Which animation studio is worse?

[Fragile Waters]

Sony Pictures Animation, or Illumination Entertainment?

[AlmightyDunkle]

Illumination
Sing is by far one of the worst movies I've ever seen.

[Ëvïlnïck8 ゴゴゴ]

Illumination.
Minions, Sing, Minions.

Minions


♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ minions that are litterly everywere!

[Daxank]

Illumination
Because they make crappy movies that are profitable.
Sony is the same except theirs aren't as profitable or don't even make the money back

[Pixelpusher]

sony pictures

i would say illumination but they brought minions into my life...

[Daxank]

Nguyên văn bởi Pixelpusher:

sony pictures

i would say illumination but they brought minions into my life...

You're dead to all of us

[Pixelpusher]

Nguyên văn bởi Daxank:

Nguyên văn bởi Pixelpusher:

sony pictures

i would say illumination but they brought minions into my life...

You're dead to all of us :VSnake:

i already knew that

[Smugass Braixen-Chan]

Sony Pictures Animation

Open Season - BAD
Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs - Okay
Hotel Transylvania - Okay

Haven't Seen These: Surf's Up, The Smurfs 1 + 2 + Lost Village, Arthur Christmas, The Pirates!, CwaCoM2, Hotel Transylvania 2, Goosebumbs, Emoji Movie (But I've heard nothing but bad things about this last one)

Total;
2x Okay
1x Bad
1x Informed Badness

Illumination Entertainment

Despicable Me - Good
Hop - Okay
Despicable Me 2 - Okay
Minions - Bad
The Secret Life of Pets - Okay

Haven't Seen These: The Lorax, Sing, Despicable Me 3

Total;
1x Good
3x Okay
1x Bad

____________________

In conclusion:

Illumination's 1 good movie cancels out its 1 awful movie in the same series, while the rest are all mediocre.

Meanwhile, Sony Pictures is Mediocre at best and downright cancer at worst.

So Sony Pictures Animation is the worse of the two, but not by much.

[Rockstarpurpp]

Illumination

[Sixtyfivekills]

Nguyên văn bởi Insanity Wolf-Chan:

Sony Pictures Animation

Open Season - BAD

I used to love that movie when I was young. I hated the sequel though.

[Mossy Snake]

Nguyên văn bởi Insanity Wolf-Chan:

Sony Pictures Animation

Open Season - BAD
Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs - Okay
Hotel Transylvania - Okay

Haven't Seen These: Surf's Up, The Smurfs 1 + 2 + Lost Village, Arthur Christmas, The Pirates!, CwaCoM2, Hotel Transylvania 2, Goosebumbs, Emoji Movie (But I've heard nothing but bad things about this last one)

Total;
2x Okay
1x Bad
1x Informed Badness

Illumination Entertainment

Despicable Me - Good
Hop - Okay
Despicable Me 2 - Okay
Minions - Bad
The Secret Life of Pets - Okay

Haven't Seen These: The Lorax, Sing, Despicable Me 3

Total;
1x Good
3x Okay
1x Bad

____________________

In conclusion:

Illumination's 1 good movie cancels out its 1 awful movie in the same series, while the rest are all mediocre.

Meanwhile, Sony Pictures is Mediocre at best and downright cancer at worst.

So Sony Pictures Animation is the worse of the two, but not by much.

Wait, they made "Pirates!"!? Since when did they own Aardvark!? That movie was amazing!

Illumination is worse because of Minions.

[Pixelpusher]

Nguyên văn bởi Insanity Wolf-Chan:

Sony Pictures Animation

Open Season - BAD
Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs - Okay
Hotel Transylvania - Okay

Haven't Seen These: Surf's Up, The Smurfs 1 + 2 + Lost Village, Arthur Christmas, The Pirates!, CwaCoM2, Hotel Transylvania 2, Goosebumbs, Emoji Movie (But I've heard nothing but bad things about this last one)

Total;
2x Okay
1x Bad
1x Informed Badness

Illumination Entertainment

Despicable Me - Good
Hop - Okay
Despicable Me 2 - Okay
Minions - Bad
The Secret Life of Pets - Okay

Haven't Seen These: The Lorax, Sing, Despicable Me 3

Total;
1x Good
3x Okay
1x Bad

____________________

In conclusion:

Illumination's 1 good movie cancels out its 1 awful movie in the same series, while the rest are all mediocre.

Meanwhile, Sony Pictures is Mediocre at best and downright cancer at worst.

So Sony Pictures Animation is the worse of the two, but not by much.

surfs up i thought was okay
all the smurf movies are meh lost village was bad
hotel transelvania 2 bad
i want to see the emoji movie
cloudy with a chance of meatballs 2 bad
dont remember arthurs christmas
never heard of the pirates


dispicable me was good
hop was meh
dispicable me 2 was bad
minions was better than the godfather hands down
secret life of pets was okay
lorax was okay
sing was meh
dispicable m3 was G A Y litchereallly

i still think sony is worse their movies are mediocere at best

[Mossy Snake]

Nguyên văn bởi Pixelpusher:

Nguyên văn bởi Insanity Wolf-Chan:

Sony Pictures Animation

Open Season - BAD
Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs - Okay
Hotel Transylvania - Okay

Haven't Seen These: Surf's Up, The Smurfs 1 + 2 + Lost Village, Arthur Christmas, The Pirates!, CwaCoM2, Hotel Transylvania 2, Goosebumbs, Emoji Movie (But I've heard nothing but bad things about this last one)

Total;
2x Okay
1x Bad
1x Informed Badness

Illumination Entertainment

Despicable Me - Good
Hop - Okay
Despicable Me 2 - Okay
Minions - Bad
The Secret Life of Pets - Okay

Haven't Seen These: The Lorax, Sing, Despicable Me 3

Total;
1x Good
3x Okay
1x Bad

____________________

In conclusion:

Illumination's 1 good movie cancels out its 1 awful movie in the same series, while the rest are all mediocre.

Meanwhile, Sony Pictures is Mediocre at best and downright cancer at worst.

So Sony Pictures Animation is the worse of the two, but not by much.

surfs up i thought was okay
all the smurf movies are meh lost village was bad
hotel transelvania 2 bad
i want to see the emoji movie
cloudy with a chance of meatballs 2 bad
dont remember arthurs christmas
never heard of the pirates


dispicable me was good
hop was meh
dispicable me 2 was bad
minions was better than the godfather hands down
secret life of pets was okay
lorax was okay
sing was meh
dispicable m3 was G A Y litchereallly

i still think sony is worse their movies are mediocere at best

Sony:
Smurfs: Crap
CWACOM 1: Alright
CWACOM 2: Crap
Hotel Transylvania 1: Bad, but not unwatchable
Hotel Transylvania 2: Really, really bad.
Emoji Movie: Worst thing ever
Arthurs Christmas: ???
The Pirates!: Amazing, if it's the same clay-animation one I'm thinking of

Illumination:
Despicable Me 1: Actually good
Despicable Me 2: Eh... It wasn't good, but it was watchable
Despicable Me 3: I hear it's bad, but I've never seen it
Minions: Crap
SLOP: Crap
Lorax: As far as Dr. Seuss movies go it was alright, but it wasn't that good
Sing: Never seen, but I hear it's bad (It seems like a cheap cash-in on the Zootopia craze)


Sony is actually worse...

[Smugass Braixen-Chan]

I also noticed something when going through the movies Sony made

Open Season - Trying to ride the success of Ice Age

Surf's Up - Trying to ride the success of Happy Feat

CWACOMB - Doesn't seem to be copying anything directly, but the "Boy tries so hard to earn the respect of a father, who seems to be disappointed by the mere fact that his son was even born, that it gets out of hand" plot is so over-used that you could accuse it of copying literally everything in the whole world. Hell, even Despicable Me uses it as a sub-plot between Gru and his Mother. And Despicable Me handles it better by turning it into a lesson about believing in yourself.

The Smurfs - Based on a Children's TV show

Arthur Christmas + The Pirates - Co-produced with Aardman Animations

Hotel Transylvania - For some reason, I thought this was based on a comic book, but it's still pretty cliche.

Goosebumps - Based on a series of children's books

Emoji Movie - Trying to ride the success of Inside Out

____________________

So basically, every film Sony has done up to this point falls into one of several categories

1. Trying to profit off the success of another animated film
   
2. Vaguely original, but still incredibly cliche
   
3. A licenced movie, so they can't even take credit for the idea
   
4. Co-produced with the same company that created Chicken Run (A timeless classic) so even if those movies are good, Sony can't take credit for it

[bigtrebuchet]

Illumination, Sony may have birthed the Emoji Movie but Illumination started the Minions Plague.

[We are in the Beam]

Nguyên văn bởi Spuddles:

Illumination, Sony may have birthed the Emoji Movie but Illumination started the Minions Plague.