All Discussions > Steam Forums > Off Topic > Topic Details
< >
Showing 16-30 of 78 comments
Originally posted by Masque:
Originally posted by I HeaR vOices:
Didn't they paywall some of their stuff? If that's correct then it's not surprising Nintendo got them.
Yes. Those old enough remember that this is why Bleem! was taken out by Sony. It was a working Playstation One emulator (when the PS1 was still just called the Playstation, and was still immensely popular in stores). For a couple of months, you could buy Bleem! at the store, with all the other boxed PC programs. Sony's lawyers weren't cool with that.
Bleem! got drained dry even though Sony lost every lawsuit they threw at it. It was ruled completely legal since the code was all original.

You should stop spreading misinformation.
Dagný Mar 4, 2024 @ 8:28pm 
Originally posted by Masque:
Originally posted by Dagný:
yep

CEMU is still available and Nintendo never went for it. Ryujinx (which is better than YUZU) might be safe. CITRA going down is a real shame.
CEMU didn't bypass decryption. If you wanted to play a game on Cemu you had to find all the arcane tools and codes necessary to decrypt the games first.

According to the decision here, and one of the reasons why the suit succeeded, was that Yuzu bypassed all that. Basically it was too easy.

If we're talking about being ez CEMU is much easier, all you need are the game files
YUZU/Ryujinx need prod keys and firmware both up to date

The main difference between the 3 is that YUZU devs were making money out of nintendo's properties and that's probably an easier case to win
Tiberius Mar 4, 2024 @ 8:30pm 
That was quick
D. Flame Mar 4, 2024 @ 9:48pm 
Told you so. Emulation of this manner is NEVER a legal gray area for modern consoles. Just like I said, it violates the DMCA. If you have to break the copy protection on the games to use it, then it is illegal.

The only thing that might still be legal is if they made actual hardware that could play the original games, like how you can now buy 3rd party consoles that have slots to play both original NES and Super NES cartridges (you still have to buy the original games themselves).
sleeps Mar 4, 2024 @ 10:02pm 
at least dolphin is not involved. if it is, it's joever.
Masque Mar 4, 2024 @ 10:09pm 
Originally posted by SlowMango:
Originally posted by Masque:
Yes. Those old enough remember that this is why Bleem! was taken out by Sony. It was a working Playstation One emulator (when the PS1 was still just called the Playstation, and was still immensely popular in stores). For a couple of months, you could buy Bleem! at the store, with all the other boxed PC programs. Sony's lawyers weren't cool with that.
Bleem! got drained dry even though Sony lost every lawsuit they threw at it. It was ruled completely legal since the code was all original.

You should stop spreading misinformation.
Sony's lawyers drained Bleem!'s devs dry because they weren't cool with that.

What misinformation is contained in my comment?

Did I say -- anywhere in the comment -- that Bleem! was judged illegal?

(Upon closer examination, Mango determined that, no, Masque did not say that at all.)

Settle down, Mango. :amadeus_happy:
Last edited by Masque; Mar 4, 2024 @ 10:09pm
76561198106954062 Mar 4, 2024 @ 10:19pm 
I prefer ryujinx anyway
Stranger Mar 4, 2024 @ 10:23pm 
yuzu was a popular fruit and still is
Zer0Shade Mar 4, 2024 @ 11:22pm 
"You'll play our games at 720p, sub-30FPS and you'll like it!"
MistyMountainHop Mar 4, 2024 @ 11:30pm 
I read this thread title wrong and thought it was going to be about Yuzo Koshiro.
Valfossa Mar 5, 2024 @ 3:43am 
Originally posted by Blue-Eyes Toon Dragon:
Wait until someone uses the source code of Yuzu to make a copycat emulator
Um, there's about 4.1k forks of Yuzu on Github, so yeah it's already started.

Here's one
https://github.com/Bogieloo/Luzu
Electric Cupcake Mar 5, 2024 @ 3:46am 
Citra forks too, I hope?
gugnihr Mar 5, 2024 @ 3:49am 
Nintendo sucks, it is evil and need to die, but I stopped using Yuzu years ago because it was too buggy / glitchy. The other emulator works better.
It's more sad for Citra as far as I know there are no alternatives for now and it works fine.
gugnihr Mar 5, 2024 @ 3:55am 
Originally posted by 016R35:
Nintendo always win the battles, but they will never win the war.

Probably yes, which is great. Sony tried to do the same during the PS1 era, well it didn't exactly work lol.
I hope that Nintendo will go bankrupt soon, at this point they are only scammers and nothing else. There is no place for consoles anymore in this world and they have clearly no intentioon to change that, they only want to still get money from all the good they have done in the past in the most scammy ways possible. This is why I hope that they will go bankrupt soon. All it takes is just another Wii U, and I cannot wait. It will be one of the most exciting days in human history.
Originally posted by D. Flame:
Told you so. Emulation of this manner is NEVER a legal gray area for modern consoles. Just like I said, it violates the DMCA. If you have to break the copy protection on the games to use it, then it is illegal.

The only thing that might still be legal is if they made actual hardware that could play the original games, like how you can now buy 3rd party consoles that have slots to play both original NES and Super NES cartridges (you still have to buy the original games themselves).
Except this lawsuit didn't prove the legality of it. The Yuzu devs folded instantly to avoid a trial.

As of right now, it still is a grey area because emulation itself is legal. Emulators(even for modern hardware) are legal if they don't supply the tools to bypass encryption. None of the modern emulators do.

Also, encryption measures weren't out in until the Wii for Nintendo and the PS1 for Sony. Yet bleem! was deemed legal while the PS1 was still being sold.
Last edited by Boblin the Goblin; Mar 5, 2024 @ 4:19am
< >
Showing 16-30 of 78 comments
Per page: 1530 50

All Discussions > Steam Forums > Off Topic > Topic Details
Date Posted: Mar 4, 2024 @ 3:50pm
Posts: 78