r.linder 2024 年 11 月 6 日 上午 9:07
Ryzen 7 9800X3D Review: "Devastating Gaming Performance" (Tom's Hardware)
https://www.tomshardware.com/pc-components/cpus/amd-ryzen-7-9800x3d-review-devastating-gaming-performance/2

So the rumors mostly appear to be true, the 9800X3D really is going to dominate more than expected, Intel is at least around 30% behind now with the 14900K and even further behind with the 285K. They really need to fix this, and fast, or we might end up with diminished upgrades per generation again.
< >
正在显示第 46 - 60 条,共 129 条留言
smokerob79 2024 年 11 月 7 日 上午 7:03 
引用自 Peter
引用自 r.linder
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s-lFgbzU3LY

Benchmarks don't lie. There are easily instances like BG3 where it pulls way ahead of Intel and other AMD processors. AMD only promised 8% but they underestimated their own chip in many instances.

Your claims are also for 2160p resolution which is freaking GPU bound, genius. If you're running 2160p, you don't even need a 9800X3D because it won't make a noticeable difference until there are far more powerful GPUs available.

I'll stick with Intel but my point is applicable to the 9800X3D.

Well, if you really really think that the vast majority of people who buy i9 cpus {I own a 12900KS and a 13900K} play at 1080p, then your thinking is out of date and irrelevant and at least a full decade behind the times.

We play with 3090 and 4090 gpus {yep I own both} on 4K OLED and 4K MiniLed monitors like the Asus PG42UQ and Asus 32UQX respectively. {yep I own both}

Sorry to burst your bubble but the 9800X3D has barely a ONE FPS ADVANTAGE over my 2 year old 12900KS at 4K, which will go down as one of the greatest cpus ever released for the enthusiast.



why cant you admit intel has been garbage for 20 years???....intel has never been worth the money......got my first laptop in 1991 to know this.....were you even born then???
Zefar 2024 年 11 月 7 日 上午 7:28 
引用自 smokerob79
why cant you admit intel has been garbage for 20 years???....intel has never been worth the money......got my first laptop in 1991 to know this.....were you even born then???

Intel has been better than AMD for the longest time. It's only really the past 2 years where AMD has put forward stuff that actually compete with Intels stuff.

But it was often that in games, Intel would get ahead of AMD. Even the budget i5 line up where greater than AMD counterpart.

引用自 r.linder
Think what you want and stay in your bubble, but the 5800X3D made an absolute mockery of the 12900K.

AMD also isn't the one that just lost over 16 billion in profits in the last quarter, Intel is. Their tactics aren't working and haven't been working for years.

That comparison isn't the best. The i9 12900K is more for workstations loads because it has more cores or E-Cores. Games can't make use of all the cores and because of that the results are going to be similar.

https://youtu.be/hBFNoKUHjcg?t=1157
Lets use Gamers Nexus and look at the work stations scores. The i9 12900K wins on all of them over the 5800X3D. By quite a big margin too.

It's the same with the AMD CPU that had 64 cores and AMD fanboys would not want to hear from Intel people "How good is it in games though?" only to get "It's not made for that!"
Tiberius 2024 年 11 月 7 日 上午 7:50 
Most ppl who bought 5800x3d could care less abt productivity score, especially when the cpu was 200$ cheaper, & we havent even counted the adoption cost here
r.linder 2024 年 11 月 7 日 上午 7:57 
引用自 Zefar
引用自 smokerob79
why cant you admit intel has been garbage for 20 years???....intel has never been worth the money......got my first laptop in 1991 to know this.....were you even born then???

Intel has been better than AMD for the longest time. It's only really the past 2 years where AMD has put forward stuff that actually compete with Intels stuff.

But it was often that in games, Intel would get ahead of AMD. Even the budget i5 line up where greater than AMD counterpart.

引用自 r.linder
Think what you want and stay in your bubble, but the 5800X3D made an absolute mockery of the 12900K.

AMD also isn't the one that just lost over 16 billion in profits in the last quarter, Intel is. Their tactics aren't working and haven't been working for years.

That comparison isn't the best. The i9 12900K is more for workstations loads because it has more cores or E-Cores. Games can't make use of all the cores and because of that the results are going to be similar.

https://youtu.be/hBFNoKUHjcg?t=1157
Lets use Gamers Nexus and look at the work stations scores. The i9 12900K wins on all of them over the 5800X3D. By quite a big margin too.

It's the same with the AMD CPU that had 64 cores and AMD fanboys would not want to hear from Intel people "How good is it in games though?" only to get "It's not made for that!"
Obviously, there's extra cores that help productivity regardless, but: Nobody here really cares about the productivity scores, this is Steam, whole point is that AMD is the gaming king.
If Peter cared that much about productivity then his 13900K also wouldn't be sitting in a box. No, he's an Intel user that's stuck in the past and still thinks Intel is better even though they've made an absolute clown of themselves ever since Ryzen 5000 series came out.
最后由 r.linder 编辑于; 2024 年 11 月 7 日 上午 7:58
Komarimaru 2024 年 11 月 7 日 上午 7:57 
As many have pointed out, it's really great at 1080p and super high end GPU. But it's done this way to check for CPU bottlenecks, since no one will notice even if just bump up to 1440p let alone 4K.

I'm personally waiting to see if the rumor is true that the 9950X3D is going cache on each CCD... If so, that's my upgrade for my system, since do workloads more than gaming, why I've stuck to my 5950X for so long.
Illusion of Progress 2024 年 11 月 7 日 上午 8:08 
引用自 Capt Spack Jarrow
Weird response, because I never said it was.

It should have been apparent that I was pointing that out as examples of one of the many, many times where people have went with the "differences between CPUs don't matter because other things mask the differences".

If you want to ignore the actual point I made because of an arbitrary detail, so be it.
The difference between the 7800X3D and 9800X3D is not the same as the difference between Sandy Bridge and first gen FX.

Yes I read correctly what you said, you don't like the answer is all.
No, I'm simply confused because you're resorting to pointing out something that is irrelevant to what I said.

I never even claimed the performance spread in the example I was using represented the same performance spread between another two random CPUs. Why would you even presume that?

My point was that people have used the "faster CPUs don't matter because the increase of the faster CPU gets masked for most people/most of the time" forever.

My response wasn't even to disagree with that in entirety.

It was just to say that faster CPUs aren't entirely reduced to being equal to slower ones because of it. There are circumstances (individual games, etc.) where a faster CPU helps, especially when you consider that not everyone is on a 7800X3D to begin with. Yeah, if you have a 7800X3D then the 9800X3D is pretty pointless. Similar to how a 7800X3D is pretty pointless to a 5800X3D owner, and similar to how an 11900K is pointless to a 10900K owner, and so on. Not everyone has the current fastest CPU when a new one exists though. There's plenty of AM4 (mostly non-X3D users) or older Intel users who will be comparing the 9800X3D to those lower points, and there it starts to make a little more sense, at least if you already have a decent GPU and/or play certain games where the CPU (or cache) matters a lot. And some people have decent GPUs and some people play those sorts of games.
Schrute_Farms_B&B 2024 年 11 月 7 日 上午 8:30 
引用自 Tiberius
Intel has been irrelevant since 5800x3d.

Weird take by some users here. Just because your fave games dont demand plenty of cpu power, it doesnt mean the cpu upgrade is pointless for others.

Look at msfs2020 benchmark. 9800x3d is almost 20% better than the next best cpu, 7800x3d (84fps vs 70fps).

The difference will be even more noticable once you add framegen on top of it.

Myself personally isnt gon upgrade from my current 7950x3d. Upgrading on every gen is a waste of money imo.

Regular MSFS2020 player here. MSFS2020 might be one of the, when not THE most demanding game CPU-wise in the last years
, even on 4K/4K Ultrawide.
When I switched from AM4 to AM5,(5800X3D to 7800X3D), I kept my 6900XT for a few weeks before gifting it to my brother.

It always bothered me that you got those microstutters, even with high end hardware so I was pretty optimistic when I fired up the game after switching to AM5.
Keep in mind, Im playing MSFS on 5120×2160 or 3440x1440 if there is no upscaling option.

Ima keep it sweet and short. NOTHING has changed, literally nothing, and Im someone who doesnt run any game without Rivatuner overlay + graph.
Better 1%'s. sure, but like already mentioned in another comment, you couldnt feel the difference while playing.

Wanna know how I got rid of most of the stutters?
By upgrading my GPU.
I know, crazy right?

5800X3D, 7800X3D, 9800X3D, 200000X3D, youll notice no to almost no difference as long as you dont run into a CPU bottleneck.
Period.
1080p/720p is another story, Ill give you guys that.

edit:
And this goes for all games out there, CPU intensive or not.
最后由 Schrute_Farms_B&B 编辑于; 2024 年 11 月 7 日 上午 8:33
Tiberius 2024 年 11 月 7 日 上午 8:36 
引用自 Schrute_Farms_B&B
引用自 Tiberius
Intel has been irrelevant since 5800x3d.

Weird take by some users here. Just because your fave games dont demand plenty of cpu power, it doesnt mean the cpu upgrade is pointless for others.

Look at msfs2020 benchmark. 9800x3d is almost 20% better than the next best cpu, 7800x3d (84fps vs 70fps).

The difference will be even more noticable once you add framegen on top of it.

Myself personally isnt gon upgrade from my current 7950x3d. Upgrading on every gen is a waste of money imo.

Regular MSFS2020 player here. MSFS2020 might be one of the, when not THE most demanding game CPU-wise in the last years
, even on 4K/4K Ultrawide.
When I switched from AM4 to AM5,(5800X3D to 7800X3D), I kept my 6900XT for a few weeks before gifting it to my brother.

It always bothered me that you got those microstutters, even with high end hardware so I was pretty optimistic when I fired up the game after switching to AM5.
Keep in mind, Im playing MSFS on 5120×2160 or 3440x1440 if there is no upscaling option.

Ima keep it sweet and short. NOTHING has changed, literally nothing, and Im someone who doesnt run any game without Rivatuner overlay + graph.
Better 1%'s. sure, but like already mentioned in another comment, you couldnt feel the difference while playing.

Wanna know how I got rid of most of the stutters?
By upgrading my GPU.
I know, crazy right?

5800X3D, 7800X3D, 9800X3D, 200000X3D, youll notice no difference as long as you dont run into a CPU bottleneck.
Period.
1080p/720p is another story, Ill give you guys that.

So your gpu cant handle 4k, and now suddenly the cpu upgrade is bad?

Do you also knw that if your ram is only 4gb, a rtx4090 wont make the perfomance better?

Jfc some ppl in this thread 🤦‍♂️
Schrute_Farms_B&B 2024 年 11 月 7 日 上午 8:39 
引用自 Tiberius
引用自 Schrute_Farms_B&B

Regular MSFS2020 player here. MSFS2020 might be one of the, when not THE most demanding game CPU-wise in the last years
, even on 4K/4K Ultrawide.
When I switched from AM4 to AM5,(5800X3D to 7800X3D), I kept my 6900XT for a few weeks before gifting it to my brother.

It always bothered me that you got those microstutters, even with high end hardware so I was pretty optimistic when I fired up the game after switching to AM5.
Keep in mind, Im playing MSFS on 5120×2160 or 3440x1440 if there is no upscaling option.

Ima keep it sweet and short. NOTHING has changed, literally nothing, and Im someone who doesnt run any game without Rivatuner overlay + graph.
Better 1%'s. sure, but like already mentioned in another comment, you couldnt feel the difference while playing.

Wanna know how I got rid of most of the stutters?
By upgrading my GPU.
I know, crazy right?

5800X3D, 7800X3D, 9800X3D, 200000X3D, youll notice no difference as long as you dont run into a CPU bottleneck.
Period.
1080p/720p is another story, Ill give you guys that.

So your gpu cant handle 4k, and now suddenly the cpu upgrade is bad?

Do you also knw that if your ram is only 4gb, a rtx4090 wont make the perfomance better?

Jfc some ppl in this thread 🤦‍♂️

Yeah, a 6900XT is a pretty low end card, right?
You didnt rly got the whole point of my comment, did you?

Unlike you,Im not talking out of my as*. Ive personally experienced the difference between a 5800X3D and a 7800X3D on high resolution.
Tiberius 2024 年 11 月 7 日 上午 8:40 
引用自 Schrute_Farms_B&B
引用自 Tiberius

So your gpu cant handle 4k, and now suddenly the cpu upgrade is bad?

Do you also knw that if your ram is only 4gb, a rtx4090 wont make the perfomance better?

Jfc some ppl in this thread 🤦‍♂️

Yeah, a 6900XT is a pretty low end card, right?
You didnt rly got the whole point of my comment, did you?

Unlike you,Im not talking out of my as*. Ive personally experienced the difference between a 5800X3D and a 7800X3D on high resolution.

The whole point of your comment is you're bottlenecked by your gpu and you expect a cpu upgrade would magicaly make the bottleneck disappear.
Tiberius 2024 年 11 月 7 日 上午 8:45 
Angry Gandalf 2024 年 11 月 7 日 上午 8:48 
@SchruteFams
You are aware that you are on the Steam forum, right?

Just take a quick look into Tiberius comment history and tell me, it's worth the hassle.
Schrute_Farms_B&B 2024 年 11 月 7 日 上午 8:50 
引用自 Tiberius
引用自 Schrute_Farms_B&B

Yeah, a 6900XT is a pretty low end card, right?
You didnt rly got the whole point of my comment, did you?

Unlike you,Im not talking out of my as*. Ive personally experienced the difference between a 5800X3D and a 7800X3D on high resolution.

The whole point of your comment is you're bottlenecked by your gpu and you expect a cpu upgrade would magicaly make the bottleneck disappear.

You know, what "heavy" on CPU means, right?
CPU workload was always at 100% on MSFS2020, even with a 7800X3D even on a 4k ultrawide,a resolution youve prob never heard about, much less played on....

Thats what Im talking about. People talking out of their AS* and selling it as facts just because theyve read or heard something somewhere....
Tiberius 2024 年 11 月 7 日 上午 8:53 
引用自 Angry Gandalf
@SchruteFams
You are aware that you are on the Steam forum, right?

Just take a quick look into Tiberius comment history and tell me, it's worth the hassle.

ahh yes the classic "i have nothing to add to the conversation but let me do some ad hominem to show how good i am at this topic"
Schrute_Farms_B&B 2024 年 11 月 7 日 上午 8:58 
引用自 Angry Gandalf
@SchruteFams
You are aware that you are on the Steam forum, right?

Just take a quick look into Tiberius comment history and tell me, it's worth the hassle.

He is entitled to his opinion and so am I.
No reason to derail.
< >
正在显示第 46 - 60 条,共 129 条留言
每页显示数: 1530 50

发帖日期: 2024 年 11 月 6 日 上午 9:07
回复数: 129