What game is better?

[Tylenol baby]

Dark Souls 1 or Witcher 2?

[Cathulhu]

Witcher 2 should be the better experience as the port of Dark Souls is pretty bad.

[Necromancer]

Dark Souls

[Zubenelgenubi]

Witcher 2.

[ᵏᵃᵗᵗ]

They are entirely different.

[Jetstream Seum]

Is it even possible to compare two items without someone going "they're entirely different", despite their obvious similarities?

I haven't played either long enough to decide which one is the better game, but don't even bother with Dark Souls if you don't have a controller. It's also rather dated compared to The Witcher 2.

[tmwfte]

Witcher 2.

[GamerWolfOps]

Witcher 2.

[ᵏᵃᵗᵗ]

Originally posted by Devious:

Is it even possible to compare two items without someone going "they're entirely different", despite their obvious similarities?

I haven't played either long enough to decide which one is the better game, but don't even bother with Dark Souls if you don't have a controller. It's also rather dated compared to The Witcher 2.

How do they have any similarities whatsoever?

[Jetstream Seum]

Originally posted by RevKat:

Originally posted by Devious:

Is it even possible to compare two items without someone going "they're entirely different", despite their obvious similarities?

I haven't played either long enough to decide which one is the better game, but don't even bother with Dark Souls if you don't have a controller. It's also rather dated compared to The Witcher 2.

How do they have any similarities whatsoever?

Well for starters both are Action-RPG games set in a fantasy setting.

If they have no similarities then no two games can ever be compared.

[banzaigtv]

The Witcher 2 is a better port than Dark Souls and will prepare you for The Witcher 3.

[Tylenol baby]

I'm going to just buy both lol

[Cathulhu]

Originally posted by banzaigtv:

The Witcher 2 is a better port than Dark Souls and will prepare you for The Witcher 3.

Witcher 2 is not a port. It was developed and relased on PC and ported to the console, not the other way around. With CD Project the PC is the lead platform, not the console and it shows.

[Naedmi]

They only share the same Genre.

Nothing in common on the subject of gameplay.

Although CD Projekt is one of my favorite developers who seem to actually care for the people they're creating the games for. I'll never forget the thank you note I got when I purchased Witcher 3.