Rx 580 8gb or Gtx 1650 4gb

[Arton]

I have ryzen 3 2200g + 16gb dual ram
Now its time for an upgrade but I'm so confused which one to buy...also they're the same price

Some say rx others says 1650 is the best idk which one is more future proof and better.

Thanks !

[Supafly]

The RX580

For a start it has double the memory. You can see the performance of them here

https://gpu.userbenchmark.com/Compare/Nvidia-GTX-1650-vs-AMD-RX-580/4039vs3923

[_I_]

580 is close to a 1060 6g

more vram doesnt make a better gpu
*excpetion is the 1060 3g vs 6g, they have the same gpu core, but the 3g ver is cut on cores and tmus

580 4g and 8g have the exact same core performance
8g will allow for more textures/models to be stored in vram, better for cad tasks but not gaming

going from the apu to a dedicated gpu, you may need a better psu also

[Arton]

Początkowo opublikowane przez _I_:

580 is close to a 1060 6g

more vram doesnt make a better gpu
*excpetion is the 1060 3g vs 6g, they have the same gpu core, but the 3g ver is cut on cores and tmus

580 4g and 8g have the exact same core performance
8g will allow for more textures/models to be stored in vram, better for cad tasks but not gaming

going from the apu to a dedicated gpu, you may need a better psu also

I have 620w psu Seasonic...is that good ?

[_I_]

that will be fine with either

[upcoast]

They trade blows, my preference is the rx580.

https://www.techspot.com/review/1945-nvidia-geforce-gtx-1650-super/

[Bad 💀 Motha]

I'd look to go towards a 1660 Super minimum. Otherwise look at 2060 KO or Super... or RX 5700

[Arton]

So 1650 is better than rx 580 but still rx is better because of 8gb vram ????

[Supafly]

Początkowo opublikowane przez Arton:

So 1650 is better than rx 580 but still rx is better because of 8gb vram ????

Reread the posts and use the link.

RX has more ram so that will be better for textures and stuff. Performance wise the link I provided shows the RX also performs better than the 1650. So if your budget means they are your best options the RX is the better card.

EDIT: Some of the others have linked and referenced the 1650 Super not 1650 or even suggested a 1660 super. Again not the 1650. Unless you have a higher budget and those are the best options you can around the RX580 is better than the 1650

[Wichtelman]

personally i would prefer rx 580 8gb over 1650 4gb and also super cuz of the vram but i would also get the rx 580 second hand for under 100$/€... if you buy a new card go gtx 1660 ti or super...

if we talk about rx 580 vs gtx 1650...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PsRsbdQcwGQ

more comparisons...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ptguvEGcLw4

[Arton]

Początkowo opublikowane przez Dead Monkey:

Początkowo opublikowane przez Arton:

So 1650 is better than rx 580 but still rx is better because of 8gb vram ????

Reread the posts and use the link.

RX has more ram so that will be better for textures and stuff. Performance wise the link I provided shows the RX also performs better than the 1650. So if your budget means they are your best options the RX is the better card.

EDIT: Some of the others have linked and referenced the 1650 Super not 1650 or even suggested a 1660 super. Again not the 1650. Unless you have a higher budget and those are the best options you can around the RX580 is better than the 1650

Sorry for late response, I've been busy with work
Anyways is it worth saving a little bit more for 1660 gpu ? I just hope there wouldn't be any problem with my 2200g

[Arton]

Początkowo opublikowane przez Wichtelman:

personally i would prefer rx 580 8gb over 1650 4gb and also super cuz of the vram but i would also get the rx 580 second hand for under 100$/€... if you buy a new card go gtx 1660 ti or super...

if we talk about rx 580 vs gtx 1650...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PsRsbdQcwGQ

more comparisons...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ptguvEGcLw4

Recently I've been looking at 1660 and im thinking about buying it, idk man

Anyways Thanks :)

[Bad 💀 Motha]

Początkowo opublikowane przez Arton:

So 1650 is better than rx 580 but still rx is better because of 8gb vram ????

Forget the vram amount. Unless you run Ultra settings, you shouldn't need more then 4gb vram. If you do then I'd look at a better gpu such as gtx 1660 super or 2060 super.

580 8gb is only as good performance wise as gtx 1060 6gb, to which even a 1650 Super surpasses

If you want good bang for buck from AMD, look at 5600 XT

[dOBER]

Początkowo opublikowane przez Arton:

So 1650 is better than rx 580 but still rx is better because of 8gb vram ????

In which game a low end card like this needs more then 4gb vram. Its not like you can play on 4k ultra settings with a card like this. So no 8gb doesnt make it any better at all.

[Arton]

Początkowo opublikowane przez Bad 💀 Motha:

Początkowo opublikowane przez Arton:

So 1650 is better than rx 580 but still rx is better because of 8gb vram ????

Forget the vram amount. Unless you run Ultra settings, you shouldn't need more then 4gb vram. If you do then I'd look at a better gpu such as gtx 1660 super or 2060 super.

580 8gb is only as good performance wise as gtx 1060 6gb, to which even a 1650 Super surpasses

If you want good bang for buck from AMD, look at 5600 XT

Damn I'm limited with current cpu, wish I had ryzen 5, I can't afford both cpu and gpu atm....
5600 xt ? Is it better than rx 580/590 or gtx 1650-66 ?

[Arton]

Początkowo opublikowane przez dOBER:

Początkowo opublikowane przez Arton:

So 1650 is better than rx 580 but still rx is better because of 8gb vram ????

In which game a low end card like this needs more then 4gb vram. Its not like you can play on 4k ultra settings with a card like this. So no 8gb doesnt make it any better at all.

I'm just confused because of mixed responses, some says it matters but some says it doesn't lol