What are people's opinions on DEI in the gaming industry?

[Myrth the Plague]

PSA: THIS IS NOT AN INVITATION TO SPOUT POLITICAL NONSENSE OR HATE ANYONE! IF YOU POST IT YOU ARE NOT BEING PRODUCTIVE TO GOOD CONVERSATION AND DISCUSSION! BE RESPECTFUL AND OPEN TO HONEST PERSPECTIVES!

With that said I personally only learned of DEI recently as a organization recently. I will say DEI has very good goals and I appreciate what they are trying to do in the gaming industry. Unfortunately the implementation needs work. Here are some good examples of DEI in the gaming industry (personal opinion):
-The Last of US II
-Dragon Age: Inquisition
-Baldur's Gate 3
-Cyberpunk 2077
-Spider-Man 2

Here are some bad examples of DEI in the gaming industry (personal opinion):
-Concord
-Dragon Age: Veilguard
-Suicide Squad: Kill the Justice League
-Battlefield V
-Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2

I should note that all the games I believe have bad examples of DEI were not all commercial failures and those that were I don't exclusively blame DEI for their failure. I would also like to note that i don't believe the games i think are good examples of DEI in gaming were successful exclusively for DEI. DEI is always good to have in game but here are some good things to keep in mind when it is included; is it accurate historically, does it effect lore or continuity, does it take focus away from the story, and does it improve the character(s) and make them more interesting.
When making a historical based game or a semi realistic game DEI should fit in with the appropriate time. If a character/person/group have a certain belief, gender, ethnicity, or orientation in one title it makes little sense that in the next title for that to change unless given a reason that feels like it appropriately fits the lore.
DEI should never be the focus of a game, the game should be the focus of the game and nothing else when anything takes the focus away from the game whether it is graphics, characters, or mechanics (i.e. controls, handling, etc.) the game is typically doomed to fail due to the focus being on on the game but an aspect of the game.
Making a character the fits DEI for the sole purpose of checking a box is wrong and almost always backfires, the mindset of "we need to have (X) character to make (X) group happy" is a horrible mindset to have and often leads to lazy writing and overall a unlikable character or game, make a character who is awesome for who they are DEI is not a personality it is apart of that person a trait if you will.
These are my honest opinions but i'd like to hear what other people think of DEI in gaming. DEI is good but i personally think it needs some work before we see games that have consistently good DEI implementation.

[Komarimaru]

Nguyên văn bởi MonkehMaster:

Nguyên văn bởi Komarimaru:

Again, what games are getting federal funding? Disney sure isn't getting funding either, they don't need it.

Where are these games, that are getting federal funding?

https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/01/ending-radical-and-wasteful-government-dei-programs-and-preferencing/

im not going to sit here posting links to prove you wrong.

all businesses in the us can and do get federal funding to promote dei programs.

Then how come you can't name a single one that's not related to a government body?

[datCookie]

Nguyên văn bởi MonkehMaster:

Nguyên văn bởi Komarimaru:

Again, what games are getting federal funding? Disney sure isn't getting funding either, they don't need it.

Where are these games, that are getting federal funding?

https://thehill.com/media/5220384-disney-fcc-dei-investigation/

im not going to sit here posting links to prove you wrong.

all businesses in the us can and do get federal funding to promote dei programs.

Except this link only shows that Disney is being investigated for DEI policies, it doesn't mention anything about them receiving federal funding to promote DEI practices.

[Boblin the Goblin]

Nguyên văn bởi Komarimaru:

Nguyên văn bởi MonkehMaster:

https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/01/ending-radical-and-wasteful-government-dei-programs-and-preferencing/

im not going to sit here posting links to prove you wrong.

all businesses in the us can and do get federal funding to promote dei programs.

Then how come you can't name a single one that's not related to a government body?

We're having a repeat of the video aren't we?

[Komarimaru]

Nguyên văn bởi datCookie:

Nguyên văn bởi MonkehMaster:

https://thehill.com/media/5220384-disney-fcc-dei-investigation/

im not going to sit here posting links to prove you wrong.

all businesses in the us can and do get federal funding to promote dei programs.

Except this link only shows that Disney is being investigated for DEI policies, it doesn't mention anything about them receiving federal funding to promote DEI practices.

Oh, they changed the link. What in gods green earth made them think Disney of all companies was getting federal funding? lol.

[Komarimaru]

Nguyên văn bởi Boblin the Goblin:

Nguyên văn bởi Komarimaru:

Then how come you can't name a single one that's not related to a government body?

We're having a repeat of the video aren't we?

So it seems. Making things up to fit their agenda, posting evidence against themselves.

It's very disappointing to see. Someone focusing so much on one thing they really want, not paying attention to the details and only hooking into a tiny part they feel suites them, not realizing it's against them when just step back and see more of it.

[MonkehMaster]

Nguyên văn bởi datCookie:

Nguyên văn bởi MonkehMaster:

https://thehill.com/media/5220384-disney-fcc-dei-investigation/

im not going to sit here posting links to prove you wrong.

all businesses in the us can and do get federal funding to promote dei programs.

Except this link only shows that Disney is being investigated for DEI policies, it doesn't mention anything about them receiving federal funding to promote DEI practices.

it doesnt? sure looks like it to me.

The FCC last month launched a similar probe into Comcast, the parent company of NBCUniversal, over DEI concerns.

Letters that Carr sent to both companies note the FCC wants to ensure that the companies “are not promoting invidious forms of discrimination.”

Since President Trump took office in January, his administration has pushed to curb DEI efforts that swelled in government and private businesses in recent years. He signed executive orders to end DEI programs across federal agencies and pull federal funding from recipients, including colleges, that promote DEI.

In his letter to Disney, Carr wrote that the FCC’s enforcement arm would follow up with the company, which he suggested may have altered names of its DEI initiatives without changing policies.

according to some others though, im making things up, yet the gov is banning all this and defunding them nation wide lol.

[Komarimaru]

Nguyên văn bởi MonkehMaster:

Nguyên văn bởi datCookie:

Except this link only shows that Disney is being investigated for DEI policies, it doesn't mention anything about them receiving federal funding to promote DEI practices.

it doesnt?

The FCC last month launched a similar probe into Comcast, the parent company of NBCUniversal, over DEI concerns.

Letters that Carr sent to both companies note the FCC wants to ensure that the companies “are not promoting invidious forms of discrimination.”

Since President Trump took office in January, his administration has pushed to curb DEI efforts that swelled in government and private businesses in recent years. He signed executive orders to end DEI programs across federal agencies and pull federal funding from recipients, including colleges, that promote DEI.

In his letter to Disney, Carr wrote that the FCC’s enforcement arm would follow up with the company, which he suggested may have altered names of its DEI initiatives without changing policies.

And where in any of that, are tax payer dollars getting involved other than investigations that the government themselves are imposing on themselves?

That again, speaks against your very own claim.

[datCookie]

Nguyên văn bởi MonkehMaster:

Nguyên văn bởi datCookie:

Except this link only shows that Disney is being investigated for DEI policies, it doesn't mention anything about them receiving federal funding to promote DEI practices.

it doesnt?

The FCC last month launched a similar probe into Comcast, the parent company of NBCUniversal, over DEI concerns.

Letters that Carr sent to both companies note the FCC wants to ensure that the companies “are not promoting invidious forms of discrimination.”

Since President Trump took office in January, his administration has pushed to curb DEI efforts that swelled in government and private businesses in recent years. He signed executive orders to end DEI programs across federal agencies and pull federal funding from recipients, including colleges, that promote DEI.

In his letter to Disney, Carr wrote that the FCC’s enforcement arm would follow up with the company, which he suggested may have altered names of its DEI initiatives without changing policies.

No, it doesn't. No where in this article does it specify that Disney, or any game company for that matter, are receiving federal funding to support DEI programs. Just because a company is being investigated for DEI practices that the current administration is trying to outlaw, doesn't mean they were recipients of federal funding in relation to these practices.

[Amaterasu]

Nguyên văn bởi Komarimaru:

Nguyên văn bởi MonkehMaster:

it doesnt?

And where in any of that, are tax payer dollars getting involved other than investigations that the government themselves are imposing on themselves?

That again, speaks against your very own claim.

Or in other words, a colossal waste of funds. I thought Trump was supposed to fix the economy.

[MonkehMaster]

Nguyên văn bởi Komarimaru:

Nguyên văn bởi MonkehMaster:

it doesnt?

And where in any of that, are tax payer dollars getting involved other than investigations that the government themselves are imposing on themselves?

That again, speaks against your very own claim.

you were already answered...

Nguyên văn bởi MonkehMaster:

Nguyên văn bởi Komarimaru:

And where is all this funding? Since so far they've not found any government funding into any private company, especially related to DEI.

I've lived in the US for quite a long time, never seen anything you're supposedly claiming.

so you are claiming, the president didnt give executive orders ending federal funding for dei programs? lol...

https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/01/ending-radical-and-wasteful-government-dei-programs-and-preferencing/

you sure you live in the US?

our taxes fund these programs, well they did, not anymore.

Pursuant to Executive Order 13985 and follow-on orders, nearly every Federal agency and entity submitted “Equity Action Plans” to detail the ways that they have furthered DEIs infiltration of the Federal Government. The public release of these plans demonstrated immense public waste and shameful discrimination. That ends today. Americans deserve a government committed to serving every person with equal dignity and respect, and to expending precious taxpayer resources only on making America great.

seriously..

[datCookie]

Nguyên văn bởi MonkehMaster:

Pursuant to Executive Order 13985 and follow-on orders, nearly every Federal agency and entity submitted “Equity Action Plans” to detail the ways that they have furthered DEIs infiltration of the Federal Government. The public release of these plans demonstrated immense public waste and shameful discrimination. That ends today. Americans deserve a government committed to serving every person with equal dignity and respect, and to expending precious taxpayer resources only on making America great.

seriously..

"Taxpayer resources" are in reference to the federal funding these federal programs have been receiving, as well as any other company that has received federal funding.

You are continuously failing to show where Disney, let alone a single game company, are receiving federal funding...

[Komarimaru]

Nguyên văn bởi MonkehMaster:

Nguyên văn bởi Komarimaru:

And where in any of that, are tax payer dollars getting involved other than investigations that the government themselves are imposing on themselves?

That again, speaks against your very own claim.

you were already answered...

Nguyên văn bởi MonkehMaster:

so you are claiming, the president didnt give executive orders ending federal funding for dei programs? lol...

https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/01/ending-radical-and-wasteful-government-dei-programs-and-preferencing/

you sure you live in the US?

our taxes fund these programs, well they did, not anymore.

Pursuant to Executive Order 13985 and follow-on orders, nearly every Federal agency and entity submitted “Equity Action Plans” to detail the ways that they have furthered DEIs infiltration of the Federal Government. The public release of these plans demonstrated immense public waste and shameful discrimination. That ends today. Americans deserve a government committed to serving every person with equal dignity and respect, and to expending precious taxpayer resources only on making America great.

seriously..

Hey, read what you post. No one was getting funding... No private company was...

Reading the very things you post, would clearly elevate your understanding in that this only affects the government and bodies related to it.

The only reason Disney is being investigated, if you bothered to read the hyperlink in the article, is because some felt there may have been a breaking of the equality laws by forcing DEI, if it can be proven, limiting eligible hires due to said DEI policies in the company.

Guess what? None of that is government funding.

Now, where are these government funded games at? Still waiting on those now that we've established your Disney article was you simply misunderstanding things.

[MonkehMaster]

even googles crappy ai search knows about some of the dei funding.

all common knowledge.

AI Overview
A DEI grant, short for Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion grant, is funding aimed at supporting projects and initiatives focused on promoting diversity, equity, and inclusion within an organization, community, or field.
Here's a more detailed explanation:

What it is:
DEI grants are financial resources allocated to organizations or individuals to implement programs, conduct research, or engage in activities that advance diversity, equity, and inclusion.

Why they exist:
These grants recognize the importance of creating inclusive environments and addressing systemic inequalities, promoting a more equitable and just society.
Examples of DEI grant activities:

Educational initiatives: Training programs, workshops, and resources to promote understanding and awareness of diversity and inclusion.

Research projects: Studies focused on understanding and addressing issues related to diversity, equity, and inclusion.
Community programs: Initiatives that connect people from diverse backgrounds, foster dialogue, and build relationships.
Capacity-building: Supporting organizations to develop their DEI strategies and implement effective programs.

Who funds them:
DEI grants can come from various sources, including foundations, government agencies, corporations, and individual donors.
Examples of DEI grant programs:

AANA Foundation DEI Initiative Grant: Supports education efforts and increases diversity within the nurse anesthesia profession.

POD Network DEI Educational Development Mini-Grants and Collaborative Grants: Provides seed funding for educational developers from underrepresented groups or institutions.
Tri Sigma Foundation DEI Community Grants: Supports creative, innovative, and grassroots efforts to promote equity and diversity.
CSUN Diversity & Equity Innovation Grant: Supports educational projects, scholarly research, creative activities, and other innovative programmatic initiatives that promote social justice, equity, diversity, inclusion, accessibility, anti-racism, and belonging for the CSUN community.
SABA Innovative Student Research Grant in Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion: Supports graduate-level study of issues relevant to diversity, equity, and inclusion in behavior analysis.

AI Overview
Learn more
Yes, federal grants are funded by tax money, specifically through income tax revenues, and are awarded to fund specific projects or programs.
Here's a more detailed explanation:

Funding Source:
Federal grants are financed through the federal government's budget, which is primarily funded by tax revenues (like income tax, payroll tax, and corporate tax).

Purpose:
These grants are intended to support various programs and initiatives, including healthcare, income security, transportation, education, and social services.
Grant Recipients:
Federal grants can be awarded to state, local, and municipal governments, as well as organizations, including universities and non-profit organizations.
No Repayment Required:
Unlike loans, federal grants are not loans and therefore do not require repayment.
Examples:
Some examples of federal grants include Pell Grants for education, IRS VITA and TCE grants for tax assistance, and grants for research and development.
Taxable Income:
In most cases, the funds from grant awards are considered taxable income, unless there is a specific statute that exempts the program from taxation.

Tax Issues for Grants - Farmers.gov
In most cases, the funds from grant awards are taxable income. ... Proceeds from grants are taxable unless there is a specific sta...Farmers.gov

Are Business Grants Taxable? - Investopedia
There are some important exceptions to this rule, however: Nonprofit organizations with 501(c)(3) status are generally tax-exempt,
Investopedia
CARES Act Coronavirus Relief Fund frequently asked questions - IRS
Dec 5, 2024 — Q. If governments use Fund payments as described in the Fund Guidance to establish a grant program to support businesse...IRS (.gov)

Show all

Generative AI is experimental. For financial advice, consult a professional.

[Midnight Sky ✨🌙✨]

Nguyên văn bởi D. Flame:

But look at what they did to Bridget, they ignored all of his character development over decades to force him into a trans checkmark, because the non-binary, cross dressing checkmark was less marketable.

Not the person with "They/them" on their profile misgendering. 😭😭😭

Anyway, no. Bridget did not have her character development walked back, she learned and grew further. Plenty of trans people try to force themselves to live how they think they're supposed to like Bridget trying to prove she was a man because, outside of her village, that's what she felt was expected.

Nguyên văn bởi D. Flame:

Bridget had been an icon for cross dressing and non-binary community for decades, and these consultation groups ripped that away. Well, at least Ferris is still around.

I can't imagine the overlap of people who hate Bridget being trans and nb folks being all that large.

And no, "consultants" didn't take away Bridget, her being trans was always the plan.[boundingintocomics.com]

Met with the interviewer’s appraisal that “Awareness of transgender people is much more prevalent now, and so in a way, it’s like the times have finally caught up with the story you wrote for Bridget all those years ago,” Ishiwatari laughed, “That’s a much cooler way to say it, but I had a strong feeling of now being the time when I can finally properly express this.”

In support of the creator’s claim of original intent, Katano asserted, “Every single character has details and story that Ishiwatari came up with in advance, and for a lot of those it’s a matter of we just haven’t used them yet. I think with Bridget, it’s really just that.”

[Komarimaru]

Ok, and yet you cannot post who got said grants? Funny using AI to support yourself, without it being able to give you examples related to gaming etc.