SmartRogue 27 września 2020 o 18:29
Recovery of Items lost through Scams
Last month I was scammed into an "item verification" con and before they could take all my items, I recognized it, and reported the individuals to Steam and Discord, as both programs were being used to perform it. Since then, I have gotten emails saying that the culprits were banned from trading, but other than that, there was no help in getting my items returned.

I am aware that there is a "Steam Item Restoration Policy", or rather, a lack of one. Steam does NOT restore any items you lose, even if you have sufficient evidence showing specifically what items were taken. Additionally, the reason for the denial of such service was given to me as "duplicating items would lower the value of other items on the Marketplace". I find this excuse to be utterly appalling and self-serving; instead of helping a loyal customer who was tricked by one of their other, less scrupulous customers posing as a Valve employee, they would rather prioritize the "economy" for virtual items. Instead of actual help, they give me "Security" advice, basically putting the blame on me for being tricked. I was being threatened with a Report/Banned account and did not trade away my items with the promise of earning a profit, I seriously thought my account was in danger.

This post is basically an expression of my frustration at this company for this irresponsible handling of a situation that they created. They can ban all the accounts they want, but in the end, the bad guy wins because they still had time to pawn off all the items they took and the consequences of their actions are a pittance to what I and many others may have lost. And if they get banned before they can sell the items, they couldn't care less because they had no emotional attachment to the items they took, and are lost forever to the parties they took it from. They can always make a new account, while I am forever reminded of my items missing from my inventory.

It doesn't matter how many security checkpoints you put into your system, if a person can figure out a way through them, or even POSE as one of the employees who imposed the security in the first place, you might as well not have them. There will ALWAYS be con men and cheats, but if you do not have a way to ensure that those who were cheated are not made whole again, then what is the point of trusting this company?
Początkowo opublikowane przez Black Blade:
First sorry for your items lost
Second, you should be happy that is all you lost, anyone can come and tell you there an employ, that happens everywhere also outside of Steam
I get more or less mouthly emails about this guy from somewhere that is an "important man" for company X and they
  • Want to give me money
  • I was sued for X and need to deal with it
  • My far family member has died and give me all her money but I need to talk to them to get it
  • They got photos of me doing porn (I have on camera on the PC and Blades don't do stuff like that.. so good luck to them) and I should send money in X time or they be published
  • A FBI agent has found I am stealing money and .....

There are lots of stuff like this (I got too many email accounts possibly) this scam is common in and out of Steam and you got hit on it here, lost items that you will not get back, that it hurts, but its better than losing your house, or all you got on your bank account because you fell for that and the bank may not be willing to help you
In the end with all the pain, you got out lucky
And you learn from it

The blame here is on education this is something people should learn, if in the past John Smith needed to go door to door to scam, they can today use bots to do this in millions

Use what you learn, tell your friends, and push it forward, that will be the parchment for the scammer that taken your stuff if everyone will know or at least enugth will know, scammers will have to stop as they will be spending more cash getting the scam going then what they gain from it

Valve is doing what they can to help but in the end, its a never-ending battle, and the root of it is human, only way Valve can really completely stop it, is close the trading system completely, have only the market and nothing else, but personally, I think most users will not want that at least not users that have this items and get hurt the most by the scammers

I hope you gain some new items to take there place, and you will use the pain to teach who ever you can to avoid this
As its the best you can do now
< >
Wyświetlanie 16-30 z 96 komentarzy
Supafly 28 września 2020 o 1:55 
If I give my car keys to a stranger and it gets stolen my insurance company won't payout.
If I give my house keys to a stranger and items get stolen my insurance company won't pay out.
If I give a stranger my phone my phone provider or phone insurer won't pay out.

You gave your items away and/or access to your account away. Why should Valve replace stuff YOU didn't protect?
Ostatnio edytowany przez: Supafly; 28 września 2020 o 1:56
Walach 28 września 2020 o 2:08 
The only thing I can think of that could work is to give the persons account a "ghost" version of each item he/she trades. This item cannot be traded etc but you can use it as a hazy version of whatever you traded.

But I don't really use the system so I have no idea what this might all be about, might not be that easy. :/
Tito Shivan 28 września 2020 o 2:10 
Początkowo opublikowane przez Napalm:
Additionally, the reason for the denial of such service was given to me as "duplicating items would lower the value of other items on the Marketplace". I find this excuse to be utterly appalling and self-serving; instead of helping a loyal customer who was tricked by one of their other, less scrupulous customers posing as a Valve employee, they would rather prioritize the "economy" for virtual items.
Few things to keep in mind why the actual policy is shaped the way it is. Measures are not taken in a vaccuum. There's usually a long road and a lot of steps that brough us where we stand now.

-Stolen items needed to be duplicated and not just given back because those items are resold, traded and put in the marketplace after the theft, taking part in multitude of transactions of users who don't know (nor need to) where the item came from. Undoing all those trades would annoy a long queue of people who never did anything wrong. Imagine if Valve rolled back a trade of yours or removed an item you bought from the marketplace because an item that was traded for an item that was sold in the marketplace to buy an item that got traded for your item was traded in exchange of a stolen one.

-Duplicating item does reduce the value of the other items. Imagine if you could print yourself another $20 bill if you got your wallet stolen. Now imagine what would happen to the $ value if we multiply that for the whole number of thefts happening in the US. Now your hard earned $20 is worth way less because some people get their wallet stolen and there's a lot of reprinted $20 bills out there.
Then there's thieves taking advantage of the feature. People 'faked' account hijacks in order to get 'two of the same' (Yes it happened in Steam)

-Returning items had a counterproductive effect. People engaged more in unsafe trading and account security practices (resulting in a increased number of scammed and hijacked users. Which in turn becomes a liability for the rest of users) because people knew they had a 'safety net' and daddy Valve would just restore their items if they got their accounts compromised.
SmartRogue 28 września 2020 o 7:09 
Początkowo opublikowane przez Tito Shivan:
Few things to keep in mind why the actual policy is shaped the way it is. Measures are not taken in a vaccuum. There's usually a long road and a lot of steps that brough us where we stand now.

-Stolen items needed to be duplicated and not just given back because those items are resold, traded and put in the marketplace after the theft, taking part in multitude of transactions of users who don't know (nor need to) where the item came from. Undoing all those trades would annoy a long queue of people who never did anything wrong. Imagine if Valve rolled back a trade of yours or removed an item you bought from the marketplace because an item that was traded for an item that was sold in the marketplace to buy an item that got traded for your item was traded in exchange of a stolen one.

-Duplicating item does reduce the value of the other items. Imagine if you could print yourself another $20 bill if you got your wallet stolen. Now imagine what would happen to the $ value if we multiply that for the whole number of thefts happening in the US. Now your hard earned $20 is worth way less because some people get their wallet stolen and there's a lot of reprinted $20 bills out there.
Then there's thieves taking advantage of the feature. People 'faked' account hijacks in order to get 'two of the same' (Yes it happened in Steam)

-Returning items had a counterproductive effect. People engaged more in unsafe trading and account security practices (resulting in a increased number of scammed and hijacked users. Which in turn becomes a liability for the rest of users) because people knew they had a 'safety net' and daddy Valve would just restore their items if they got their accounts compromised.
While I appreciate a Steam Community Moderator replying and explaining the policy, I still have to disagree with it. Here's why:

-In reality, I agree duplicating money would lower the cost of the currency being duplicated. That is what happens when counterfeit money is added to a population of real money, like in your example. But that is implying that the item being duplicated is going to be used in the economy. The items I want returned/duplicated are not going to be ever used the economy because I am not going to trade them. I wasn't even going to trade them to begin with until the scammer told me that if I didn't, my account would have been deleted and I would have lost EVERYTHING. I was scared and taken advantage of and will not stand continuing being a victim.

-You can say returning items has a counterproductive effect. And that might be true in the cases of unscrupulous people who think they can use loopholes. But if an employee looks at the individual who was a victim and do a background check on their trades and activities and possible accounts linked to their IP addresses, they can determine if they are honestly scammed and have their items returned, or if they are only faking it and have had abused the return system multiple times.

-If there ever was a return of a restoration of policy, I would limit it to only ONE time, and that is after a serious background check of trades and activities, and evidence provided by the victim to show that they were scammed. I did everything I could to help get the scammers reported to the system, but even if they get punished, I wasn't made whole again. The scammers can always make new accounts and do the same thing again and again, so what is the point of me trying to be a good customer reporting these ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥, if I am not going to be compensated for the things I lost to them. I was lucky enough to realize halfway that I was being tricked, instead of losing all of my items, but even then, I thought that Valve was going to help me afterward. I honestly didn't know about the no item restoration policy, and thought they would help me get my items back after locking those accounts after I reported them. How wrong I was, and how anguished I have become to learn the truth.

Supafly 28 września 2020 o 7:18 
Początkowo opublikowane przez Napalm:
**Snip

Fact is you were lax in your account security. You can discuss and hypothesize about past solutions, options, the good the bad and it won't matter. Valve isn't going to start provided users with lost items.

Insurances companies won't payout if you give strangers your home, bike, car keys and Valve should not be giving you skins back. Valve is doing the same thing every other business is. If you don't keep it secure they won't reimburse you.

Learn from the mistake so you keep everything secure
SmartRogue 28 września 2020 o 7:36 
Początkowo opublikowane przez Dead Monkey:

Fact is you were lax in your account security. You can discuss and hypothesize about past solutions, options, the good the bad and it won't matter. Valve isn't going to start provided users with lost items.

Insurances companies won't payout if you give strangers your home, bike, car keys and Valve should not be giving you skins back. Valve is doing the same thing every other business is. If you don't keep it secure they won't reimburse you.

Learn from the mistake so you keep everything secure
The "stranger" said they were a Valve Employee, they even gave me a link to their account proving it was. How was I supposed to not believe that? Isn't fraud a thing? Doesn't insurance protect against fraud?
Supafly 28 września 2020 o 7:43 
Początkowo opublikowane przez Napalm:
The "stranger" said they were a Valve Employee, they even gave me a link to their account proving it was. How was I supposed to not believe that? Isn't fraud a thing? Doesn't insurance protect against fraud?

Check everything. It's basic safety.

Because Valve does not contact users like that. If I walked upto you and told you I was a Bank Employee and gave you a profile, bank card, link to the banks website would you believe me? If so you'd be in trouble. It's a scam. You need to not believe everything on the internet and in person.

That was no different to dodgy emails or me calling you on the phone and claiming to be from your bank. I could have raided your bin last night and got various details I could tell you to make you believe me. Yet, you still shouldn't trust me. I've disconnected from actual bank staff that called me because they want me to verify who I am when they won't verify who they are. I've then contacted bank using standard number to follow up about them calling me. Never by the number they called me from.

Some Insurance policies protect against some frauds. However their wording is very specific and if they can get away without a payout they will.

Plenty of saying told to kids still apply in adult life.

Don't trust strangers.
Stranger danger
Ostatnio edytowany przez: Supafly; 28 września 2020 o 7:45
SmartRogue 28 września 2020 o 7:51 
Początkowo opublikowane przez Dead Monkey:

Check everything. It's basic safety.

Because Valve does not contact users like that. If I walked upto you and told you I was a Bank Employee and gave you a profile, bank card, link to the banks website would you believe me? If so you'd be in trouble. It's a scam. You need to not believe everything on the internet and in person.

That was no different to dodgy emails or me calling you on the phone and claiming to be from your bank. I could have raided your bin last night and got various details I could tell you to make you believe me. Yet, you still shouldn't trust me. I've disconnected from actual bank staff that called me because they want me to verify who I am when they won't verify who they are. I've then contacted bank using standard number to follow up about them calling me. Never by the number they called me from.

Some Insurance policies protect against some frauds. However their wording is very specific and if they can get away without a payout they will.

Plenty of saying told to kids still apply in adult life.

Don't trust strangers.
Stranger danger
There was another aspect of the scam I didn't tell you about. When I talked to them on Discord, they gave me video of going to my profile, highlighting my name and other parts of it and showing that they can delete my account. It was too realistic to say that it wasn't an actual Valve employee doing it. Also, it started off as a person saying that they "accidentally reported me" for scamming, so I thought I would straighten things out. It's only what a reasonable person would do, I thought. I was trying to be a good person and they took advantage of me for that. Some people are really the worst.
Crazy Tiger 28 września 2020 o 7:55 
Początkowo opublikowane przez Napalm:
Początkowo opublikowane przez Dead Monkey:

Check everything. It's basic safety.

Because Valve does not contact users like that. If I walked upto you and told you I was a Bank Employee and gave you a profile, bank card, link to the banks website would you believe me? If so you'd be in trouble. It's a scam. You need to not believe everything on the internet and in person.

That was no different to dodgy emails or me calling you on the phone and claiming to be from your bank. I could have raided your bin last night and got various details I could tell you to make you believe me. Yet, you still shouldn't trust me. I've disconnected from actual bank staff that called me because they want me to verify who I am when they won't verify who they are. I've then contacted bank using standard number to follow up about them calling me. Never by the number they called me from.

Some Insurance policies protect against some frauds. However their wording is very specific and if they can get away without a payout they will.

Plenty of saying told to kids still apply in adult life.

Don't trust strangers.
Stranger danger
There was another aspect of the scam I didn't tell you about. When I talked to them on Discord, they gave me video of going to my profile, highlighting my name and other parts of it and showing that they can delete my account. It was too realistic to say that it wasn't an actual Valve employee doing it. Also, it started off as a person saying that they "accidentally reported me" for scamming, so I thought I would straighten things out. It's only what a reasonable person would do, I thought. I was trying to be a good person and they took advantage of me for that. Some people are really the worst.
A respectable business doesn't operate like the way people do in the scam. Valve never contacts people directly for things. Anybody can link an account, what's to say it's actually theirs? Why would they use Discord? Why would they use such "hostage profile" tactics? And why would a Valve employee have to verify items that come from within the Steam economy/system?

Fraud is a thing, yes, but you don't have insurance on Steam. Valve does help, they help in recovering the account. They just don't offer the help you want and I'd advice you to not make such assumptions in the future.

You made a mistake, it can happen. Now learn from it.

However, no matter how much you keep posting here: Your items will not get returned. Harsh reality, yes, but better to accept it.
Supafly 28 września 2020 o 8:01 
Początkowo opublikowane przez Napalm:
There was another aspect of the scam I didn't tell you about. When I talked to them on Discord, they gave me video of going to my profile, highlighting my name and other parts of it and showing that they can delete my account. It was too realistic to say that it wasn't an actual Valve employee doing it. Also, it started off as a person saying that they "accidentally reported me" for scamming, so I thought I would straighten things out. It's only what a reasonable person would do, I thought. I was trying to be a good person and they took advantage of me for that. Some people are really the worst.

Discord? Why the hell would you believe someone from discord? Valve has their own platform they'd use. I wouldn't need anymore info than that to report and block them.

You ever watch TV? Everything can be faked. Don't believe everything you see or hear. You like if you get an email say this or that don't believe it. Believing everything someone shows you is going to get you scammed like mad. A decent scammer will take the effort to make something look official. It's up to you to check things. Always.


I reasonable person would ignore them. Reported for something you haven't done means nothing will happen. There is nothing for you to do. If I report Jack for killing Mary and will the Police just arrest and jail Jack? No. It'd be investigated and if no evidence he'd get released. The same here. Valve would investigate and as you haven't scammed someone nothing would happen.

It's common scam tactics. Not just for Steam but every walks of life. You've experienced it now so hopefully you learn to think things through and check facts before you act.
Tito Shivan 28 września 2020 o 8:25 
Początkowo opublikowane przez Napalm:
-snip
1. Returned items ARE taking part in the economy. As they're exact contra of the originals they can be trade and sold at the marketplace as their original counterparts.

2. Policies are made for people, not individuals. You might be a knowledgeable individual but there's other several hundred million Steam accounts out there.

3. The policy was a one time only item recovery. But that means several dozen million 'one time return' At a certain point there was 77.000 accounts being hijacked and stripped of their items. That's a lot of item duplications even if you do it only once.
nullable 28 września 2020 o 9:06 
Początkowo opublikowane przez Napalm:
There was another aspect of the scam I didn't tell you about. When I talked to them on Discord, they gave me video of going to my profile, highlighting my name and other parts of it and showing that they can delete my account. It was too realistic to say that it wasn't an actual Valve employee doing it.

Well aside from the bit where businesses don't typically taunt and threaten their users like that, and use fear to get the riled up and pliable... so they'll do as instructed.

I'm sure what you were shown looked convincing. But process-wise it makes no sense. Although it's well understood why you were blind to the latter detail because you were dazzled by the horror of the prospect of your account being deleted. Lots of people fall for it.

Also while you didn't divulge this detail previously it's a common facet anyone dealing with scam victims has seen a dozen dozen times before. I know it must add insult to injury to have been scammed and really have nothing new to add to the issue. But that's the state of things.

There's always going to be a huge group of users who won't take security seriously until it's too late. People love learning from experience. And they'll pay double for a pound of cure if it's an option, rather than an ounce of prevention. These are just things about human behavior that work in the scammers favor. And the one thing about people, we're always making more of them.

Początkowo opublikowane przez Napalm:
Also, it started off as a person saying that they "accidentally reported me" for scamming, so I thought I would straighten things out. It's only what a reasonable person would do, I thought. I was trying to be a good person and they took advantage of me for that. Some people are really the worst.

Scammers develop techniques that work extremely well on regular people, it's not just random nonsense they do on a whim. They take advantage of numerous weaknesses in human behavior. Without experience, expertise or training it can be hard to resist or be prepared for the circumstances a scam presents you.

Lesson one though is anything relying on fear or greed is extremely suspect.
Ostatnio edytowany przez: nullable; 28 września 2020 o 9:06
SmartRogue 28 września 2020 o 9:24 
Początkowo opublikowane przez Brockenstein:
Początkowo opublikowane przez Napalm:
There was another aspect of the scam I didn't tell you about. When I talked to them on Discord, they gave me video of going to my profile, highlighting my name and other parts of it and showing that they can delete my account. It was too realistic to say that it wasn't an actual Valve employee doing it.

Well aside from the bit where businesses don't typically taunt and threaten their users like that, and use fear to get the riled up and pliable... so they'll do as instructed.

I'm sure what you were shown looked convincing. But process-wise it makes no sense. Although it's well understood why you were blind to the latter detail because you were dazzled by the horror of the prospect of your account being deleted. Lots of people fall for it.

Also while you didn't divulge this detail previously it's a common facet anyone dealing with scam victims has seen a dozen dozen times before. I know it must add insult to injury to have been scammed and really have nothing new to add to the issue. But that's the state of things.

There's always going to be a huge group of users who won't take security seriously until it's too late. People love learning from experience. And they'll pay double for a pound of cure if it's an option, rather than an ounce of prevention. These are just things about human behavior that work in the scammers favor. And the one thing about people, we're always making more of them.

Początkowo opublikowane przez Napalm:
Also, it started off as a person saying that they "accidentally reported me" for scamming, so I thought I would straighten things out. It's only what a reasonable person would do, I thought. I was trying to be a good person and they took advantage of me for that. Some people are really the worst.

Scammers develop techniques that work extremely well on regular people, it's not just random nonsense they do on a whim. They take advantage of numerous weaknesses in human behavior. Without experience, expertise or training it can be hard to resist or be prepared for the circumstances a scam presents you.

Lesson one though is anything relying on fear or greed is extremely suspect.

So, what do I do now? I have to live through life being reminded that I was scammed and will never be made whole again? Do you have any idea how traumatizing that is?

This is what I feel like I am being told by everyone:
"Got your items scammed from you? And you have a list of those exact items that were taken from you? Too bad, you aren't going to get them back, no matter how much to cry or beg or kick or scream, you will NEVER see those items again, even though you spent hours and days getting them and paying us money to get them."
"Maybe you shouldn't have been so gullible!"
"Maybe you should have been more suspicious!"
"Maybe you should have been smarter!"
"Maybe you shouldn't have items people want to take from you!"
"Maybe you shouldn't have given others the benefit of the doubt!"
"Maybe you shouldn't have been so afraid of bad things happening to you!"
"No one here is on your side, the company is right for doing absolutely nothing for you!"
"The company got taken advantage of a long time ago, so they made this policy which pretty much screws over anyone who sincerely got their property taken from them!"

Honestly, sometimes I wish I were never born instead of having to be subjected to all of this on top of being scammed. What's the point of living if no one helps you after one's trust being destroyed. How can I trust anyone again? You all don't understand how mentally devastating this is to me. Sorry to have bothered all of you, you clearly have told me there isn't any point in fighting for my things.
Supafly 28 września 2020 o 9:32 
Początkowo opublikowane przez Napalm:

So, what do I do now? I have to live through life being reminded that I was scammed and will never be made whole again? Do you have any idea how traumatizing that is?

This is what I feel like I am being told by everyone:
"Got your items scammed from you? And you have a list of those exact items that were taken from you? Too bad, you aren't going to get them back, no matter how much to cry or beg or kick or scream, you will NEVER see those items again, even though you spent hours and days getting them and paying us money to get them."
"Maybe you shouldn't have been so gullible!"
"Maybe you should have been more suspicious!"
"Maybe you should have been smarter!"
"Maybe you shouldn't have items people want to take from you!"
"Maybe you shouldn't have given others the benefit of the doubt!"
"Maybe you shouldn't have been so afraid of bad things happening to you!"
"No one here is on your side, the company is right for doing absolutely nothing for you!"
"The company got taken advantage of a long time ago, so they made this policy which pretty much screws over anyone who sincerely got their property taken from them!"

Honestly, sometimes I wish I were never born instead of having to be subjected to all of this on top of being scammed. What's the point of living if no one helps you after one's trust being destroyed. How can I trust anyone again? You all don't understand how mentally devastating this is to me. Sorry to have bothered all of you, you clearly have told me there isn't any point in fighting for my things.

Well thats life. Whether you do everything right and safe or not ♥♥♥♥ happens.

It's up to you to treat your information and belongings safe.

No one can and will hold you hand through everything to ensure you don't get screwed over by something and reimburse you IF you do screw up.

Live and learn so if/when other scammers and ***** try in the future you'll be able to protect yourself.

We do understand what it's like. Some of those posting have been scammed or know others who have been scammed. Maybe not on Steam but scammers are everywhere and scams outside of Steam can be much much worse.
SmartRogue 28 września 2020 o 9:50 
Początkowo opublikowane przez Dead Monkey:

Well thats life.

That's life? That's Life??

I seriously think you are downplaying the problem I am having now.

I don't think of myself as a materialistic person, and honestly, I still don't think I am after all this. You all may think I am overly dramatic, but you can't simply ignore how strongly I feel about this. By denying me the ability to get these items back, it's essentially like denying my existence. It's denying the time I spent to get them. It's denying the fact that I used to own these things. It's denying the MEMORIES I had of having a good time playing the game. If I don't get these things back, one day, I am going to forget that I ever owned them along with the memories attached to them, and to me that is HORRIFYING. I don't want to forget such a large part of my life because some ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ thought they can make a profit and everyone saying nothing can be done about it. I want to be able to go back to my inventory one day and say "Oh yea, I remember when I did that" but right now I CAN'T and I am afraid that I never will. No amount of online security is going to protect me from my own mind after experiencing such a traumatic event.
< >
Wyświetlanie 16-30 z 96 komentarzy
Na stronę: 1530 50

Data napisania: 27 września 2020 o 18:29
Posty: 96