Do you think the concept of reincarnation is evil?

[Starfarer]

I mean the idea that you forget and lose all your loved ones and that your soul is forced against your will to go back into a physical body in an imperfect universe sounds pretty malevolent, no matter how much you argue about how it is meant to teach you lessons. Also, I’m referring to the classic concept of reincarnation, not the New Age concept of it where you have a choice in the matter.

This is just a thought and not intended to be a slant toward any religion.

[Starfarer]

引用自 Chalupabaras：

引用自 Not Big Surprise：

in a way it's kinda ♥♥♥♥♥♥

but at the same time, if that's the case then... is it really you anymore?

When you change your clothes, you are still you regardless of your changed appearance. Shuffling off your mortal coil is no different a concept. Besides, you're a ghost driving a meat coated skeleton made of stardust, riding a rock that's hurtling through space. What's there to worry about?

Your free will and reunion with the source of infinite love are two things you worry about so yeah.

[❤ Sly Succubus ❤]

Reincarnation? Eh no not really, cant say thats evil to start with because usually those that believe in reincarnation dont believe in good or evil to begin with, you die, you die, you get reborn.

Its like the most simple of way of saying "Life has birth and death, one day you'll die and be reborn as a cow, deal with it and some crying that you got bullied at school Grage!"

[nohuman]

引用自 Chalupabaras：

引用自 Not Big Surprise：

in a way it's kinda ♥♥♥♥♥♥

but at the same time, if that's the case then... is it really you anymore?

When you change your clothes, you are still you regardless of your changed appearance. Shuffling off your mortal coil is no different a concept. Besides, you're a ghost driving a meat coated skeleton made of stardust, riding a rock that's hurtling through space. What's there to worry about?

sort of like reinstalling windows hoping your computer gets faster, but then it doesn't.

[Sidakte]

引用自 Tonepoet：

As a concept? Not particularly. Just because somebody thinks the world is a certain way does not mean that person is evil. Not any more evil than the thought that gravity is going to keep us stuck on this rock until the diameter of the earth will expand to engulf the earth into a fiery demise. Not the mere thought or belief in it.

The notion that reincarnation as a force is quite awful is not exactly new though. In Tibeten Buddhism there is a scroll painting The Wheel of Life[www.gesar-travel.com], which serves is a graphical diagram of Samsara, which depicts animals depicting the three root evils in the center, the Six realms of Samsara, and the Twelve Bardos which represent stages in the reincarnation cycle. The pig represents ignorance, and naturally, if there was a past life you forgot, then you are ignorant of it.

On the back of it you have some big scary lookin' three-eyed pig nosed gannondorf deity with fangs holding up the wheel and chomping on the back of it as if it was a giant cookie. That is Yama, the god of death and his chomping away at the back of the wheel has been described to me as him devouring it to represent the impermanence of the cycle and that it'll come to an end.

The end goal for Buddhists has always been to achieve enlightenment and bring about the end of suffering altogether, which for some denominations includes the cycle of rebirth. That necessitates pointing out unpleasant realities if need be. Now whether or not this is actually reality is questionable, but the Buddhists believe it is. The world is how it is, and there is nothing malicious about trying to see it for how it is.

You can not have salvation without peril.

tyvm for this. seriously tyvm.

[Chalupacabaras]

引用自 Scurrybt：

引用自 Chalupabaras：

When you change your clothes, you are still you regardless of your changed appearance. Shuffling off your mortal coil is no different a concept. Besides, you're a ghost driving a meat coated skeleton made of stardust, riding a rock that's hurtling through space. What's there to worry about?

Your free will and reunion with the source of infinite love are two things you worry about so yeah.

Maybe for others. I've always had the underlying sense that if I "get it right" this time, I can go Home and never return here unless I choose to.

引用自 Not Big Surprise：

it's not so much the body
more so, your entire sense of continuity, all your memories, your identity, everything that you could point to in order to define yourself, all of that is lost

can you really say it's you who's being reincarnated at that point?

The past and the future do not exist, they are creations of your ego for the sake of its own self-preservation. Only the here and now is truly you, and you are not your self.

[Starfarer]

引用自 Chalupabaras：

引用自 Scurrybt：

Your free will and reunion with the source of infinite love are two things you worry about so yeah.

Maybe for others. I've always had the underlying sense that if I "get it right" this time, I can go Home and never return here unless I choose to.

引用自 Not Big Surprise：

it's not so much the body
more so, your entire sense of continuity, all your memories, your identity, everything that you could point to in order to define yourself, all of that is lost

can you really say it's you who's being reincarnated at that point?

The past and the future do not exist, they are creations of your ego for the sake of its own self-preservation. Only the here and now is truly you, and you are not your self.

Look into Gnosticism to understand how entities known as Archons and the Demiurge trick you into going back through reincarnation. Reincarnation is a masterful lie and jail designed for you to never go back to your true home. It is only though insight and faith through the higher force that you can actually break the cycle. You don’t own the universe any kind of lesson, as the material is false to begin with.

[Dutchgamer1982]

it is evil in the sence it is a lie.
-and of satan the father of lies.

buying into that lie will prevent you from seeking Christ and repend.
believing in the lie of reincarnation does not make it true and leads only to hell just as any other road thats not trough Christ.

It also feeds the pride in humans that we ever can earn heaven by our own works..

culturally nations with many believers in it have on the plus side more respect for nature/all living thins.

but on the downside much less emphathy for the poor.. the evil caste-system woulf not ecist without that reincarnation believe.

[Birds]

引用自 Not Big Surprise：

引用自 Chalupabaras：

When you change your clothes, you are still you regardless of your changed appearance. Shuffling off your mortal coil is no different a concept. Besides, you're a ghost driving a meat coated skeleton made of stardust, riding a rock that's hurtling through space. What's there to worry about?

it's not so much the body
more so, your entire sense of continuity, all your memories, your identity, everything that you could point to in order to define yourself, all of that is lost

can you really say it's you who's being reincarnated at that point?

Just because you define yourself by these things doesn't mean you actually are them.

[❤ Sly Succubus ❤]

引用自 Dutchgamer1982：

it is evil in the sence it is a lie.
-and of satan the father of lies.

buying into that lie will prevent you from seeking Christ and repend.
believing in the lie of reincarnation does not make it true and leads only to hell just as any other road thats not trough Christ.

It also feeds the pride in humans that we ever can earn heaven by our own works..

culturally nations with many believers in it have on the plus side more respect for nature/all living thins.

but on the downside much less emphathy for the poor.. the evil caste-system woulf not ecist without that reincarnation believe.

As far as I know, Satan was never mentioned in the bible to begin with, he was literally made up during the new testament which was done because King James I wanted to rule with power, even going as far to nearly be crusaded by the Vatican but they didnt because James himself ended up with the Baron Wars instead

Its rather ironic because something he forced in the book designed to instill fear ended up with his own death and collapse of his entire kingdom as a result and just lead to the English Reformation, like the dude himself would of been Satan and just ended up writting his own fate

[Chalupacabaras]

引用自 Scurrybt：

Look into Gnosticism to understand how entities known as Archons and the Demiurge trick you into going back through reincarnation. Reincarnation is a masterful lie and jail designed for you to never go back to your true home. It is only though insight and faith through the higher force that you can actually break the cycle. You don’t own the universe any kind of lesson, as the material is false to begin with.

On the contrary. The Demiurge, Archons and your puny god locked themselves into my cage and threw away the key.

[❤ Sly Succubus ❤]

引用自 Scurrybt：

引用自 Purple Heart：

As far as I know, Satan was never mentioned in the bible to begin with, he was literally made up during the new testament which was done because King James I wanted to rule with power, even going as far to nearly be crusaded by the Vatican but they didnt because James himself ended up with the Baron Wars instead

Its rather ironic because something he forced in the book designed to instill fear ended up with his own death and collapse of his entire kingdom as a result and just lead to the English Reformation, like the dude himself would of been Satan and just ended up writting his own fate

The Bible is a lie, as it includes the Old Testament. Only the New Testament is true as it’s closest to what Gnosticism taught, which is the true version of Christianity.

I hate to be "that guy" but both are literally books made to revolt against Rome, seriously a good portion of the both the New and Old are taken from Roman myths and Greek. Like Hell is just the Underworld, Satan is Hades, God is Zeus (Or Jupiter), the Arch Angels are the other gods, heck the Kingdom of God is literally just Mount Olympus, and the entire story of Jesus is part story of Hercules and part story of Baldr from the Norse, which is even called Dying-and-rising deity in just outright book writing now.

Like not many people grasp Christianity is a mashup of past religions, like devil literally means diabolic in Roman...IE, one who is Evil...that should tell you how far they bothered to even go with words.

[Starfarer]

引用自 Chalupabaras：

引用自 Scurrybt：

Look into Gnosticism to understand how entities known as Archons and the Demiurge trick you into going back through reincarnation. Reincarnation is a masterful lie and jail designed for you to never go back to your true home. It is only though insight and faith through the higher force that you can actually break the cycle. You don’t own the universe any kind of lesson, as the material is false to begin with.

On the contrary. The Demiurge, Archons and your puny god locked themselves into my cage and threw away the key.

A common thing is prisoners labeling themselves as gods to deny the reality that they are slaves. I do hope you enjoy staying in the material.

[Birds]

Most of the parables and situational examples presented in the bible are direct transliterations of babylonian law-myths, meant to illustrate common pitfalls of society one may fall into with the wrong set of thoughts.

[Chalupacabaras]

引用自 Purple Heart：

I hate to be "that guy" but both are literally books made to revolt against Rome, seriously a good portion of the both the New and Old are taken from Roman myths and Greek. Like Hell is just the Underworld, Satan is Hades, God is Zeus (Or Jupiter), the Arch Angels are the other gods, heck the Kingdom of God is literally just Mount Olympus, and the entire story of Jesus is part story of Hercules and part story of Baldr from the Norse, which is even called Dying-and-rising deity in just outright book writing now.

Like not many people grasp Christianity is a mashup of past religions, like devil literally means diabolic in Roman...IE, one who is Evil...that should tell you how far they bothered to even go with words.

Rome didn't speak Roman, they spoke Latin.

As for THE devil, his name was "ha'Saitan" in Hebrew. The rest were just plain ol' "saitan", which also meant "adversary" or "lawyer".

[❤ Sly Succubus ❤]

引用自 Chalupabaras：

引用自 Purple Heart：

I hate to be "that guy" but both are literally books made to revolt against Rome, seriously a good portion of the both the New and Old are taken from Roman myths and Greek. Like Hell is just the Underworld, Satan is Hades, God is Zeus (Or Jupiter), the Arch Angels are the other gods, heck the Kingdom of God is literally just Mount Olympus, and the entire story of Jesus is part story of Hercules and part story of Baldr from the Norse, which is even called Dying-and-rising deity in just outright book writing now.

Like not many people grasp Christianity is a mashup of past religions, like devil literally means diabolic in Roman...IE, one who is Evil...that should tell you how far they bothered to even go with words.

Rome didn't speak Roman, they spoke Latin.

As for THE devil, his name was "ha'Saitan" in Hebrew. The rest were just plain ol' "saitan", which also meant "adversary" or "lawyer".

Wait so your telling me that by history, Satan was just a really good lawyer?

...Makes to much sense given Jesus lost his trial- oh no.