The Witcher 3 or Red Dead Redmption and why?

[quanta]

no more to say it's up there.

[mike]

red dead redemption as it has a very good story








i love you

[Jaunitta 🌸]

These 2 games cannot be compared. Like all these epic games they are all brilliant and effort rewwards.
Only accept opinions from those who have played both.
Witch3 wild hunt is amazing and the Travelling around the map to the Vikings era to the fantasy lands it has it all. Sailing ships the fighting the solving fo family feuds.
The stories side quests can be found on the towns news board the exploring the graphics the cities we can walk through.
But get the 2 DLC as well. You will never be sorry. Best game ever in my opion and will always be my favourite.

RDR2 is more a western with many missions from strangers dont play online MP as its riddled with internet problems and hackers.
also it takes a while to get used to M&K as the gamne was designed for controller and those descriptions are still used .
I am really liking this game it does have some exellent missions and funny things ingame that will surprise you but it doesnt capture me like Witcher 3 did.
The order I would recomend playing them.
Is Witcher 3 Wild Hunt
then
Kingdom Come Delieverence
Then RDR2.
Buy a 2nd HDD and move installations to USB you going to need the space as each has a large download especially RDR 2 is 115 gig.
haha check this, cant believe these actually exist

YouTube™ Video: The Witcher 3 Vs Red Dead Redemption 2, The Battle of Giants 

Views: 82,541

Red Dead Redemption 2 from Rockstar Games is a great wild west experience. But when we think of RDR2, other great RPGs come to our minds naturally specially The Witcher 3 hailed as one of the best...

[shiel]

Both. If you can't play both, then pick based on the setting you'd rather right now.

[Electric Cupcake]

CD Projeckt Red menschen vs. Rockstar n'wahs.

No contest on the face of it.

[Your Mom's Oshi]

They're both good games. Just pick based on what setting is more interesting to you.

[Ⓥenom Ⓢnake 🐍]

Do you want to be a magic sword wizard or do you want to be at cowboy.

My vote is cowboy, and like Red Dead Redemption Red Dead Redemption 2 is amazing for being a cowboy.

[Daxank]

I like both games
Witcher 3 if you want to go deep into modding
Red Dead Redemption 2 if you don't care about modding much and want to play it multiplayer too

[BossGalaga]

Originally posted by xLeez .:

The Witcher 3 or Red Dead Redmption and why?
no more to say it's up there.

Do you want to be a brooding fantasy warrior dood or a brooding gunslinging cowboy dood?

[Arvaos]

In terms of the main storyline and voice acting, Red Dead Redemption 2 wins.

When it comes to side quests and dialogue, The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt wins due to the non-linearity of the every quest and the multiple outcomes that can be had with each playthrough.

As for gameplay? Red Dead Redemption 2 by miles. The animations, responses, physics are much better due to Rockstar having worked on the Rage Engine for many years now.

Exploration is also incredible in Red Dead Redemption 2 with many random stranger events and appearances which can happen anywhere on the map. The world is incredibly detailed and each area is unique with different states.

I would say Red Dead Redemption 2.

[Vixus]

Both are ♥♥♥♥
Buy Hunt Down the Freeman

[🦜Cloud Boy🦜]

if you like shooter games, RDR2
if you like melee combat sword fighting game, Witcher

[shiel]

Originally posted by Vixus:

Both are ♥♥♥♥
Buy Hunt Down the Freeman

*looks at profile*
Yeah, that's about what I expected.

Originally posted by ⎛⎝ Cloud Boy ⎠⎞:

if you like shooter games, RDR2
if you like melee combat sword fighting game, Witcher

Disagree. Neither is tops in those categories. It more comes down to setting. Sometimes I'm feeling the western style and sometimes I'm feeling the fantasy style. There's no better choice than those two games imo for either category(although I have a serious soft spot for Dragon Age Origins).

[/.]

That's like asking what's the best pizza you've ever had vs the best burger you've ever had.

Both are delicious, it just depends on what you're in the mood for.

The real question is... Which is the burger and which is the pizza?

[quanta]

TY you all <3

[friend robocat]

which has the drm

pick the one without drm