Doomguy vs Master Chief

[Recordist]

Rules are as follows

1. Master chief has access to all his convential weapons except for the op stuff like Rocket Launchers and Energy Swords

2. Doomguy has access to all his weapons except for the B.F.G 9000

3. Battle takes place in Hell, no demons

4. No prep

5. No shields for chief (armour is op enough)

6. Both are at full strength and speed

A.I are permitted but won't serve much purpose

[Peekaboo]

master chief would exterminate him.

[Eat3n]

Considering that at higher difficulties in the game Master Chief's weapons f***ing suck and it takes 1/2 a clip to kill anything with a damn "assault rifle" AND enemy grunts can 2-hit kill you with a f***ing pistol...my vote is Doomguy.

[Space Coward]

-EAT3N-님이 먼저 게시:

Considering that at higher difficulties in the game Master Chief's weapons f***ing suck and it takes 1/2 a clip to kill anything with a damn "assault rifle" AND enemy grunts can 2-hit kill you with a f***ing pistol...my vote is Doomguy.

OR, the Covenant are just way harder to fight than demons. Minus the grunts, even on Legendary it's at most two punches in the face for them.

[FuccHandsMcMike]

Moss님이 먼저 게시:

-EAT3N-님이 먼저 게시:

Considering that at higher difficulties in the game Master Chief's weapons f***ing suck and it takes 1/2 a clip to kill anything with a damn "assault rifle" AND enemy grunts can 2-hit kill you with a f***ing pistol...my vote is Doomguy.

OR, the Covenant are just way harder to fight than demons. Minus the grunts, even on Legendary it's at most two punches in the face for them.

The harder you make the difficulty, the smarter and faster the Covenant gets! Playing legendary is how the game is actually meant to be played.

[ErickaUnlimited]

I'm not terribly knowledgeable in the lore of either franchise, but I'd have to say Master Chief from what I do know.

[Space Coward]

TheWyvernFox님이 먼저 게시:

Moss님이 먼저 게시:

OR, the Covenant are just way harder to fight than demons. Minus the grunts, even on Legendary it's at most two punches in the face for them.

The harder you make the difficulty, the smarter and faster the Covenant gets! Playing legendary is how the game is actually meant to be played.

Ha, no. Legendary is Hardmode with the values multiplied. That's a lot of hiding one player behind a rock and alternating grenade spam deaths.

Heroic is great, though, if you're up for the challenge.

[Midnight Sky ✨🌙✨]

No shields is a rather pointless rule since Doomguy (at least in Doom 2016) has a couple guns that can shred through Chief's shields. The shield can protect against bullets, but doesn't work as well against plasma and other energy-based weapons.

Doomguy is also excellent at thinking as quickly as he moves. He needs to be able to assess a situation and decide how to deal with it immediately

Doomguy's biggest issue is that most of Chief's guns are hitscan and can't be dodged.

[Ⓥenom Ⓢnake 🐍]

This is such a weird comparison, as the games play very differently, the characters are vastly different (A no-named guy who is really good at killing because of his anger issues and a soldier genetically modified and trained from age 8 to be a killing machine), their experiences are vastly different (one got in a few demon invasions, one was in active combat for 35 years), their combat styles are vastly different (carry all guns in ass while running in circles with the fire button depressed vs weapon management while using cover and precision shooting), their universes are vastly different (hell on Mars versus a fight through the universe), And the enemies they fight are vastly different (Walk straight, burping fire or group tactics, varied means off assault, an on par or better equipment.)

Oh well. I pick the Chief.

This might actually be more fun to discuss if the characters were similar. You know, like "who's tougher? Doomguy, Sam, or Duke?" Or "who is better at saving the Universe?" Shepard or Master Chief?" You know, characters with similarities.

[Eat3n]

Moss님이 먼저 게시:

-EAT3N-님이 먼저 게시:

Considering that at higher difficulties in the game Master Chief's weapons f***ing suck and it takes 1/2 a clip to kill anything with a damn "assault rifle" AND enemy grunts can 2-hit kill you with a f***ing pistol...my vote is Doomguy.

OR, the Covenant are just way harder to fight than demons. Minus the grunts, even on Legendary it's at most two punches in the face for them.

Punching them to death is just as stupid as an assault rifle taking 1/2 a clip to kill while grunts need 1 shot to break shields and 2nd shot to kill.

TheWyvernFox님이 먼저 게시:

Moss님이 먼저 게시:

OR, the Covenant are just way harder to fight than demons. Minus the grunts, even on Legendary it's at most two punches in the face for them.

The harder you make the difficulty, the smarter and faster the Covenant gets! Playing legendary is how the game is actually meant to be played.

The difficulty doesn't bother me. What bothers me is that Master Chief is supposed to be this badass soldier yet he's running around with crap gear. Nevermind that the shields and guns suck, but seriously, it's the future and the USNC still uses bullets? No wonder they're getting their asses kicked.

[Kamiyé]

Red Monk님이 먼저 게시:

Doomguy would shove master chiefs leg down his throat.

This.
Chief is too conscious of his actions. He still possesses humane thought and looks out for others (marines, cortana, etc.).
The only thought going through Doomguy's mind is "RIP AND TEAR, RIP AND TEAR".

[Perquisitore]

Doomguy is hotter.

/closed thread

[Dominic]

I like Doom guy and all and Even Duke Nukem and Lo wang and so on. But I feel master chief would win. He can fall from orbit and survive. Not even Doom guy can do that.

[Milk]

Ribrary님이 먼저 게시:

Angry Floof님이 먼저 게시:

Doomguy has no shields.

He has his powerups, Invincibility isn't banned


I had to give doomguy a slight advantage or it would be 2016 really good marine vs 219293819 super space alien advanced enhanced soldier. Chief wins in a vanilla fight because of his tech, (I think cheif could 1v1 fist fight him and beat him aswell, due to being genetically ehnanced and all) doomguy still has a pretty good chance at winning.

If we're allowing powerups, chief has overshields.

[Doomerang]

Doomguy is too brutal for masterchief.

[Pizmo]

Red Monk님이 먼저 게시:

Pizmo님이 먼저 게시:

You are ripping my heart to pieces with this question. Doom and Halo are my two favorite franchises.

I think Doomguy is just a regular dude in a space suit.

Master Chief is genetically enhanced to be faster, stronger, and smarter then a normal human.

So I say master chief wins the fight hands down

Doomguy has the praetor suit though which was built by demons so being faster, stronger and smarter isn't facts.

Yea but Doomguy is just a dude in an a space suit. Master chief isn't. The chief was >designed< for combat. Also chief has more experience. He has been training to be the ultimate soldier since he was 8 years old