此主题已被锁定
dragenkill 2023 年 6 月 30 日 上午 8:19
age verification
We need an age verification so that the content that is blocked due to the protection of minors guidelines can be made available again
最后由 dragenkill 编辑于; 2023 年 7 月 1 日 下午 2:49
< >
正在显示第 46 - 60 条,共 60 条留言
引用自 dragenkill
It just violates the terms if you've to use a VPN connection to activate a key but even then Valve wouldn't judge you.
The VPN restriction is more likely to prevent buying games from regions with a huge price difference compared to your region.
And again... there's just a bunch of special cases with a strict restriction.
Except this special cases you can get the other games by key or gifting.

but this it not the point ont this
I just wanted to correct your wrong assumptions...
引用自 dragenkill
You can get nearly all of the restricted-in-Germany games as a gift or by key... that was explained/discussed so many times in the German forum.
Of course it would be nice to buy this games with one mouse click but it is what it is and seems as a German user you have to do two clicks. ¯\_:cat_and_thoughts:_/¯

This is no longer something that Steam has prevented as far as I know
Because that's just spreading misinformation.
dragenkill 2023 年 6 月 30 日 下午 3:32 
引用自 dragenkill

but this it not the point ont this
I just wanted to correct your wrong assumptions...
引用自 dragenkill

This is no longer something that Steam has prevented as far as I know
Because that's just spreading misinformation.

what for misinformation this misinformation is givin non legal way I won't listen about ways what is illigal or violated the terms
引用自 dragenkill
I just wanted to correct your wrong assumptions...

Because that's just spreading misinformation.

what for misinformation this misinformation is givin non legal way I won't listen about ways what is illigal or violated the terms
Dude... do you've even read what I've wrote before that?
It's not illegal or a violation to the terms to buy (neither activate) a key or get a gift of a restricted game.
Except a few special cases which can't be activated even with VPN.
dragenkill 2023 年 6 月 30 日 下午 3:49 
引用自 dragenkill

what for misinformation this misinformation is givin non legal way I won't listen about ways what is illigal or violated the terms
Dude... do you've even read what I've wrote before that?
It's not illegal or a violation to the terms to buy (neither activate) a key or get a gift of a restricted game.
Except a few special cases which can't be activated even with VPN.

Yes, and it's about the special cases that are not permitted in Germany And further, it's not about the keys here, which is why I won't go into it any further
sanyok 2023 年 7 月 1 日 下午 12:43 
引用自 rawWwRrr
The day I have to provide an identity card to an online store in which to purchase a video game will be the end of my video game purchases.
If your region isn't affected, you don't have to. It's only for those who see the "This item is currently unavailable in your region" page.

BTW, you have already provided Valve with your name and address for the invoices. So is ID really a big deal to you? Probably only if you have something to hide.


引用自 Crazy Tiger
I wouldn't be so triggerhappy on providing an ID to a corporation that can't verify said ID anyway. Better to not share such sensitive information.
It seems you have the wrong idea about it. You should rather compare it to a visit to a disco or something. A bouncer outside asks for your ID, you show it to him, he lets you in. That doesn't sound that complicated, does it? Nobody will verify anything or store your personal data. They will just unlock the account for the restricted area and that's it.


And I've to ask again... do you have a reliable source other than assumption? Because I've get some (in-Germany-restricted) game gifts myself this year and had no problem to receive them.
For gifts you need someone you can trust very well because you have to send them the money first. You found one, fine, but not everyone has a person like that. And you wouldn't just send 60€ to a complete stranger, would you?

In addition, this person must be in the same currency region. Gifts from the USA, for instance, are no longer possible. From Asia or South America this has never been possible anyway. So in this specific case, the donor must preferably be somewhere in the EU.

And as for the keys. You want an example. Here comes one - "Dying Light". The second part is available on Steam for whatever reason.

In order to activate a key, you have to buy it first, right? And of course you should buy it from an official reseller and not on the gray market with unknown origin.

So let's visit one of the famous resellers - HumbleBundle. You visit the website, type in the name of the game and guess what? Nothing comes. No problem. You use Google & Co. and find the page with the game there. But what comes when you click the link? Right! "The game is not available for purchase in your country".

OK. You visit another famous reseller - Fanatical. The same procedure. The same result - "Will not activate in Germany" with no "Purchase" button.

And so on. You can't even buy a key legally. And even if you manage to get a key, there is absolutely no guarantee that it will work, because the situation often changes. Both Dying Light Enhanced Edition (Sub ID: 88801) and Dying Light Definitive Edition (Sub ID: 633707) have recent restrictions - "This package can NOT be activated or purchased in specified countries: ...", and Germany is also on that list. Maybe it worked in the past, but now it's definitely uncertain. And that means risk.

German users can't even visit the Community Hub of such games anymore, which was possible just a short time ago. And as you mentioned yourself, there are still games that can't be gifted or activated with keys at all. So what about them? Just do without them even though it's legal to have them?

Anyway, your suggestions with gifts and keys are not as easy as you think. And they're not for everyone either. There's just too much risk involved. The solution with a simple one-time age verification will certainly cause a lot less headache and stress.
引用自 sanyok
German users can't even visit the Community Hub of such games anymore,
You've to own the game, then you can enter the game-hub.

引用自 sanyok
Anyway, your suggestions with gifts and keys are not as easy as you think.
I don't think it's easy, I KNOW it's easy... never had a problem so far to get the games I want. ¯\_:smugcatsack:_/¯
sanyok 2023 年 7 月 1 日 下午 7:25 
You've to own the game, then you can enter the game-hub.
However, this was not always the case; it was only recently changed. You can still visit the Community Hub of unblocked games even if you don't own them.

I don't think it's easy, I KNOW it's easy... never had a problem so far to get the games I want.
Then this thread is not for you.
引用自 sanyok
You've to own the game, then you can enter the game-hub.
However, this was not always the case; it was only recently changed. You can still visit the Community Hub of unblocked games even if you don't own them.
You don't say...:pudcatsurprised:
But we're not talking about non-restricted games.:cat_and_thoughts:

引用自 sanyok
I don't think it's easy, I KNOW it's easy... never had a problem so far to get the games I want.
Then this thread is not for you.
It's a public forum and no echo-chamber so you leave it to me in which topic I participate, no :conwhat:
Anxiety 2023 年 7 月 2 日 上午 1:08 
You don't say...:pudcatsurprised:
But we're not talking about non-restricted games.:cat_and_thoughts:
I've got to say, your collection of cat smilies is impressive. :envy:
引用自 Anxiety
You don't say...:pudcatsurprised:
But we're not talking about non-restricted games.:cat_and_thoughts:
I've got to say, your collection of cat smilies is impressive. :envy:
:escapethx::cute: but nah... it's just a small collection from what's available at the market so no need to be impressed. :magicat:
AmsterdamHeavy 2023 年 7 月 2 日 上午 4:44 
引用自 dragenkill
引用自 AmsterdamHeavy


Ya, they do have the time to wait because the German government has no hold them. Worst case scenario they stop selling you ANY games.

I bet youd get some German citizens complaining about the legislators then. Well, that or claim to be victims of their own overreach.

Why don't you go into the other points everything I hear is just is your problem which sooner or later is not true, or are you afraid to realize that this can also happen in your country if an authority decides to take stricter accounts that's not just a problem in Germany everyone has to deal with the problem sooner or later employ 18+ is 18+ or don't you have something like that at your place

* and btw when is is for now stil a german can we get talk about it i mean this forum is four this thinks and the "simple" version is for now get a third-party host for this problem i see guys have problem with the mindset about i give no one my id card information but is a fact this is in german nearly normal for for certain things (SonyPS fore example have this when u buy with u card u have no option and must show him all information from u id card) we have the rules for this tu make sure about make nothing nonsens with this information
** and side fact I don't know how that's regulated in other countries, but our ID card even has its own online function

No. No one will EVER get my ID to access a website. A few months ago I tried to buy a $25 piece of plastic for my car and because I was using a VPN they demanded a copy of my ID. I told them to go F themselves if they are so worried about fraud on a $25 piece of plastic.

The fact that you think this is normal and OK explains why you think every other invasive and grasping law your country comes up with is reasonable. Those are not reasonable laws. It seems that Germans simply enjoy being micromanaged and told what to do.



You know what happens here in the US when states pass these stupid laws?

Companies stop serving those states.

Examples: Utah and West Virginia have both been dropped by ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥. Now people in those states cant use the site at all. Problem solved, children protected and adults get no wank material.

It all comes down to how important your market is to the business and if they can live without you. Im willing to bet that Valve can live without Germany and its stupid laws. Would they prefer to take your money? Of course...but your country is getting close to making it NOT WORTH serving you any longer because you push ridiculous and cumbersome precedents.
Ashley 2023 年 11 月 19 日 上午 10:13 
Just give us age verification already.

Most of us have access to digital IDs, and there are several apps and services that are supported by the government. It literally takes a single NFC scan on a phone to get it done. All you have to do is tap into that.

You've built an entire, separate infrastructure just for Chinese users, and you're telling me you can't give German users a simple age check?

Come on...
Dimwit Donald (very high IQ) 2024 年 11 月 29 日 下午 4:44 
I just saw a nipple. Luckily, it wasn't part of any displays of affection, or even reproduction, but located on a sadistically mutilated, disemboweled and partly decayed carcass, not loved and admired, but slaughtered for parts like a thing and left to rot, like it should be. I think I will be fine. Imagine making love, not mass murder. Sick.

:steamhappy:
最后由 Dimwit Donald (very high IQ) 编辑于; 2024 年 11 月 29 日 下午 5:29
Chronocide 2024 年 11 月 29 日 下午 5:52 
引用自 dragenkill
We need an age verification so that the content that is blocked due to the protection of minors guidelines can be made available again
Seems like steam has more to risk by selling adult content to germans than they have to gain.

https://usk.de/en/home/obligations-for-content-providers/

Even on the basic level, every single game needs to be registered with the USK labeling (which is probably not free). That's a lot of games that would need to be registered.

And even there, submitting your game to be registered does not automatically make it approved, they can reject games...

And then if steam provides even a single image, of something adult, to a minor, as the distributor, they can be fined up to 500,000 euros.
引用自 Boblin the Goblin
It isn't Steam's job to protect minors.
Legally, they are obligated to do so. And I think that's correct. Minors should be protected.

That said, it would be much easier to just not sell adult content to people from Germany

...which is apparently the direction they went: https://www.theouterhaven.net/2020/12/steam-region-blocks-adult-only-games-in-germany/

Definitely seems like Germany wrote a law that can't realistically be complied with for an international company, such as steam. It may even be intentionally so, as steam's profits really don't benefit Germany in the slightest.

Germany is a democracy, right? Vote to change it, if you think it's a problem. Honestly, seems like a good law for Germany. Sounds like they're looking out for you.
Connie 2024 年 11 月 29 日 下午 5:53 
This thread was quite old before the recent post, so we're locking it to prevent confusion.
< >
正在显示第 46 - 60 条,共 60 条留言
每页显示数: 1530 50

发帖日期: 2023 年 6 月 30 日 上午 8:19
回复数: 60