McMichael 2014년 9월 30일 오후 2시 39분
Canadian Dollar
Hi there,

This seems like a cool idea. Is Steam going to try and beat the credit card conversion rates? I'm just wondering what convenience this will add to Canadian customers.

-CM
< >
전체 댓글 334개 중 226~240개 표시 중
Wangotango52 2014년 10월 9일 오전 9시 09분 
I am afraid I have to side with the cynics on this steam change to CAD. RIGHT NOW the prices are just different by exchange rate. If Steam made a firm promise that this was all they were planning on doing I might feel better. But the main reason to change the site (especially not showing the US prices anymore) is most likely so they can introduce "Regional pricing" which for US based firms usually means - everyone else pays more.

A recent interview with the President of the Canadian retailers association was enlightening. She said the CDN retailers were pissed with US (and US distributers of foreign made stuff) wholesale prices to Canada that were WAY higher than could be explained by exchange, shipping (not relavent to digital distribution). When asked why they priced so high - "because they can".
They control the products people want and the various wholesalers are complicit in their pricing strategies for Canada. Great examples can be found by comparing same products on Amazon.ca and Amazon.com. CDN markups of 50 percent (sometimes 100 percent) are common. Plus shipping is more expensive. Unlike Amazon, Steam has made it impossible to check US pricing without using a region hiding service and setting up a new US account.

So over time I think you will find differential pricing for Steam games for Canadians which in a year or two will be significantly larger than just the exchange rate. There is really no other reason to make this change.
Wangotango52 2014년 10월 9일 오전 9시 30분 
Also, a note to Satoru. You say you are Canadian but your profile says you are from the US.
Your extensive and continuous support of this (vs almost universal negativity from Canadians) shows that either 1) you work for Steam/Valve or a US video game company or 2) again, you are not a Canadian otherwise you would understand how many times we are screwed on these pricing issues. And PS: we are NOT wealthier than the US!
HLCinSC 2014년 10월 9일 오전 9시 33분 
Wangotango52님이 먼저 게시:
Also, a note to Satoru. You say you are Canadian but your profile says you are from the US.
Your extensive and continuous support of this (vs almost universal negativity from Canadians) shows that either 1) you work for Steam/Valve or a US video game company or 2) again, you are not a Canadian otherwise you would understand how many times we are screwed on these pricing issues. And PS: we are NOT wealthier than the US!
He said earlier a couple times that he was born and raised in Canada and moved to Massachusetts to work at a start up.
Machin Ator 2014년 10월 9일 오전 9시 40분 
Wangotango52님이 먼저 게시:
I am afraid I have to side with the cynics on this steam change to CAD. RIGHT NOW the prices are just different by exchange rate. If Steam made a firm promise that this was all they were planning on doing I might feel better. But the main reason to change the site (especially not showing the US prices anymore) is most likely so they can introduce "Regional pricing" which for US based firms usually means - everyone else pays more.

A recent interview with the President of the Canadian retailers association was enlightening. She said the CDN retailers were pissed with US (and US distributers of foreign made stuff) wholesale prices to Canada that were WAY higher than could be explained by exchange, shipping (not relavent to digital distribution). When asked why they priced so high - "because they can".
They control the products people want and the various wholesalers are complicit in their pricing strategies for Canada. Great examples can be found by comparing same products on Amazon.ca and Amazon.com. CDN markups of 50 percent (sometimes 100 percent) are common. Plus shipping is more expensive. Unlike Amazon, Steam has made it impossible to check US pricing without using a region hiding service and setting up a new US account.

So over time I think you will find differential pricing for Steam games for Canadians which in a year or two will be significantly larger than just the exchange rate. There is really no other reason to make this change.

Bingo. See, some of us can read that writing on the wall.
Machin Ator 2014년 10월 9일 오전 9시 42분 
HLCinSC님이 먼저 게시:
Wangotango52님이 먼저 게시:
Also, a note to Satoru. You say you are Canadian but your profile says you are from the US.
Your extensive and continuous support of this (vs almost universal negativity from Canadians) shows that either 1) you work for Steam/Valve or a US video game company or 2) again, you are not a Canadian otherwise you would understand how many times we are screwed on these pricing issues. And PS: we are NOT wealthier than the US!
He said earlier a couple times that he was born and raised in Canada and moved to Massachusetts to work at a start up.

Well since he isnt affected by the change, and seems to have hundreds of comments in each thread, I thought he worked for Valve.

I find it hard to understand how someone can be so involved in defending a change which does not affect them - but which does affect many others. I also found the lack of honesty and candour to be discouraging, as though unable to ackowledge that this change was made for the SOLE REASON of being able to squeeze Canadians for more money, if not now, in the future.
Kahrkura 2014년 10월 9일 오전 10시 23분 
I'm still a little bothered by the currency change, though less so now than before. My biggest gripe was being able to easily compare prices between Steam and other online retailers. A website I frequent, IsThereAnyDeal, could have potentially solved the issue of comparing prices between Steam and that of other retailers since all their prices are listed in one currency, but since many game titles don't have their prices changed according to the current exchange rate I won't be able to compare the USD pricing of Steam products. The one potential upside is that at least a few titles on Steam have the same $ cost as they did when the pricing was in USD but since the value of the Canadian Dollar is lower I could potentially save some money on certain titles. This also suggests that certain titles may have mark ups, though most tiles I've seen that have a higher $ cost are within a couple % difference of the USD cost after taking the exchange rate into account. As a budget conscientious gamer I'm going to have to spend a little extra time, looking up exchange rates, whenever I'm considering purchasing a game on Steam. Perhaps the change in currency might save me a small sum on a purchase. If it doesn't, I'll simply purchase my games elsewhere.
Kahrkura 님이 마지막으로 수정; 2014년 10월 9일 오전 10시 24분
Satoru 2014년 10월 9일 오전 10시 41분 
Rock Harder님이 먼저 게시:
Well since he isnt affected by the change, and seems to have hundreds of comments in each thread, I thought he worked for Valve.

And whether I do or not is not relevant to the facts of the matter. And is not relevant to my arguments or the data pricing that currently exists.

I find it hard to understand how someone can be so involved in defending a change which does not affect them - but which does affect many others. I also found the lack of honesty and candour to be discouraging, as though unable to ackowledge that this change was made for the SOLE REASON of being able to squeeze Canadians for more money, if not now, in the future.

If you're going to continue with ad hominem attacks to support your position, then perhaps you may consider your position to be far more tenuous than you imagine.

Again the idea that the change is utterly catastrophic to Canadians isn't borne out by the actual prices. Most titles, as shown in the top 20, are cheaper in CAD. Items that are more expensive have only a minimal price increase.

So you're not being squeezed out of money right now. If you're referring to some nebulous future, then I can argue that as the CAD goes down, that your pricing differential will in fact improve. Both scenarios are equally as likely. Thus to assert that changes 'sole reason' is to 'squeeze canadians for more money' is currently not happening, and there is a reasonable scenario in the future where that also is not the case.

The 'currency change is to squeeze more money out of Canadians' argument also falls flat on its face when you consider Australia and New Zeland. Regions that are getting kicked in the nuts in pricing on Steam, but use USD to do it. If, as you assert, the currency change is to 'increase prices', publishers can do that, right now, in USD. And there are 2 countries, right nwo, where it is happening. Ergo, the idea that publishers 'forced' the currency change to do this, is absurd. They don't need to do that if they just want to raise prices. They can do it unilaterally on Steam with USD. So even this argument is basically 100% false.

What you are doing is simply imposing a 'single' scenario and extrapolating it as fact. When again, the current situation doesn't actually reflect the 'doomsday' scenario you're describing nor is the future scenario any more or less likely than the one I put forth. And you can't bring up the edge cases like NBA2K15 and use that as a sign of the coming apocoalypse while also ignoring the other side of those edge caes like Borderlands The PreSequel.

Aside from the extreme tail ends of the spectrum (both expensive and cheap), the change to CAD is overall a net positive for Canadians in terms of fairly moderate savings of 1-2%, even if you don't take into account the 1-3% foreing transaction fees. And even the deviations from that are actually fairly small on the high end, with NBA2K15/FarCry4 being 5% more expensive in CAD, but on the discount side thre are much larger benefits of around 10% for various titles like CivBE/Borderlands.

If you're going to scream and shout at least look at the pricing structure as a whole, rather than cherry picking 3 games on the high end and extrapolating the apocalypse. At least the "I hate the change because comparing prices on the market is more annoying" as a far more legitiamte complaint that 'we are getting robbed' which realistically isn't the case for the vast majority of games on Seteam after the conversion.

If you look at the pricing objectively, the change doesn't shake up the landscape that much from a pricing perspective. And certainly doesn't even come close to how pricing jumped dramatically with the introduction of GBP/Euros back in teh day.
Satoru 님이 마지막으로 수정; 2014년 10월 9일 오전 10시 54분
Satoru 2014년 10월 9일 오전 10시 58분 
Wangotango52님이 먼저 게시:
IBut the main reason to change the site (especially not showing the US prices anymore) is most likely so they can introduce "Regional pricing" which for US based firms usually means - everyone else pays more.

Russia Brazil and the new South East Asia currencies would love to talk with you about that. Since prices in those regions decreased when the currencies were introduced.

Lets also consider that the poster child for regional pricing, Australia, has their games, priced in USD higher than in other regions. Thus the argument falls on its face because IT IS NOT NECESSARY to convert the currencies to do what you suppose is the end game. Publishers can do it right now without having to 'force' steam to convert currencies.
Bladewind 2014년 10월 9일 오후 12시 02분 
Let`s put some statistics for the argument. Before making any prices, check the steamprices website: https://www.steamprices.com/

As I have a US$ account created specifically for internet purchases, I am not please with this change. Steam should give us a choice to make the purchase in US or CDN$, not dictate.
Satoru 2014년 10월 9일 오후 12시 14분 
Bladewind님이 먼저 게시:
Let`s put some statistics for the argument. Before making any prices, check the steamprices website: https://www.steamprices.com/

As I have a US$ account created specifically for internet purchases, I am not please with this change. Steam should give us a choice to make the purchase in US or CDN$, not dictate.

If you coudl 'choose' everyone would choose Rubles
Wangotango52 2014년 10월 9일 오후 12시 23분 
The comment that AU and NZ are currently charged more in USD is interesting. So steam does have that capability already to do regional pricing?
It doesn't change the fact that I am 90 precent sure that our prices will go up more than exchange rate within a year or two. Looking at the situation right now isn't relavent to the discussion as Steam/Valve are smart enough not to that into effect until all this commentary has died down.
Straight question Santoru - do you receive any finacial renumeration from Steam/valve or gaming company or it's paid PR or consultants?
Machin Ator 2014년 10월 9일 오후 12시 24분 
Satoru님이 먼저 게시:
Bladewind님이 먼저 게시:
Let`s put some statistics for the argument. Before making any prices, check the steamprices website: https://www.steamprices.com/

As I have a US$ account created specifically for internet purchases, I am not please with this change. Steam should give us a choice to make the purchase in US or CDN$, not dictate.

If you coudl 'choose' everyone would choose Rubles

First off, what exactly is wrong with that, if they did choose Rubles - seriously

Second, there was no ad hominem attack; I pointed out that you seem to be arguing from a disingenuous position where you would not accept the currency changes lay the groundwork for future changes; like increased pricing in the market or the collection of tax.

Whether or not prices are significantly higher now is not the issue; the issue is where prices are going, and why the status quo was not good enough.
Pixel Peeper 2014년 10월 9일 오후 1시 13분 
Skatlols Schmalols님이 먼저 게시:
Tripoteur Ventripotent님이 먼저 게시:

That doesn't make any sense... I mean, sure, buying in USD allowed you to avoid being screwed on the exchange rate, but that only saved you 2% or 3% (what PayPal and/or credit cards overcharge when converting currency).

Some of the prices have only increased by 10% (lower than the exchange rate), which means you're actually paying less for them now.

I suggest watching the exchange rates and the prices of the games in both currencies to make sure you don't get scammed eventually, but right now things haven't changed significantly. You're not paying 10% or 15% more.

Wut?

A game that was 14.99 USD is now 16.99 CAD, and that's the lesser price hike. That is NOT 2-3%. Calculate it.

Um... are you just ignoring the exchange rate?

14.99 USD = 16.7446 CAD

You're paying 16.99 CAD instead of 16.7446 CAD. That's an increase of about 1.5%. Some games are actually cheaper.

Like I said, be wary. Watch the exchange rate and compare the price of games in both currencies. And yes, watch out for greedy publishers.

But don't make things up. The vast majority of the time, right now, you're *not* paying 10% more, not even close.
Satoru 2014년 10월 9일 오후 1시 26분 
Wangotango52님이 먼저 게시:
The comment that AU and NZ are currently charged more in USD is interesting. So steam does have that capability already to do regional pricing?

Correct.

http://store.steampowered.com/app/65980/?cc=au

CivBE is priced at $49.99USD. its 89.99USD in Australia/NZ. There are many other titles that are priced like that but it's basically 'any title that has a retail release'. Shadow of Mordor is another but there's plenty you can look at on the AU/NZ store.

It also does this in Europe. There is in fact 2 Euro 'tiers' of pricing. So a game, in Euros, will have 2 separate prices depending if you're in France or Spain.

https://steamdb.info/app/730/

This has existed for several years.

So it's not reasonable to attribute the currency conversion as a pretense to increasing prices. Since steam already has that capability, and can still maintain the existing currency.

It doesn't change the fact that I am 90 precent sure that our prices will go up more than exchange rate within a year or two. Looking at the situation right now isn't relavent to the discussion as Steam/Valve are smart enough not to that into effect until all this commentary has died down.

But again there's the flip side to that where as the CAD drops, but the 'absolute' price remains the same your pricing differential improves. Steam isn't a stock exchange where it shifts pricing on a daily basis. If the CAD drops 5% steam isn't going to immediately start re-pricing everything to compensate. The store simply doesn't work that way. So again you can have both sides of that coin. Even highly traded items like CS:GO keys are only adjusted infrequently. Even the price of CS:GO the game hasn't changed I believe from it's release in 2012, despite fluctuations in GBP and Euros.

Straight question Santoru - do you receive any finacial renumeration from Steam/valve or gaming company or it's paid PR or consultants?

Bit of a loaded question isnt it?

Yes in fact my big fat check is due any day now once I hit 10000 posts. So keep complaining otherwise i can't make my boat payment this month for my vacation in Dubai! This stuff doesn't pay for itself you know.

Does it really matter what my answer is, given that you're already making the assumption?
Satoru 님이 마지막으로 수정; 2014년 10월 9일 오후 1시 28분
Satoru 2014년 10월 9일 오후 1시 27분 
Tripoteur Ventripotent님이 먼저 게시:

14.99 USD = 16.7446 CAD\

Note that the 14.99USD price point is only one of a few points I'm aware of where the CAD conversion is not in your favor (6.99/8.99 are the other but teh % difference is 0.2%). All other price points that use the Steam standard conversion are priced 1-2% lower than their USD price.
Satoru 님이 마지막으로 수정; 2014년 10월 9일 오후 1시 34분
< >
전체 댓글 334개 중 226~240개 표시 중
페이지당 표시 개수: 1530 50

게시된 날짜: 2014년 9월 30일 오후 2시 39분
게시글: 334