Whats wrong with saying men cant give birth?

[76561199699838894]

Im a transguy myself and i dont get why its wrong to say men cant give birth...

[ZZZZZ]

Origineel geplaatst door Xautos:

Origineel geplaatst door ZZZZZ:

definition of birth is actually quite wide

Giving birth is the act of pushing down muscular contractions that pushes the baby out of the uterus and genitalia into the world by the new mother. That is the definition of giving birth. Their bodies are designed that way on purpose so they can give birth.

It's the same as it is for a lot of other animals that carry their young to term and end up pushing them out. That's giving birth.

When was the last time a man was able to give birth to a child by pushing it out through their penis?

The definition is not as wide as you think and babies can be extricated from an artificial womb by way of c-section but by definition it's not giving birth, since the baby is stuck in that womb until it dies or is cut out.

u describe a certain kind of birth, there are multiple types tho.. like even a fish dropping an egg counts as birth by definition.. all creations of offsprings count as birth in the wide definition

[BunnieBealla]

my dad was pregnant
at least that's what he said before he left
he's been at that hospital for quite a while now uwu

[replika]

Origineel geplaatst door BunnieBealla:

my dad was pregnant
at least that's what he said before he left
he's been at that hospital for quite a while now uwu

internal bleeding

[the vampire of time and memory]

Origineel geplaatst door AdahnGorion:

Origineel geplaatst door the vampire of time and memory:

I mean some trans guys can, so it would be untrue

No it would not, because one is a gender and the other is sex.
Sex is rooted in biology, whereas gender is rooted in psychology

Its not all biological females that can give birth ofc, but in most cases they can and have the regular typical productive organs for it and the corrent genoms.

Males can´t birth naturally in our species, its rooted in biology


From a biological pow, there are two main sexes and then we have situations where people are born with genetic alternation and both working sex organs.. So its not black and white ofc.. its grey.. but genders.. genders is something you feel and you can be whatever gender you want, but that wont change your biological sex.

sorry tldr, trans guys are men

[意味のない人生]

Origineel geplaatst door AdahnGorion:

Origineel geplaatst door the vampire of time and memory:

I mean some trans guys can, so it would be untrue

No it would not, because one is a gender and the other is sex.
Sex is rooted in biology, whereas gender is rooted in psychology

Its not all biological females that can give birth ofc, but in most cases they can and have the regular typical productive organs for it and the corrent genoms.

Males can´t birth naturally in our species, its rooted in biology


From a biological pow, there are two main sexes and then we have situations where people are born with genetic alternation and both working sex organs.. So its not black and white ofc.. its grey.. but genders.. genders is something you feel and you can be whatever gender you want, but that wont change your biological sex.

The idea of sex vs gender goes over a lot of people's heads. I find that people often use the terms interchangeably, which muddies up the discussions because they are two very different things.

To the OP, just because one identifies as a man or a woman does not mean their biology is going to reflect that in any way. Nothing wrong with telling people the truth in that context. I personally think it's significantly worse to just let folks spread misinformation as it has the potential to do a lot more harm in the long run.

[WhiteKnight77]

Bait thread.

[Shadow]

A man would die from the pain, women are designed for it, it's biology

[Hobbit XIII]

If we take the media of movies as an example.

Life of Brian says it is the right of a man to give birth and whether he can or not is irrelevant it is about having the right to.

Junior starring Devito and Schwarzenegger, says it is ok to for a man to give birth through science.

Roy Chubby Brown in the film UFO, says it is impractical for himself to give birth. The females disagree and show that he can give birth through his bottom.

So I think it is really up to the people to decide from these three films what really should be there chosen way on this subject.

-in my humble opinion.

[Krypto]

Men don't have a uterus, or fallopian tubes, or ovaries, or produce eggs.

That's all you really need to know.

Biology and your feelings don't mix.

[Frankie]

Origineel geplaatst door Xero_Daxter:

Well they can’t. It’s basic biology.

/thread. What is wrong with these people?

[20000Aggro]

Biological males can't give birth, a person legally considered to be a man can if they were born female.

[AerSilver ♞]

Origineel geplaatst door kiritokunloverkawaiidesu420xD:

Whats wrong with saying men cant give birth?

Absolutely nothing.

[Krypto]

Origineel geplaatst door Gamgam:

Biological males can't give birth, a person legally considered to be a man can if they were born female.

Still a female regardless.

[Painkilleruk]

seriously.... another bait post.

It is common sense
Men are incapable of birthing babies, biology 101 man provides DNA female carries and acts as host.
Women that transition to men are still women ergo can have children again basic and simple
I could identify as a rtx 9090 dont mean if I plug a monitor cable in my backside it will thrash 8k gaming with high FPS does it.

[Insomniac Jack]

It's not wrong it's just delusional.