Is it right or wrong to celebrate the 4th of July?

[porjspn]

Sorry if there is already a topic like this, my computer crashed well at the time of publishing.

It's just out of curiosity!
Hello, first I would like to clarify that English is not my native language, so I am directly using Google translator and after Grammarly to fix my mistakes.

Let's say that in the following hypothetical scenario it happens:
To non-Americans (people from the United States of America), what would you think if the president of your country celebrated the 4th of July, which is independence day in the united states?

Celebrate in his decorated house, with typical decorations of American Independence Day.

A party, however small, with friends in a pandemic season, with miniatures of the American flag drawn on the table, probably in some corner where no photos were taken, there was a flag hanging on the wall.

And, who knows? at some point until I sang a part of the American anthem.

And a question to Americans, what would you think or even feel if President Donald Trump did that with, say, the day of independence from Italy or France? or any other country that seems to suit that example for you.
(Remembering that for the example it does not have to be a country that has good or excellent relationships, just any country that is not very involved.)

[Masque]

引用自 Hugsie Muffinball：

引用自 Munithe EXT：

Sure, but being proud of your nation doesn't mean you have to be proud of your government or enjoy living in fear of it (which is why they won't declare dissatisfaction anyway).

"Patriotism is supporting your country all the time, and the government when it deserves it."

Has the Chinese peoples' standard of living gone up since the revolution? How about since the 1980s? If I were Chinese, I'd probably support the country, and the government, right about now. They went from agrarian, most in mud huts, to world economic powerhouse in just a few short decades. Mostly because of their government.

With no small assist from ours. Thanks, Billy Jeff. China should have Clinton statues in every major city.

[Masque]

引用自 Munithe EXT：

Rural China is still extremely poor. They still live in huts and have no schools or running water.

So is rural America. Your point?

Has the standard of living in China gone up, drastically, in the last few decades, or not?

[𝕎𝔸𝕃𝕋𝔼ℝ]

I love raptors

[AD]

Not an American. My country does not have a president, we have a king (with no formal power). If our king celebrated it, it would feel a bit strange and a bit funny since America is a republic. But I doubt I would care that much, at least if they only did it privately. In public it might be inappropriate, since our king is supposed to represent my country and not another country, but I'm honestly not sure how I would react. Don't think it would be that big of deal for me, though, but maybe it would bother me a little.

For anyone who is not supposed to represent the country I don't really care that much. Don't think it's a good sign for a free country to say "you cannot celebrate this" or "you must celebrate that".

[Starbug]

引用自 Munithe EXT：

Rural China is still extremely poor. They still live in huts and have no schools or running water.

You'll probably find the same is the case in rural Appalachian communities.

[Lumpy]

I always thought of that day as just fireworks day

[GuRu Asaki]

They tuned down fire works, & took away the right for us to light them off ourselves... But because they tunex them down, they arent very good, & since the budget is super low now...

Without shooting them off myself there just is no point in Celebrating 4th of July anymore, because I always felt you Celebrate with fireworks...

[Masque]

Also what I mentioned about Clinton is too simplistic.

America has boosted China's economic status since Richard M. Nixon opened up trade, and we began outsourcing most of our manufacturing jobs to the Chinese people.

All Clinton did was boost their military tech immeasurably, for campaign money.

[Masque]

引用自 GuRu Asaki：

They tuned down fire works, & took away the right for us to light them off ourselves... But because they tunex them down, they arent very good, & since the budget is super low now...

Without shooting them off myself there just is no point in Celebrating 4th of July anymore, because I always felt you Celebrate with fireworks...

So shoot them off yourself anyway.

The citizens of L.A. sure did. They can't arrest us all, and most towns won't even bother trying any more.

Look, the laws in America have no teeth any more, from top to bottom. Act according to your morals, and hope for the extremely good odds that you'll be just fine.

[Starbug]

引用自 Boomer：

引用自 Starbug：

No doubt they do but I don't think that would affect their instilled training to kill invading capitalist dogs and drive them to the sea.

That would be ironic, seeing as how China is already full of their own "capitalist dogs", which apparently is fine by them.

Getting beat at your own game by ex-commies must be a right kick in the teeth to all free market patriots. Outsourcing manufacturing seems like a mistake now.

[Masque]

It was a mistake from the beginning, Starbug. Many of us have always said that.

[𝕎𝔸𝕃𝕋𝔼ℝ]

引用自 Munithe EXT：

Maybe if we had a law which said all products that aid the chinese economy should be clearly labelled and colour coded depending on how much they support china (like uses materials sourced from china or manufactured in china). I think it would harm Chinese economy greatly if people chose to avoid those products because of the label.

Yeah and those labels would also be made in china

[Starbug]

引用自 Boomer：

引用自 Starbug：

Getting beat at your own game by ex-commies must be a right kick in the teeth to all free market patriots. Outsourcing manufacturing seems like a mistake now.

Well, I am neither American, nor Chinese, but just found it adorably hypocritical of your notion to encourage the use of capitalism to vanquish capitalism.

Neither am I American or Chinese. That doesn't preclude me from seeing the dark irony of commie capitalists prevailing in an economic peeing contest. Perhaps you've mistaken that observation for some sort of encouragement.

[Ganger]

引用自 Radene：

Sounds like something straight ot of Stalin's textbook.

It does but it really angers me seeing many clueless young people want to destory the freedoms we in the west have believing the other side will be better without looking into history and seeing how billions of people have and are living under the jack boot of oppression the world over.

Maybe I sound like a old fart but hey thats just me.

[Chunk Norris ☯]

引用自 Starbug：

引用自 The Father ☯：

How many nations looked at our military impressiveness and decided not to mess with us?

China. They forced the USA to retreat from both Korea and Vietnam. Like an old Kung Fu master chasing off some young whippersnapper.. You might have had the guns but they most certainly had the numbers.

Since then the USA and its allies have resoundedly focused on fighting much smaller fishes. The military industrial complex does need these low intensity conflicts to keep armament towns in the rustbelt pumping out wmd's.

That's because we were forced to fight a limited warfare campaign by politicians who didn't care about the cost of American lives. If we were allowed to fight the war how it should of been fought we'd control Vietnam