Infinity war's nidavellir colossal design flaw

[Kyle Nuva]

are we just gonna ignore how much the eye of the station and the dying star makes no damn sense? its even worse then the death star, its logic is so bad. why does turning the rings jump start the buring star? shouldnt it always be burning? if its dead, how does it reignite? more implortantly, the beam's path flys into the door/lock mechanic, it burns off. and this star is as hot as the sun or more and it melted the stormbreaker metal but doesnt melt everything around it? but why is the only door open level in the center of the beams path? thats much more flawed and pooly built then the death star, the death star having a computer terminal and two workers near by but at least they are away from the beam, but nidavellir has a beam that fires into the very thing that keeps the doors open. how is that possible? the pot it in the worst and dangerous place possible

also why would thor need the new hammer to wake up after being shot by a fiery beam? hes the god of thunder, not hammers. so that doesnt make any sense either

[Thlormby]

Why do you keep posting about Infinity War

[101Titan101]

Much like a homosexual with poor coordination, you're missing the point. It's about the charachters and action and plot.

[Mighty Chonker]

doesn't matter the how of it just that it does work in any case it's a fictional universe with superpowered beings some of which are godlike that also has an advanced level of tech

[Kyle Nuva]

Originally posted by Whomst'd've Habe Gedacht:

Much like a homosexual with poor coordination, you're missing the point. It's about the charachters and action and plot.

WRONG

[Kyle Nuva]

Originally posted by Whomst'd've Habe Gedacht:

Much like a homosexual with poor coordination, you're missing the point. It's about the charachters and action and plot.

Originally posted by JOMO:

doesn't matter the how of it just that it does work in any case it's a fictional universe with superpowered beings some of which are godlike that also has an advanced level of tech

WRONG

[Kyle Nuva]

Originally posted by Sobeck:

Why do you keep posting about Infinity War

WRONG

[captainwiseass]

It's not supposed to make sense, it's supposed to look cool.

[L1qu1dator]

Dude, you expect logic from a fantasy... stop.

[JelliedKnife]

Originally posted by Gundam Heavyarms:

Originally posted by Sobeck:

Why do you keep posting about Infinity War

WRONG

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2yqUpypQwGs

[Mikasa Ackerman]

Originally posted by L1qu1dator:

Dude, you expect logic from a fantasy... stop.

even fantasy needs logic , like everything
in real life theres set rules , if someone dies they are dead, fantasy worlds with magic need to have consistent rules for that , if someone dies ,can they be revived , can they only be revived as zombies ( edo tensei ) can they only be revived via some ancient magic , whatever

and the moment you mix franchises together its bound to not make sense anymore

[L1qu1dator]

Originally posted by Sakura Haruno:

Originally posted by L1qu1dator:

Dude, you expect logic from a fantasy... stop.

even fantasy needs logic , like everything
in real life theres set rules , if someone dies they are dead, fantasy worlds with magic need to have consistent rules for that , if someone dies ,can they be revived , can they only be revived as zombies ( edo tensei ) can they only be revived via some ancient magic , whatever

and the moment you mix franchises together its bound to not make sense anymore

Yeah some basic logic, but the margin for error is huge compared to real life set stories. But it's a fantasy and authors make up things that don't exist in real world or were never seen, so they end up working by breaking rules of real life, sometimes maybe author deliberately ignores the rules, cause real life doesn't "sound" so cool.
Some people treat these stories like... I wouldn't be surprised if these comics would be like a Bible in 2000 years if people would survive till then. ;)

[TVMAN]

The space forge can make the magic metal melt and nothing else because asgardians are good at space blacksmithing due to their viking god powers hth.

[Galactic Yoshi]

It’s a small inconsistency. The movie was awesome

[999999999]

The rings create an electro static/electro magnetic field that generates heat and the cold dense dead star heats back up until fusion is able to restart.

[Mikasa Ackerman]

Originally posted by L1qu1dator:

Originally posted by Sakura Haruno:

even fantasy needs logic , like everything
in real life theres set rules , if someone dies they are dead, fantasy worlds with magic need to have consistent rules for that , if someone dies ,can they be revived , can they only be revived as zombies ( edo tensei ) can they only be revived via some ancient magic , whatever

and the moment you mix franchises together its bound to not make sense anymore

Yeah some basic logic, but the margin for error is huge compared to real life set stories. But it's a fantasy and authors make up things that don't exist in real world or were never seen, so they end up working by breaking rules of real life, sometimes maybe author deliberately ignores the rules, cause real life doesn't "sound" so cool.
Some people treat these stories like... I wouldn't be surprised if these comics would be like a Bible in 2000 years if people would survive till then. ;)

they can break real life rules but imo the fantasy world they create needs to have its own rules , pretty much like video games , some games have fall damage , others dont , some games have world wide gravity ( mario 64 for example) others ( galaxy ) dont , and throughout the game , that thing stays consistent , the time stone allowed thanos to just bring back the stone and vision , why didnt strange do the same ?

same with thor and loki , they are gods , how can they just die ( i know , loki killed Baldur but still )
i am not 100% sure if gods can die as easily ,but loki just dying like that in the beginning made no sense , and besides , if thanos is basically ready to kill half of everything , wouldnt that be enough to justify sending all the Einherjar and valkyries from valhalla to the battlefield as well which would automatically make thanos lose as that could easily be a whole army of very skilled soldiers

thats my number one problem with those movies , they just take names of norse gods and other things like valkyrie and make a comic story out of it , but dont actually care about the mythology

also , at the end of thor ragnarok , wasnt valkyrie on board of the ship ? she would defenitely be on the same level as thanos without all stones , if not above , and besides that , they also had two gods on board ( or technically , if all of asgard was evacuated , shouldnt Tyr , freyr and other norse gods also be on the ship if they were in asgard (not sure about Ægir since hes a sea god ) ? and a bunch of gods would defenitely be enough to kill thanos at the start

all these characters were made to look super powerful in their own movies and now all together struggle to defeat one single enemy , it just doesnt make sense


also , why didnt iron man give everyone an indestructible suit and problem solved, he managed to do it for hulk ,so why not for the rest

another thing, in thor ragnarok , dr strange was able to just teleport loki away , why couldnt he do the same in infinity war with vision so thanos would never get to him ?