Vader Vs Gandalf Vs Dumbledore?

[Lucky Lee]

Vader (after episode 3, before episode 4) with Lightsabre

Gandalf (resurrected Gandalf The White) with staff

Dumbledore (version from Fantastic Beasts) with wand

Who would win in a fight? And why?

[saranacX]

Lord Vader commands the force, he will repel any woo woo magic. Then choke them both out at the same time as he informs them that their lack of faith disturbs him.

[Esoteric]

Gandalf since he's Maiar.

[Washell]

Disney and WB for 10 billion US for televising the fight.

[King Narwhal]

Well, lets see their track records:

Darth Vader - Lost to his mentor, fried, poked his mentor later only for him to come back as a ghost, chopped off a n00b jedi's arm, choked another old guy, lost 2 death balls, and failed his one mission of killing his son. Oh, and was fried by another old guy that he threw in a hole. The only thing he really did was slaughter some kiddos in training, kill his own men, and kill old people.

Gandalf - Killed a corrupted god (the Balrog, look it up), died and came back, un-cursed a king by overpowering the most powerful wizard alive at the time, used his magic glowstick to fend off the Nazgul, and got rid of Denethor the utterly insane while saving his (unloved) son from burning alive.

Dumbledore - Stood around and watched, disappeared whenever any of the actual action happens, got his arm cursed, drank poison, died, came back at the very end to tell Harry that Voldemort killed part of his soul instead of Harry's, disappeared forever.


I'd say Gandalf is best, then Vader (because he at least did something), then Dumbledore.

[alicerinz]

For the reference, Vader killed anywhere from 100 to 300 Jedi during the Empire's reign.

[saranacX]

Truth původně napsal:

For the reference, Vader killed anywhere from 100 to 300 Jedi during the Empire's reign.

He also got to make it with Natalie Portman. Checkmate.

[Lucky Lee]

Truth původně napsal:

For the reference, Vader killed anywhere from 100 to 300 Jedi during the Empire's reign.

Now THAT'S a killer.

[Jinn-Gon Qui]

Fresh Frozen původně napsal:

I'll go with Darth Vader. The force is strongest with him.

[DarkCrystalMethod]

Bilbo Baggins

[Mod Sloth]

DarkCrystalMethod původně napsal:

Bilbo Baggins

I think you mean "BILLLLBO BAGGINS!"

[DarkCrystalMethod]

Mod Sloth původně napsal:

DarkCrystalMethod původně napsal:

Bilbo Baggins

I think you mean "BILLLLBO BAGGINS!"

You are correct, as always.

[alicerinz]

DØC původně napsal:

YinkYinkYinken původně napsal:

Now THAT'S a killer.

most of them were children...

Thats a complete and utter lie. Most of the ones who managed to flee the Temple were experienced Jedi. The kids didnt have the skills required to evade the kind of force that was sent after them.

At some point Vader even faced off against ~6 masters at once.

[gugnihr]

I like only Gandalf (I prefer Harry Potter over Lord of the rings but I prefer Gandalf over Dumbledore. I hathe both Star Wars and Vader) so I vote for him.

[Lucky Lee]

I doubt Gandalf could react quickly enough to avoid Lord Vader's force-choke.