

:BITRAY_CrazyCube:
kwrty Sep 21, 2017 @ 3:50pm 
Originally posted by SparkyCarton:
Originally posted by AustrAlien2010:
It's not really theft, if nothing was taken.

Kẅrty also has not yet responded to my inquiries. I wonder why. I relished another one of these cases.
I did a search of that persons profile picture (the lady), which led to a bunch of that same picture used places, but I saw a lot of "MXDVS" so I searched that, found a store with that rose and knife thing on it; "Cross hatching of a flower and shivs Drawing by Max for MXDVS" the "Max" had a link that went to an instagram "mxdvs" that says: "Max Reynders 🕊 creative director of @ateliermxdvs antwerp based illustrator n stylist"

leading me to believe: the OP took that logo thingy, ploped it on a AE background effect, and claimed it as their own artwork.

:BITRAY_CrazyCube:

This is why I realised that I can't do a DMCA thing after I read all of the terms. I really like that brand (have the hoodie with that design on it) and wanted to make a Steam Art work out of it. So, yeah, I technically do not own the logo so I don't have the rights to the Artwork, but what I was annoyed about in this case is that someone took the GIF I made with that drawing with out crediting or asking me or whatever. And it was not an AE background effect, I made it myself by layering with stock footage of a VHS tape being crushed.

To be clear, I don't plan to try to do anything about this because I can't call the GIF completely my creation, I guess, since I used someone else's logo.
Last edited by kwrty; Sep 21, 2017 @ 3:51pm
Originally posted by SparkyCarton:
Originally posted by AustrAlien2010:
It's not really theft, if nothing was taken.

Kẅrty also has not yet responded to my inquiries. I wonder why. I relished another one of these cases.
I did a search of that persons profile picture (the lady), which led to a bunch of that same picture used places, but I saw a lot of "MXDVS" so I searched that, found a store with that rose and knife thing on it; "Cross hatching of a flower and shivs Drawing by Max for MXDVS" the "Max" had a link that went to an instagram "mxdvs" that says: "Max Reynders 🕊 creative director of @ateliermxdvs antwerp based illustrator n stylist"

leading me to believe: the OP took that logo thingy, ploped it on a AE background effect, and claimed it as their own artwork.

:BITRAY_CrazyCube:

Which can explain the silence of the suggestion to get a third party take down service if he was so worried about his identity being known.

People hate them at YouTube, but for legit reasons they are great (especially with website owners and site scrappers).
kwrty Sep 21, 2017 @ 3:54pm 
Originally posted by KEVYNE_KICKLIGHTER:
Originally posted by SparkyCarton:
I did a search of that persons profile picture (the lady), which led to a bunch of that same picture used places, but I saw a lot of "MXDVS" so I searched that, found a store with that rose and knife thing on it; "Cross hatching of a flower and shivs Drawing by Max for MXDVS" the "Max" had a link that went to an instagram "mxdvs" that says: "Max Reynders 🕊 creative director of @ateliermxdvs antwerp based illustrator n stylist"

leading me to believe: the OP took that logo thingy, ploped it on a AE background effect, and claimed it as their own artwork.

:BITRAY_CrazyCube:

Which can explain the silence of the suggestion to get a third party take down service if he was so worried about his identity being known.

People hate them at YouTube, but for legit reasons they are great (especially with website owners and site scrappers).

I don't like the idea of random people on the internet knowing my identity. And I had decided against doing the third party take down before I even considered that I didn't own the logo in the Art.
< >
Showing 1-15 of 19 comments
Per page: 1530 50

Date Posted: Sep 20, 2017 @ 5:07pm
Posts: 19