Is communism good on paper?

[🌠Deusgo]

Clearly it don’t work in humans, the person at the top tends to be a ♥♥♥♥ bag, but with another civilisation, that of robots per say, without greed or the need to hate see it fruitful?

[Magma Dragoon]

If something is bad in practice it is bad in theory.

[TheHogfather]

The best place for communism is to stay on the paper

[Philco7a]

Of all the communist Governments over the decades not 1 has ever given out free crack pipes to its peasants....until Joe Biden came along....
You can never be arrested with a Joey Biden issued crack pipe, would be entrapment. And that there makes Biden Communism the best Communism.

[Top Cat]

Escrito originalmente por Deusgo:

Is communism good on paper?

Yeah, toilet paper.

[saranacX]

It's a great weight loss plan.

[Reddari]

Escrito originalmente por Philco7a:

Of all the communist Governments over the decades not 1 has ever given out free crack pipes to its peasants....until Joe Biden came along....
You can never be arrested with a Joey Biden issued crack pipe, would be entrapment. And that there makes Biden Communism the best Communism.

Communism and government are oxymorons. There is no division by class or status in communism. In none of the pretend communists states has this been true. You can't have a person with different status come take your things as every thing is supposed to belong to the community and the person that takes your stuff is not supposed to exist in communism.
The whole thing has been a deception just like most other forms of government and politics.

Your example also makes no sense in communism because again... the crack pipes would be already property of the community, the special status people "of the government" can't exist by the fundamental premise of communism. The division of class - government people and peasants cannot exist. EVERYONE is supposed to be of the SAME class.

It is a big ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ lie about the same as what ANARCHY actually is. Nearly every media depiction of anarchy is actually showing the opposite of anarchy - it shows gangs of thugs which is a bunch of ARCHONS that run around and rule over others. An-archy is supposed to have NO ARCHONS. So the reason anarchy does not work is because people who are NOT anarchist. You got thugs who are not anarchists and the people who follow other thugs are themselves not anarchists. You get bunch of people who organize into a HIER-Archy - not An-Archy. There is a clear Archia there damnit, not No-Archia.

All of this goes over the head of common man and I forgive those who don't get it.
Both of these concepts have been so heavily distorted because they are both very antithetical to existence of government.

[Ulfrinn]

Not even on paper. The only papers that say otherwise are the ones remaining after communism is done filtering through the information to decide what is okay for you to read.

[Hobbit XIII]

How many people answering this thread have read the communist manifesto?

[sleeps]

Escrito originalmente por Corvus XIII:

How many people answering this thread have read the communist manifesto?

I assume that the capital is a legit reflection and criticism of the systems they had. the manifesto however is like if he had a manic attack

[Reddari]

Escrito originalmente por sleeps:

Escrito originalmente por Corvus XIII:

How many people answering this thread have read the communist manifesto?

I assume that the capital is a legit reflection and criticism of the systems they had. the manifesto however is like if he had a manic attack

He probably had. A little demon came around and made him write that BS. There is another problem why communism and anarchy does not work for humanity. Humanity is not alone - this world is full of mental parasites. Every conscious human being has hundreds or even over a thousand of these attachments that alter their behavior. Pure humans would help each-other, its in their nature. But practically no human on Earth is pure. Even more ironic is that those closest to pure tend to be aliens in human skin suit who know about these parasites.

[アキウアラ]

Escrito originalmente por Deusgo:

Clearly it don’t work in humans, the person at the top tends to be a ♥♥♥♥ bag, but with another civilisation, that of robots per say, without greed or the need to hate see it fruitful?

Yes on paper it is very good.

[oldirty`]

Which paper? There are many.

[bAd a!m]

the best system would be something akin to what they had in startrek, where the people worked in order to better themselves.

also, if the whole earth was united, a global socialist communist system would be the best in order to maximize the efficiency of the human race and provide the required resources to everybody.

[El Mythical 23 k.s.c.]

Yeah good on paper.

[Ulfrinn]

The only paper communism belongs on is toilet paper.