Disc 11 Minecraft Theory

[CokedBadger]

The music disc "11" isn't music at all, it actually sounds like something straight out of a horror movie, what it plays is what sounds like somebody running from something, and there are sounds playing that sounds like the Wither's breathing

The 11 disc could be the Wither's origins, cause it sounds like the Wither is breathing in the background, and somebody is trying to run from him

What do you think?

PS:

There's currently a flame war going on, because somebody gave a theory that person chasing the other person is Herobrine, and now we're in a debate whether or not Herobrine exists to prove if it could be Herobrine, no matter what I do the flamers are still saying they're right, this thread is complete chaos

POSSIBLE ANSWERS TO IF HEROBRINE IS REAL:

1: Herobrine is real and Mojang is covering it up

2: Herobrine is real and the truth never fully reached all of society

3: Herobrine doesn't exist

[HarleyIsntReal]

lmao all of those herobrine "sightings" were faked. all of these people pointing to "evidence" like how herobrine is notch's dead brother (notch doesn't even have a brother.) doesn't make any sense what-so-ever lol

[CokedBadger]

Originally posted by ṼṏẌṏḭḊ:

Originally posted by Beans On Butter:

Because just saying "Herobrine isn't real" doesn't prove that he isn't real, you need to provide evidence that points to the fact he isn't real

You prove that Herobrine is real

I can't prove that he's real or that he isn't

Originally posted by HarleyTheSpartan:

Originally posted by Beans On Butter:

Because just saying "Herobrine isn't real" doesn't prove that he isn't real, you need to provide evidence that points to the fact he isn't real

...but there's no evidence he's real in the first place... why would i need to prove he isn't real when there's no evidence he's real...

Well you said he isn't real, but you'll need to prove it in order for your claim to be believable

Originally posted by l1z4rdbr34th:

Looking through data files in the game would prove whether or not Herobrine is real as a mob in the overworld, Nether, or End. But he's not, so there.

BUT, what if it is in the game files, but it's using a fake name, so instead of a file name having "herobrine" in it, it could be replaced by "tree" or something

Originally posted by Rowley Jefferson:

Originally posted by Beans On Butter:

Because just saying "Herobrine isn't real" doesn't prove that he isn't real, you need to provide evidence that points to the fact he isn't real

Herobrine was never in the game, it’s a stupid creepypasta. Google Brocraft herobrine stream

Gonna have to provide evidence

Originally posted by HarleyTheSpartan:

lmao all of those herobrine "sightings" were faked. all of these people pointing to "evidence" like how herobrine is notch's dead brother (notch doesn't even have a brother.) doesn't make any sense what-so-ever lol

What if the sightings are real, yet nobody believes them

[AWAWA Liz]

Another way to prove whether or not Herobrine is real and in the game is looking for his character model. Sprites, details, everything. So where is it??? It's not there.

[HarleyIsntReal]

Originally posted by Beans On Butter:

Originally posted by HarleyTheSpartan:

...but there's no evidence he's real in the first place... why would i need to prove he isn't real when there's no evidence he's real...

Well you said he isn't real, but you'll need to prove it in order for your claim to be believable

you need evidence to prove that he's real, though. he isn't real until proven otherwise.

Originally posted by Beans On Butter:

Originally posted by HarleyTheSpartan:

lmao all of those herobrine "sightings" were faked. all of these people pointing to "evidence" like how herobrine is notch's dead brother (notch doesn't even have a brother.) doesn't make any sense what-so-ever lol

What if the sightings are real, yet nobody believes them

they aren't real as they've already been debunked by people.

[ֆ]

Originally posted by Beans On Butter:

Originally posted by ṼṏẌṏḭḊ:

You prove that Herobrine is real

I can't prove that he's real or that he isn't

Originally posted by HarleyTheSpartan:

...but there's no evidence he's real in the first place... why would i need to prove he isn't real when there's no evidence he's real...

Well you said he isn't real, but you'll need to prove it in order for your claim to be believable

Originally posted by l1z4rdbr34th:

Looking through data files in the game would prove whether or not Herobrine is real as a mob in the overworld, Nether, or End. But he's not, so there.

BUT, what if it is in the game files, but it's using a fake name, so instead of a file name having "herobrine" in it, it could be replaced by "tree" or something

Originally posted by Rowley Jefferson:

Herobrine was never in the game, it’s a stupid creepypasta. Google Brocraft herobrine stream

Gonna have to provide evidence

Originally posted by HarleyTheSpartan:

lmao all of those herobrine "sightings" were faked. all of these people pointing to "evidence" like how herobrine is notch's dead brother (notch doesn't even have a brother.) doesn't make any sense what-so-ever lol

What if the sightings are real, yet nobody believes them

I did. Google "Brocraft herobrine stream"

[CokedBadger]

Originally posted by HarleyTheSpartan:

Originally posted by Beans On Butter:

Well you said he isn't real, but you'll need to prove it in order for your claim to be believable

you need evidence to prove that he's real, though. he isn't real until proven otherwise.

Originally posted by Beans On Butter:

What if the sightings are real, yet nobody believes them

they aren't real as they've already been debunked by people.

1: What do you also think that something isn't real unless you can see it?

2: I literally just gave a possibility

Originally posted by Beans On Butter:

What if the sightings are real, yet nobody believes them

Originally posted by Rowley Jefferson:

Originally posted by Beans On Butter:

I can't prove that he's real or that he isn't



Well you said he isn't real, but you'll need to prove it in order for your claim to be believable



BUT, what if it is in the game files, but it's using a fake name, so instead of a file name having "herobrine" in it, it could be replaced by "tree" or something



Gonna have to provide evidence



What if the sightings are real, yet nobody believes them

I did. Google "Brocraft herobrine stream"

Yes:

One piece of evidence = Proven true/false regardless of the end it supports

[ṼṏẌṏḭḊ]

Butters... Dude....
No official Herobrine....

[CokedBadger]

Originally posted by ṼṏẌṏḭḊ:

Butters... Dude....
No official Herobrine....

Prove it

[CokedBadger]

So does anybody have evidence that proves Herobrine doesn't exist? Cause if Herobrine doesn't exist then the theory that the 11 disc is linked to Herobrine is false

[AWAWA Liz]

It's not linked to Herobrine, there was never a Herobrine. It's just a random Steve like who you play as.

[ṼṏẌṏḭḊ]

Originally posted by Beans On Butter:

So does anybody have evidence that proves Herobrine doesn't exist? Cause if Herobrine doesn't exist then the theory that the 11 disc is linked to Herobrine is false

*Facepalm

[ֆ]

Originally posted by Beans On Butter:

So does anybody have evidence that proves Herobrine doesn't exist? Cause if Herobrine doesn't exist then the theory that the 11 disc is linked to Herobrine is false

Minecraft doesn't even have any lore. At least the last time I played. It's just a creepy disc. There's no Herobrine.

[Marcawn]

Why is there a minecraft thread on a steam forum

[AWAWA Liz]

Originally posted by A̸̙̪͆r̵̟̫̀̿͐͜c̸̑͠:

Why is there a minecraft thread on a steam forum

Because it's Off Topic.

[CokedBadger]

Originally posted by l1z4rdbr34th:

It's not linked to Herobrine, there was never a Herobrine. It's just a random Steve like who you play as.

Provide some proof

Originally posted by Rowley Jefferson:

Originally posted by Beans On Butter:

So does anybody have evidence that proves Herobrine doesn't exist? Cause if Herobrine doesn't exist then the theory that the 11 disc is linked to Herobrine is false

Minecraft doesn't even have any lore. At least the last time I played. It's just a creepy disc. There's no Herobrine.

https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=Minecraft+lore

I know these are all theories, but damn there is a lot to reveal