所有讨论 > Steam 论坛 > Off Topic > 主题详情
此主题已被锁定
ψ -No.23- 2018 年 9 月 25 日 上午 6:58
What's wrong with cultural appropriation?
I'm really confused when people screech at other people for wearing something from another culture, like isnt that a good thing??? Nobody owns a culture and doing stuff like that should bring us all together, not create an even bigger schism. And if cultural appropriation is so bad, then why are non-white people allowed to go to Starbucks? Aren't they "appropriating their culture?"
< >
正在显示第 136 - 144 条,共 144 条留言
BanOphobia My Struggle 2018 年 9 月 27 日 下午 2:49 
引用自 L1qu1dator
引用自 Lost "N" Spaced

Lots of fresh air I suppose if you go regimental?

I wore a medical gown once. How the hell do women walk/run in long dress. Respect for pulling that off.
Like Japanese women in their kimonos, in small steps i guess :)
I guess if you don't mind the cold, or live in a warm region.
But serioulsly it's like wearing lederhosen when you're not Bavarian during Oktoberfest, I don't see anyone wearing those. ;P

I bet a few use lederhosen in some COSPLAY event as part of some costumes. Think of the poor Weeaboo Cos-players stripped of culturally appropriating lederhosen. Aren’t Weeaboo’s a new cultural identity or something?
76561198126550068 2018 年 9 月 27 日 下午 2:53 
Theres nothing wrong with that, but if someone want to make other people lose their way in culture by force, then you have a problem.
L1qu1dator 2018 年 9 月 28 日 下午 12:03 
引用自 Lost "N" Spaced
I bet a few use lederhosen in some COSPLAY event as part of some costumes. Think of the poor Weeaboo Cos-players stripped of culturally appropriating lederhosen. Aren’t Weeaboo’s a new cultural identity or something?
I-I don't know no more, I would like to say no, though. ;P
dont add me 2018 年 9 月 28 日 下午 8:11 
The whole idea of cultural approriation is divisive. It's splitting people into groups and saying that those groups can't adopt eachother's practices.

Divisions lead to conflict.

By advancing the idea that people aren't allowed to adopt eachother's cultures, you are creating division. You are sewing the seeds of conflict by dividing people.

If you are trying to advance the idea that cultures should remain pure, then you are also advocating for stagnation and separation. You're the badguy.
ROFLpl0x 2018 年 9 月 29 日 上午 10:15 
引用自 Toast
The whole idea of cultural approriation is divisive. It's splitting people into groups and saying that those groups can't adopt eachother's practices.

Divisions lead to conflict.

By advancing the idea that people aren't allowed to adopt eachother's cultures, you are creating division. You are sewing the seeds of conflict by dividing people.

If you are trying to advance the idea that cultures should remain pure, then you are also advocating for stagnation and separation. You're the badguy.
It's those very cultural differences that split people into groups to begin with, and adopting cultural practices isn't adopting cultural identity. Even doing the latter isn't wrong if it's done legitimately. A family in Norway that packs it's bags and moves to Chile is inevitably going to adopt the Chilean culture and identity and become ethnic Chileans, if not in their own generations then one in the near future. Assimilation is both natural and encouraged. Why? For two reasons: 1. to avoid conflict and 2. to protect the host culture.

You want to know what leads to a hell of a lot of conflict? Arrogance, especially blind arrogance, and nothing is more arrogant than telling someone that how they live and think is wrong and that they're the bad guy if they do it that way. If some group wants to remain culturally pure, that's there business. There's no conflict until somebody who doesn't approve of the way they live goes poking their nose where it doesn't belong.

And you don't even realize it, but these beliefs that underneath everybody's clothes people are all the same or should be all the same or the "culture is in the public domain" BS that, not surprisingly, still remains in this thread as a completely unfounded assertion of "cold hard fact" are an intrinsic part of the new western CULTURE and don't exist outside of it to any extent worth mentioning. Every time someone tries to apply professor Goldberg's mantras to another group of people they're advancing that western culture over someone else's, literally forcing it on them in some cases (EU vs the V4), all the while complaining about how divisions cause conflict where there never was any conflict before they created it themselves.

And guess what. They hate you for it. They hate you because you mind their business and think you have some right to judge how other people live and think and a moral duty to "fix" what you don't approve of. Mind your own business and there won't be any conflict. What conflict did the Visegrad have with the EU before the EU started trying to shove it's multiculturalism down the Visegrad's socially conservative and culturally homogenous throats? Whose fault is that, the V4's for wanting to be left alone or the rest of the EU's for demanding they should be the same as they are?
[FFK3] Trovaa 2018 年 9 月 29 日 上午 10:23 
引用自 Who?
Nothing.
BanOphobia My Struggle 2018 年 9 月 30 日 上午 3:47 
引用自 PALE
Nothing wrong with cultural appropriation. Without it we would never have gotten burgers, tacos or pizza...

OMG cultural appropriation wardens are going to check even my fridge/freezer/cuboards now?

Cultural Prohibition on the cards with 15 years for taco smuggling damn killjoys.
< >
正在显示第 136 - 144 条,共 144 条留言
每页显示数: 1530 50

所有讨论 > Steam 论坛 > Off Topic > 主题详情
发帖日期: 2018 年 9 月 25 日 上午 6:58
回复数: 144